-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Talic
LOL. Yeah, OK. Now look at the pompous one. "pretty good records" don't change the "could have, should have, would have" to what DID happen.
Your bet with Murska in previous threads came back to bite you. No matter what role you were in THIS game, you Would have been lynched day one, or night killed day 2. Just like you were.
Unless you were a wolf. But then, Murska wouldn't have started the wagon on you.
Keep arguing your maybes. I'm telling you what happened, and short of being a wolf, that's exactly what Would have happened.
Does that have any impact on your skill as a player? No. It's just the way it breaks.
Now get over yourself. I'm done here.
Well, thank you, your opinion have been noted.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
happyturtle
If you were all that familiar with my werewolf reputation you'd know I have a pretty good record of getting people lynched that I want lynched.
So yeah, I would have gotten you lynched. Not could have. Would have.
Just take a look at how she ran things in SEU.
*fondly remembers the claw bursting through his chest*
Ah...that was the best time I've ever been manipulated. :smallbiggrin:
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
I've already said, I'm not denying she's a good player, even one of the best. I'm saying that she's arguing an absolute certainty.
I'm trying to say yeah, good game. I don't think it's easy though, when Happy is going all "good game" out of one side of her mouth, and criticizing my play style in the same breath, saying how if the great happy was there, the day would have been saved.
There's a lot of variables, with over a dozen people trying to manipulate. There's a big difference between saying it's a possibility, like I said, and a certainty, like she did. What she's doing is arrogant, and frankly, the mark of a sore loser. And I don't much appreciate it.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Talic
I've already said, I'm not denying she's a good player, even one of the best. I'm saying that she's arguing an absolute certainty.
I'm trying to say yeah, good game. I don't think it's easy though, when Happy is going all "good game" out of one side of her mouth, and criticizing my play style in the same breath, saying how if the great happy was there, the day would have been saved.
There's a lot of variables, with over a dozen people trying to manipulate. There's a big difference between saying it's a possibility, like I said, and a certainty, like she did. What she's doing is arrogant, and frankly, the mark of a sore loser. And I don't much appreciate it.
Talic... you are overreacting, a lot.
You have been making dozens of posts based on what? One singel comment you thought were "arrogant"? Please, I have seen way more arrogant comments in WW games and leaved it to that, not bashing away whoever made the comment.
She have for petes sake already said you won the argument, yet you continue bashing her? Why?
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
EVERYONE calm down. Prefarably by not posting about the matter at all, ever. It won't make it any better. :smallannoyed:
Yes, the wolves played a good game. Yes, the villagers were weaker than the wolf team from the start. Yes, the almost-perfect start in the beginning pretty much crushed the villagers' chances. Yes, Talic played admirably to keep the villagers from ever regaining a glimmer of hope. Yes, Happy and probably many others who were following the game probably had hunches and suspicions about people who were wolves. Yes, if they had been in the game, they might've been able to turn it around. No, regardless of all this, there's no reason to argue.
It's just a game.
@V There is nothing worth arguing here. See the sentence directly above.
This is not the argument you're looking for.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Murska
EVERYONE calm down. Prefarably by not posting about the matter at all, ever. It won't make it any better. :smallannoyed:
Yes, the wolves played a good game. Yes, the villagers were weaker than the wolf team from the start. Yes, the almost-perfect start in the beginning pretty much crushed the villagers' chances. Yes, Talic played admirably to keep the villagers from ever regaining a glimmer of hope. Yes, Happy and probably many others who were following the game probably had hunches and suspicions about people who were wolves. Yes, if they had been in the game, they might've been able to turn it around. No, regardless of all this, there's no reason to argue.
It's just a game.
Exactly what I was trying to say. There were a few disagreements, however, over particulars of probability.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Reinholdt
I still have yet to play in a game where the neutrals don't join the wolf team, though. :smalltongue:
Well, It's your fault for not signing into FSN :smallamused:
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
1. How did you like the game?
I had fun. Always nice being backstabbed by dad. :smallbiggrin: Good times!
2. What did you think of the narrations?
Nicely done.
3. Did the narrator(s) do a good job?
Yes
4. Was the game balanced?
No, but that's already been addressed
5. Any complaints?
Yes. I hate being the seer! Third time I've been the frikkin seer/fool! I've only been a wolf four times.
However, if roles were randomly generated, then I guess it's just one of those weird things, like Trixie being a mason or Murska being a wolf. If they weren't random, then... grrr!
6. Would you play again?
Probably
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
happyturtle
5. Any complaints?
Yes. I hate being the seer! Third time I've been the frikkin seer/fool! I've only been a wolf four times.
However, if roles were randomly generated, then I guess it's just one of those weird things, like Trixie being a mason or Murska being a wolf. If they weren't random, then... grrr!
How is been seer a bad thing? I've never been seer once in 50+ games :smalltongue:
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Loved it, had fun, great narration.
And I don't think it was unbalanced, I just think that we had two HUGE losses on the first two nights. And we were fighting an uphill battle after that - one that became impossible to win. Oh well.
I just wish I'd been around on the last 2 days to defend myself and maybe give us one more chance. :smallamused:
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
I don't think the game was that unbalanced, the wolves just did an amazing game. I would play again for sure, my one gripe is that there was essentially no collaboration between the police at all.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fleeing Coward
How is been seer a bad thing? I've never been seer once in 50+ games :smalltongue:
I'm too noisy a player to hide well. I talk to too many people, both in thread and privately. That's why villager is my favourite role.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Um, confession time. The roles where only partly random. For the roles of baner, seer, and alpha, I personally picked. The other roles were given out by drawning them out of a hat.
Sorry HappyTurtle, I didn't know.
editv Thank you
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Is okay. I forgive you. :smallsmile:
"All I Ask of You" is one of the songs on our wedding CD. It's such a great musical, and you did a good job making a game of it.
But it really is best to go random. Especially if you narrate again, you don't want people trying to guess the power roles based on out of game factors.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Fleeing Coward
How is been seer a bad thing? I've never been seer once in 50+ games :smalltongue:
I've only been seer once, but it pretty much guarantees you have to hide for team villagers sake. Which can be boring and sometimes difficult.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
happyturtle
I'm too noisy a player to hide well. I talk to too many people, both in thread and privately. That's why villager is my favourite role.
I prefer normal wolf for that exact reason. Of course, Alpha was fun aswell in Mirrodin... :smallwink:
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
ThePhantom
Um, confession time. The roles where only partly random. For the roles of baner, seer, and alpha, I personally picked. The other roles were given out by drawning them out of a hat.
Sorry HappyTurtle, I didn't know.
editv Thank you
I was personally picked out to be the Alpha?
Wow.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Darkcomet
I was personally picked out to be the Alpha?
Wow.
It was a kind of thank you for chosing to stay in my game, when I was worried about if I would have enough people.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Ah. Well, that certainly explains that line you had at the end of the role PM. :smalltongue:
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Well, I must say I enjoyed the game as a whole. [Of course I didn't like the fact that we couldn't find more than one wolfie :smalltongue:]
Anyway, great game, better narrative, and of course, great players.
Darkcomet, you rock my socks at playing.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Crimmy
Well, I must say I enjoyed the game as a whole. [Of course I didn't like the fact that we couldn't find more than one wolfie :smalltongue:]
Anyway, great game, better narrative, and of course, great players.
Darkcomet, you rock my socks at playing.
Eh?
But I didn't do much of anything.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
And that, of course, led to believe that you were nothing.
I must say, the defense rests.
-
Re: Phantom of the Opera Werewolf - Game Thread
I feel bad that I didn't pay much attention to this game until it was too late
Sorry :smallfrown: