I saw it yesterday, and I liked it a lot, far more than I was expecting to. Most everyone was well cast, the action scenes were pretty cool, some of the references made me laugh (a Futurama reference in Star Trek? Is the universe inside out?), and it was pretty cool in general.

There were a couple of things that bugged me though:
Quote Originally Posted by Swordguy View Post
...the scale of the engineering spaces, for example, are almost certainly too large to actually fit within the ship, given the scale of the windows and the depth of the shuttlebay...
Right from the very first scene with the Kelven, I was thinking this. However, it has absolutely no impact on how good the film is.
How advanced the evil mining behemoth was bugged me as well, until I read this thread and realised it was actually from 150 years in the future, which kinda explained everything...