Re: Number of Turns / Review
Thank you for doing that.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
As far as I can tell, Jillian didn't fly off to Transylvito. She met the Transylvito forces somewhere in the field, probably at the same hex where they faced Stanley.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Nice. Just one thing, to make things less confusing better call them days, and then split those into each side's turn.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
hope that looks better :tongue:
Re: Number of Turns / Review
@DevilDan
I'm not sure exactly, but Jillian was at Transylvtian(or atlease with Vinny when they talked to the Don.) if you see this page on panal 3,4 and 8, you see Jillian in the background.
Not exactly whos turn that was, or what I'm just assuming at this point
besides it wasn't suppose to be a good review or what not, i'm just procrastinating on more important stuff. :smallsmile:
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pebot
@DevilDan
I'm not sure exactly, but Jillian was at Transylvtian(or atlease with Vinny when they talked to the Don. if you see
this page on panal 3,4 and 8, you see Jillian in the background.
Not exactly whos turn that was, or what I'm just assuming at this point
I don't know whose turn it was, but the figure with Don King was the thinkamancer allowing him to communicate with Vinny; Don King's in his throne room while Vinny is clearly out in the field.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
There's a problem here. In day two you put Jillian's turn before Stanley. Now we know from day one that Jillian was on Ansom's turn (she had move left). Now either we are missing a day (Jill sleeps in the forest before Wanda going to the MK?) or this is a booper.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Quote:
Originally Posted by
teratorn
There's a problem here. In day two you put Jillian's turn before Stanley. Now we know from day one that Jillian was on Ansom's turn (she had move left). Now either we are missing a day (Jill sleeps in the forest before Wanda going to the MK?) or this is a booper.
I think its a booper, it would e odd for Jillian to break her alliance with Ansom just so she could scout for him. Tough it is possible.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Some things you should add
Webinar croaks spidew patrol.
Jillian croaks twoll scout, reports via hat.
Jillian and Webinar threaten each other.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
For Jillian's turn I don't know, in the comic she leaves at dawn, and it has to be before Stanly's turn because Stanly captures her.
I have a guess, that she is a barbadian and can take her turn whenever she wants, but that is a large assumption.
The idea that she unallied with Ansom is a good possibility though.
and yeah, DevilDan your right I'm wrong, I never noticed that. that makes a lot more sense !
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pebot
For Jillian's turn I don't know, in the comic she leaves at dawn, and it has to be before Stanly's turn because Stanly captures her.
I don't see any indication that she leaves at dawn; it's simpler to assume that she leaves when Ansom's turn starts.
As for her capture, that happened after her side's turn ended while she was still out scouting.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
I'm pretty sure you're off by a day.
On day 1, ansom said that the rest of the column would arrive in two turns.
http://www.giantitp.com/comics/erf0008.html
This leaves the possibility that nothing major happened in Stanley's camp that next day, and the jillian went scouting on Ansom's turn. The following day, (day 3) everything else on your day 2 happens, and all of the rest of your turns are off by one.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
I see... either we skipped a whole turn of GK action (that is, it passed unseen) or Gillian split off ahead of GK's turn, as a barbarian. Certainly she must have left before GK's turn because she "ended turn" before the turn in which Stanley captured her.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Quote:
Originally Posted by
SteveMB
But after her side's turn end comes the night, and only after that Stanley's turn. And I don't understand the point about move if she was going to sleep away from the column.
The only way for this to make sense would be for her to be captured during her turn, and only transferred to GK in the morning, during GK's turn.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Quote:
Originally Posted by
teratorn
But after her side's turn end comes the night, and only after that Stanley's turn. And I don't understand the point about move if she was going to sleep away from the column.
The only way for this to make sense would be for her to be captured during her turn, and only transferred to GK in the morning, during GK's turn.
Because Stanley claims that he actively went after her, we can only assume that the capture occurred during GK's turn. (Sure, he could be lying, but he doesn't need to lie to feed his own ego. He can attribute even the greatest stroke of luck or providence to his own skills or to the will of the Titans.)
Either we passed an entire GK turn without seeing any of the action or Jill got her own turn. The more I think about it, the likelier it seems that she split off from the coalition (though we don't understand the mechanism) and that her turn began before GK's turn. Then Stanley "pulled together" a group of dwagons--he knew exactly where she was thanks to the Eyemancers--and captured her. Webinar set out during the coalition turn. Every group (well, Charlescomm and Transylvito) that has joined the conflict has gotten a turn preceding GK and the RCC. This would put Jill's hypothetical barbarian turn in the right spot, chronologically.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
So I liked the idea that we "miss" a turn for Stanly because Ansom did say the the other elfs would take 2 turns to get there, so I set it up that Jillian moves on Ansom's turn. then the next turn Stanly captures Jillian, and then Webinar is sent out to help Jillian. and then finds the items.
the problem I have with this is that, Jillian says the her gwiffin has 52 move, with the Orly reduces by 8 (making it 44) that would have to assume that Webinar was able to move 44 during Ansom's turn.
I'm not sure exactly what happened, but I set it up to miss a turn, again I do enjoy the criticism do keep it coming. ( wasn't planing on it to be a big deal but I enjoy the comments)
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pebot
So I liked the idea that we "miss" a turn for Stanly because Ansom did say the the other elfs would take 2 turns to get there, so I set it up that Jillian moves on Ansom's turn. then the next turn Stanly captures Jillian, and then Webinar is sent out to help Jillian. and then finds the items.
the problem I have with this is that, Jillian says the her gwiffin has 52 move, with the Orly reduces by 8 (making it 44) that would have to assume that Webinar was able to move 44 during Ansom's turn.
I'm not sure exactly what happened, but I set it up to miss a turn, again I do enjoy the criticism do keep it coming. ( wasn't planing on it to be a big deal but I enjoy the comments)
If she was scouting she wouldn't have followed a straight line (yes, not convincing but feasible.)
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Day 3: Jillian was captured on Stanley's turn, not Ansom's.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Quote:
If she was scouting she wouldn't have followed a straight line (yes, not convincing but feasible.)
I like it. it is feasible which is enough
and yes, i set it so that jillian was captured during stanly's turn, it's just which turn it was is the question we are asking.
Re: Number of Turns / Review
Quote:
Originally Posted by
Pebot
I like it. it is feasible which is enough
and yes, i set it so that jillian was captured during stanly's turn, it's just which turn it was is the question we are asking.
We'll never know until the "Gods" reveal to us either that Jillian got her own pre-GK turn as a barbarian or that there was an un-chronicled Gk turn.