Quote Originally Posted by Kato View Post
Hasn't this debate happened three times already? Not to pick it up in its entirety but in short... Logia users don't dodge attacks with seastone (at least not the way they do with normal attacks). Luffy was susceptible to Smoker's seastone weapon, even though it was blunt.
Water is not seastone, albeit the effects are similar but not identical.
I never said Luffy wasn't susceptible to smoker's seastone. Just that the seastone didn't turn off his rubber, it made him weak. Seastone has always made the user too exhausted to move when in direct contact.