Like a part of the Farmpunk world from the Wrong side of the Tracks? That could get creepy. I also see a Paladin-esque class, or maybe a Hobo-esque class that roams the boarder-tracks Keeping the Creepy on the Creepy side, and the Non-Creepy on the Non-Creepy side.
Barbarian-esque Loggers... this sort of setting would be fantastic.
It would be based on DnD 3.5, yes?
Or it's own system?
Heh. You could also apply the trope that only children or the drunk and crazy can see certain kinds of supernatural things. Yes, that's why hobos always carry moonshine in this setting.