Quote Originally Posted by etrpgb View Post
You has been more restrictive than me (for example I set Cleave as useful), but I assume we agree on the main point.
Yeah, Cleave may be in wrong category, but eh.

Quote Originally Posted by etrpgb View Post
I miss the point of the Fighter... isn't the opposite? Bad feats meant bad Fighter?
The feats suck because fighter gets so many of them. Think Spring Attack chain, Weapon Focus/Specialization chain, and so forth and so forth. They can't have been designed on the assumption that you get 7 of them over your entire career. No, the designers thought "hey, fighters get a huge bunch of these", and went from there.