Coanacoch takes what he needs to requisition. Everything taken from provisions/ armory will be marked "***" for return later. Obvious consumables (candles, food, whatever) will, of course, not be returned unless there are leftovers.
Spoiler
Show
3 javelins, 1 handaxe, backpack, bedroll, flint & steel, waterskin, 5 days rations, 2 torches, 50' silk rope