"You have failed in your duty as a paladin, Starfire. Because of your thoughtlessness, you have endangered the world more than you know. I offer you but one chance to redeem yourself: Follow into the fire and face your mistake, or lay here as a spirit for eternity to consider what you have wrought.
Decide quickly, for I move now to clean up your mess." True to his word, Dawnstrider begins moving further, deeper.
"Oh! Um. Hi. Err..."All right, then! Come along!"
The tunnels grew hotter and hotter until the pair reached the chamber with the bound Obsididan Flare, lying among magma fissures.
"Ah, surface ponies. You have returned sooner than I expected. Tell me, have you come to a decision yet?"
What decision should we have made, exactly?"
He takes out the rest of his rope and makes a lasso.
"HEY! You flying, ungraceful turd...
Isn't it clear yet, haven't you heard?
You and your stupid, ineffectual boss
Are already failing, 'cause you've already lost!" He uses the rhyme with a bit of extra push to broadcast 'I'm a huge threat AND I'm insulting your master...doesn't that make you stunned with indignance?'
And then he tosses the lasso around his wings.
(tl;dr - Daniel rhymes to make the acrobat stop momentarily and tosses the rope around him to drag him down once he does...if he does.)