How about you instead have a list of comic makers who sign-up for a review on their webcomic and what they want you to review on. (i.e. Artwork, story, etc.) That way, the mods can't infract you because the artists gave consent. Plus, you should critique on instead of what's bad, on what needs improvement on, and offer suggestions.
Does that work?
I agree with this. If you make constructive critics instead of offensive ones you will be fine.
by the way...
I've edited all my posts on the last index thread to:
>>>>>Please read the last post<<<<<
Would be awesome if you guys could do the same. The last post is pointing towards this thread.