Quote Originally Posted by Gillric View Post
This particular player took a risk on rolling stats as it is quite possible to end up with less than point buy or even balanced stats that don't have the two high stats you get from point buy (this is a big issue with 4E). By forcing him to change to point buy you are only punishing him when he took a risk and happened to get lucky.
Rule of thumb: Players who are diehard rolling enthusiasts make their own "luck" through multiple rerolls, be it mulliganing on their current set or outright disregarding low dice. When you're able to discard the results of your bad luck, there's no risk to rollers.

I don't think Tukka's players are intentionally trying to game the system, so much as they're enjoying the results of the times they rolled well. Still, it's worth it to bring the subject up before game next time, and put it to a vote whether players want everybody to use point-buy or everybody to roll. It shouldn't be too hard for either side to adjust their character's stats to the appropriate method.