Threads like this are what we call "morally justified" threads around here, as in "Were Redcloak's actions morally justified?" We tend to lock them before they spiral into an angry debate about personal relative ethics. Note that the very first response has already violated the board's rules prohibiting discussing real world historical/political events.
By the D&D rules, Redcloak is Evil. Anything else is a personal moral judgment best discussed among your friends or family members.
Thread locked, per indefinite moratorium on "morally justified" threads.