Results 1 to 30 of 213
Thread: The Discussion Thread Index II

20090131, 11:48 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
The Discussion Thread Index II
When I first started spending time around the forum, I came across The Discussion Thread Index, an index of all discussion threads on the OOTS comics. I thought it was an excellent idea, and I enjoyed reading through old discussion topics to see what people had to say. Sadly, the original topic has gone unupdated for over a year.
I decided to revive the idea with my own topic! Enjoy, and please point out any mistakes you find. All credit goes to atteSmythe for coming up with this excellent idea.
If the text is red, that means the discussion thread has been deleted.
PrintOnly Books
Discussion for Start of Darkness
Discussion for Snips, Snails, & Dragon Tales
Misc.
Kickstarter Bonus PDFs Discussion Thread
Monthly Discussion Threads
Discussion for #1 to #55
Discussion for #56 to #62
Discussion for #63 to #74
Discussion for #75 to #82
Discussion for #83 to #91
Discussion for #92 to #99
Discussion for #100 to #107
Discussion for #108 to #116
Discussion for #117 to #124
Discussion for #125 to #133
Discussion for #134 to #144
Discussion for #145 to #152
Discussion for #153 to #162
Discussion for #163 to #175
Discussion for #176 to #187
Biweekly Discussion Threads
Discussion for #188 to #193
Discussion for #194 to #197
Discussion for #198 to #202
Discussion for #203 to #208
Discussion for #209 to #215
Discussion for #216 to #221
Individual Discussion Threads
Discussion for #222
Discussion for #223
Discussion for #224
Discussion for #225
Discussion for #226
Biweekly Discussion Threads
Discussion for #227 to #232
Discussion for #233 to #239
Discussion for #240 to #246
Discussion for #247 to #251
Individual Discussion Threads
Discussion for #252
Discussion for #253
Discussion for #254
Discussion for #255
Discussion for #256
Discussion for #257
Discussion for #258
Discussion for #259
Discussion for #260
Discussion for #261
Discussion for #262
Discussion for #263
Discussion for #264
Discussion for #265
Discussion for #266
Discussion for #267
Discussion for #268
Discussion for #269
Discussion for #270
Discussion for #271
Discussion for #272
Discussion for #273
Discussion for #274
Discussion for #275
Discussion for #276
Discussion for #277
Discussion for #278
Discussion for #279
Discussion for #280
Discussion for #281
Discussion for #282
Discussion for #283
Discussion for #284
Discussion for #285
Discussion for #286
Discussion for #287
Discussion for #288
Discussion for #289
Discussion for #290
Discussion for #291
Discussion for #292
Discussion for #293
Discussion for #294
Discussion for #295
Discussion for #296
Discussion for #297
Discussion for #298
Discussion for #299
Discussion for #300
Discussion for #301
Discussion for #302
Discussion for #303
Discussion for #304
Discussion for #305
Discussion for #306
Discussion for #307
Discussion for #308
Discussion for #309
Discussion for #310
Discussion for #311
Discussion for #312
Discussion for #313
Discussion for #314
Discussion for #315
Discussion for #316
Discussion for #317
Discussion for #318
Discussion for #319
Discussion for #320
Discussion for #321
Discussion for #322
Discussion for #323
Discussion for #324
Discussion for #325
Discussion for #326
Discussion for #327
Discussion for #328
Discussion for #329
Discussion for #330
Discussion for #331
Discussion for #332
Discussion for #333
Discussion for #334
Discussion for #335
Discussion for #336
Discussion for #337
Discussion for #338
Discussion for #339
Discussion for #340
Discussion for #341
Discussion for #342
Discussion for #343
Discussion for #344
Discussion for #345
Discussion for #346
Discussion for #347
Discussion for #348
Discussion for #349
Discussion for #350
Discussion for #351
Discussion for #352
Discussion for #353
Discussion for #354
Discussion for #355
Discussion for #356
Discussion for #357
Discussion for #358
Discussion for #359
Discussion for #360
Discussion for #361
Discussion for #362
Discussion for #363 to #365
Discussion for #366
Discussion for #367
Discussion for #368
Discussion for #369
Discussion for #370
Discussion for #371
Discussion for #372
Discussion for #373
Discussion for #374
Discussion for #375
Discussion for #376
Discussion for #377
Discussion for #378
Discussion for #379
Discussion for #380
Discussion for #381
Discussion for #382
Discussion for #383
Discussion for #384
Discussion for #385
Discussion for #386
Discussion for #387
Discussion for #388
Discussion for #389
Discussion for #390
Discussion for #391
Discussion for #392
Discussion for #393
Discussion for #394
Discussion for #395
Discussion for #396
Discussion for #397
Discussion for #398
Discussion for #399
Discussion for #400
Discussion for #401
Discussion for #402
Discussion for #403
Discussion for #404
Discussion for #405
Discussion for #406
Discussion for #407
Discussion for #408
Discussion for #409
Discussion for #410
Discussion for #411
Discussion for #412
Discussion for #413
Discussion for #414
Discussion for #415
Discussion for #416
Discussion for #417
Discussion for #418
Discussion for #419
Discussion for #420
Discussion for #421
Discussion for #422
Discussion for #423
Discussion for #424
Discussion for #425
Discussion for #426
Discussion for #427
Discussion for #428
Discussion for #429
Discussion for #430
Discussion for #431
Discussion for #432
Discussion for #433
Discussion for #434
Discussion for #435
Discussion for #436
Discussion for #437
Discussion for #438
Discussion for #439
Discussion for #440
Discussion for #441
Discussion for #442
Discussion for #443
Discussion for #444
Discussion for #445
Discussion for #446
Discussion for #447
Discussion for #448
Discussion for #449 & Part Two
Discussion for #450
Discussion for #451
Discussion for #452
Discussion for #453
Discussion for #454
Discussion for #455
Discussion for #456
Discussion for #457
Discussion for #458
Discussion for #459
Discussion for #460
Discussion for #461
Discussion for #462
Discussion for #463
Discussion for #464
Discussion for #465
Discussion for #466
Discussion for #467
Discussion for #468
Discussion for #469
Discussion for #470
Discussion for #471
Discussion for #472
Discussion for #473
Discussion for #474
Discussion for #475
Discussion for #476
Discussion for #477
Discussion for #478
Discussion for #479
Discussion for #480
Discussion for #481
Discussion for #482
Discussion for #483
Discussion for #484
Discussion for #485
Discussion for #486
Discussion for #487
Discussion for #488
Discussion for #489
Discussion for #490
Discussion for #491
Discussion for #492
Discussion for #493
Discussion for #494
Discussion for #495
Discussion for #496
Discussion for #497
Discussion for #498
Discussion for #499
Discussion for #500
Discussion for #501
Discussion for #502
Discussion for #503
Discussion for #504
Discussion for #505
Discussion for #506
Discussion for #507
Discussion for #508
Discussion for #509
Discussion for #510
Discussion for #511
Discussion for #512
Discussion for #513
Discussion for #514
Discussion for #515
Discussion for #516
Discussion for #517
Discussion for #518
Discussion for #519
Discussion for #520
Discussion for #521
Discussion for #522
Discussion for #523
Discussion for #524
Discussion for #525
Discussion for #526
Discussion for #527
Discussion for #528
Discussion for #529
Discussion for #530
Discussion for #531
Discussion for #532
Discussion for #533
Discussion for #534
Discussion for #535
Discussion for #536
Discussion for #537
Discussion for #538
Discussion for #539
Discussion for #540
Discussion for #541
Discussion for #542
Discussion for #543
Discussion for #544
Discussion for #545
Discussion for #546
Discussion for #547
Discussion for #548
Discussion for #549
Discussion for #550
Discussion for #551
Discussion for #552
Discussion for #553
Discussion for #554
Discussion for #555
Discussion for #556
Discussion for #557
Discussion for #558
Discussion for #559
Discussion for #560
Discussion for #561
Discussion for #562
Discussion for #563
Discussion for #564
Discussion for #565
Discussion for #566
Discussion for #567
Discussion for #568
Discussion for #569
Discussion for #570
Discussion for #571
Discussion for #572
Discussion for #573
Discussion for #574
Discussion for #575
Discussion for #576
Discussion for #577
Discussion for #578
Discussion for #579
Discussion for #580
Discussion for #581
Discussion for #582
Discussion for #583
Discussion for #584
Discussion for #585
Discussion for #586
Discussion for #587
Discussion for #588
Discussion for #589
Discussion for #590
Discussion for #591
Discussion for #592
Discussion for #593
Discussion for #594
Discussion for #595
Discussion for #596
Discussion for #597
Discussion for #598
Discussion for #599
Discussion for #600
Discussion for #601
Discussion for #602
Discussion for #603
Discussion for #604
Discussion for #605
Discussion for #606
Discussion for #607
Discussion for #608
Discussion for #609
Discussion for #610
Discussion for #611
Discussion for #612
Discussion for #613
Discussion for #614
Discussion for #615
Discussion for #616
Discussion for #617
Discussion for #618
Discussion for #619
Discussion for #620
Discussion for #621
Discussion for #622
Discussion for #623
Discussion for #624
Discussion for #625
Discussion for #626
Discussion for #627
Discussion for #628
Discussion for #629
Discussion for #630
Discussion for #631
Discussion for #632
Discussion for #633
Discussion for #634
Discussion for #635
Discussion for #636
Discussion for #637
Discussion for #638
Discussion for #639
Discussion for #640
Discussion for #641
Discussion for #642
Discussion for #643
Discussion for #644
Discussion for #645
Discussion for #646
Discussion for #647
Discussion for #648
Discussion for #649
Discussion for #650
Discussion for #651
Discussion for #652
Discussion for #653
Discussion for #654
Discussion for #655
Discussion for #656
Discussion for #657
Discussion for #658
Discussion for #659
Discussion for #660
Discussion for #661
Discussion for #662
Discussion for #663
Discussion for #664
Discussion for #665
Discussion for #666
Discussion for #667
Discussion for #668
Discussion for #669
Discussion for #670
Discussion for #671
Discussion for #672
Discussion for #673
Discussion for #674
Discussion for #675
Discussion for #676
Discussion for #677
Discussion for #678
Discussion for #679
Discussion for #680
Discussion for #681
Discussion for #682
Discussion for #683
Discussion for #684
Discussion for #685
Discussion for #686
Discussion for #687
Discussion for #688
Discussion for #689
Discussion for #690
Discussion for #691
Discussion for #692
Discussion for #693
Discussion for #694
Discussion for #695
Discussion for #696
Discussion for #697
Discussion for #698
Discussion for #699
Discussion for #700
Discussion for #701
Discussion for #702
Discussion for #703
Discussion for #704
Discussion for #705
Discussion for #706
Discussion for #707
Discussion for #708
Discussion for #709
Discussion for #710
Discussion for #711
Discussion for #712
Discussion for #713
Discussion for #714
Discussion for #715
Discussion for #716
Discussion for #717
Discussion for #718
Discussion for #719
Discussion for #720
Discussion for #721
Discussion for #722
Discussion for #723
Discussion for #724
Discussion for #725
Discussion for #726
Discussion for #727
Discussion for #728
Discussion for #729
Discussion for #730
Discussion for #731
Discussion for #732
Discussion for #733
Discussion for #734
Discussion for #735
Discussion for #736
Discussion for #737
Discussion for #738
Discussion for #739
Discussion for #740
Discussion for #741
Discussion for #742
Discussion for #743
Discussion for #744
Discussion for #745
Discussion for #746
Discussion for #747
Discussion for #748
Discussion for #749
Discussion for #750
See third post for continued links.Last edited by Lira; 20130225 at 08:02 PM.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090201, 01:29 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Discussion for #751
Discussion for #752
Discussion for #753
Discussion for #754
Discussion for #755
Discussion for #756
Discussion for #757
Discussion for #758
Discussion for #759
Discussion for #760
Discussion for #761
Discussion for #762
Discussion for #763
Discussion for #764
Discussion for #765
Discussion for #766
Discussion for #767
Discussion for #768
Discussion for #769
Discussion for #770
Discussion for #771
Discussion for #772
Discussion for #773
Discussion for #774
Discussion for #775
Discussion for #776
Discussion for #777
Discussion for #778
Discussion for #779
Discussion for #780
Discussion for #781
Discussion for #782
Discussion for #783
Discussion for #784
Discussion for #785
Discussion for #786
Discussion for #787
Discussion for #788
Discussion for #789
Discussion for #790
Discussion for #791
Discussion for #792
Discussion for #793
Discussion for #794
Discussion for #795
Discussion for #796
Discussion for #797
Discussion for #798
Discussion for #799
Discussion for #800
Discussion for #801
Discussion for #802
Discussion for #803
Discussion for #804
Discussion for #805
Discussion for #806
Discussion for #807
Discussion for #808
Discussion for #809
Discussion for #810
Discussion for #811
Discussion for #812
Discussion for #813
Discussion for #814
Discussion for #815
Discussion for #816
Discussion for #817
Discussion for #818
Discussion for #819
Discussion for #820
Discussion for #821
Discussion for #822
Discussion for #823
Discussion for #824
Discussion for #825
Discussion for #826
Discussion for #827
Discussion for #828
Discussion for #829
Discussion for #830
Discussion for #831
Discussion for #832
Discussion for #833
Discussion for #834
Discussion for #835
Discussion for #836
Discussion for #837
Discussion for #838
Discussion for #839
Discussion for #840
Discussion for #841
Discussion for #842
Discussion for #843
Discussion for #844
Discussion for #845
Discussion for #846
Discussion for #847
Discussion for #848
Discussion for #849
Discussion for #850
Discussion for #851
Discussion for #852
Discussion for #853
Discussion for #854
Discussion for #855
Discussion for #856
Discussion for #857
Discussion for #858
Discussion for #859
Discussion for #860
Discussion for #861
Discussion for #862
Discussion for #863
Discussion for #864
Discussion for #865
Discussion for #866
Discussion for #867
Discussion for #868
Discussion for #869
Discussion for #870Last edited by Lira; 20130225 at 08:02 PM.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090301, 10:14 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Oct 2007
 Location
 Your nightmares.
 Gender

20090330, 09:41 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Mar 2009
 Location
 Italy, Pescara
 Gender
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
I noticed thread #252's link is broken or maybe the thread has been deleted.
I only wanted to point this out.
Thanks for the post Lira, id very useful
SpoilerIn memory of Gary Gygax (19382008) and Dave Arneson (1947– 2009)
Supporter of V in his darkest hour.
V  I love the smell of bat guano in the morning. Smells like... victory.
 Now if you don’t mind, I am somewhat preoccupied telling the laws of physic to shut up and sit down.
 I prepared Explosive Runes this morning
 I... I must suceed.
Please look at my dragons

20090404, 02:24 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Feb 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
also, thread 263 link is down.
I've rather enjoyed trawling through them though didn't start posting regularly until after War & XPs, so seeing views on older strips is interesting.
EDIT: Lira's asked me to keep the list updated so it will continue from here:
Gygax Magazine OoTS Discussion Threads
(See next post)
Individual Discussion Threads (Main Online Strip)
Discussion for #871
Discussion for #872
Discussion for #873
Discussion for #874
Discussion for #875
Discussion for #876
Discussion for #877
Discussion for #878
Discussion for #879
Discussion for #880
Discussion for #881
Discussion for #882
Discussion for #883
Discussion for #884
Discussion for #885
Discussion for #886
Discussion for #887
Discussion for #888
Discussion for #889
Discussion for #890
Discussion for #891
Discussion for #892
Discussion for #893
Discussion for #894
Discussion for #895
Discussion for #896
Discussion for #897
Discussion for #898
Discussion for #899
Discussion for #900
Discussion for #901
Discussion for #902
Discussion for #903
Discussion for #904
Discussion for #905
Discussion for #906
Discussion for #907
Discussion for #908
Discussion for #909
Discussion for #910
Discussion for #911
Discussion for #912
Discussion for #913
Discussion for #914
Discussion for #915
Discussion for #916
Discussion for #917
Discussion for #918
Discussion for #919
Discussion for #920
Discussion for #921
Discussion for #922
Discussion for #923
Discussion for #924
Discussion for #925
Discussion for #926
Discussion for #927
Discussion for #928
Discussion for #929
Discussion for #930
Discussion for #931
Discussion for #932
Discussion for #933
Discussion for #934
Discussion for #935
Discussion for #936
Discussion for #937
Discussion for #938
Discussion for #939
Discussion for #940
Discussion for #941
Discussion for #942
Discussion for #943
Discussion for #944
Discussion for #945
Discussion for #946
Discussion for #947
Discussion for #948
Discussion for #949
Discussion for #950
Discussion for #951
Discussion for #952
Discussion for #953
Discussion for #954
(Future discussion threads will be indexed below.)Last edited by hamishspence; 20140610 at 06:38 AM. Reason: update

20090404, 04:09 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Sep 2008
 Location
 Poland
 Gender
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
This thread should be made Sticky.
"It's better when you have several prisoners. You put them in one place and ask each one for the location of enemy camp. Then you slit their throats at a slightest sign of refusal, one by one, until there is only one left. This is usually the end, because the poor fellow breaks by then. If he doesn't well... all the better for you."
 Kavar Maldafaroth, the halfling rogue/barbarian, explains how to interrogate prisoners

20090404, 04:25 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Feb 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Seconded. If the lost discussion threads could be fixed too, that would be nice.
But stickying this would be ideal.
Gygax Magazine OoTS Discussion Threads
Discussion for #G001
Discussion for #G002
Discussion for #G003
Discussion for #G004
Discussion for #G005
Individual Discussion Threads (Main Online Strip)
Discussion for #955
Discussion for #956
Discussion for #957
Discussion for #958
Discussion for #959
Discussion for #960
Discussion for #961
Discussion for #962
Discussion for #963
Discussion for #964
Discussion for #965
Discussion for #966
Discussion for #967
Discussion for #968
Discussion for #969
Discussion for #970
Discussion for #971
Discussion for #972
Discussion for #973
Discussion for #974
Discussion for #975
Discussion for #976
Discussion for #977
Discussion for #978
Discussion for #979
Discussion for #980Last edited by hamishspence; Yesterday at 11:03 AM. Reason: update

20090404, 07:13 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Thanks for pointing that out. The thread seems to have been deleted, so I've noted that in the first post.
Also, thanks for the comments about stickying, guys. I'm glad you think this topic is worth it . But there's lots of other important topics that haven't been stickied, so it wouldn't really be fair if this one was.
Also: Updated with #643.Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090406, 10:28 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Mar 2009
 Location
 Italy, Pescara
 Gender
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
I also think this topic should be stiky!
Thanks for your exellent work
SpoilerIn memory of Gary Gygax (19382008) and Dave Arneson (1947– 2009)
Supporter of V in his darkest hour.
V  I love the smell of bat guano in the morning. Smells like... victory.
 Now if you don’t mind, I am somewhat preoccupied telling the laws of physic to shut up and sit down.
 I prepared Explosive Runes this morning
 I... I must suceed.
Please look at my dragons

20090407, 02:46 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Nov 2004
 Location
 Somewhere in NL
 Gender
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Regarding lost discussion threads...
Would it be possible to find them through the Internet Archive? If so, maybe it would be feasible to put a link to *that* repository.
Just an idea...!JoseB
o/` Ooooh, sweet mystery of liiiiiIIIIIiiife... o/`

20090416, 02:35 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090424, 04:58 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #646 and #647.
Also, I tried to find the old Discussion Threads using the Internet Archive, but I couldn't find anything. However, I have saved at least one discussion thread in my files (#223), so I'll try to locate that and put it on here.Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090502, 11:05 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #648, #649, and #650.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090514, 07:28 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #651, #652, and #653.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090519, 11:26 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Mar 2007
 Location
 Rome, Italy
 Gender
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
nice idea!
I was thinking that it might be worth it to have a table rather than a long list with the links (with rows of 10 strips or so)Knowledge, logic, reason, and common sense serve better than a dozen rule books.
E. G. Gygax
Lawful member of the Hinjo fanclub
Treegrappler of the Durkon fanclub

20090519, 11:32 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Jun 2006
 Location
 Poland
 Gender
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
At least some of the threads linked to here are much shorter than I remember. Weird.
Also, good job, of course.My FFRP characters. Avatar by Kris on a Stick. Sigatars by Gulaghar, Kris on a Stick and Zefir, respectively.

20090530, 10:05 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #654, #655, #656, and #657!
Thanks for the idea, I'll look into that later (I'm a bit swamped with exam preparations at the moment). :)
Thanks, I'm glad you found it useful.
Also: I was going through some stuff on my computer and I found that I'd save the text of the Sprained Wrist Theatre thread. It needs to be cleaned up a bit to be readable, but I should have it done and ready to post along with my next update to this topic.Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090611, 02:43 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Feb 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Are we going to do the last few?
I think that 658 has not been posted to for a while could probably be added on.

20090611, 07:37 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Yeah, this just took longer because I said I would post the Sprained Wrist Theatre thread with this update and I've been putting off cleaning that up . But I got through it today, so:
Updated for #658, #659, #660, and #661.
Also updated for the Sprained Wrist Theatre (which, oddly enough, it does not appear I copied the entire thing. Oh well, first 64 posts of the thread is good enough.
SpoilerOld 06272005, 08:32 PM #1
Winged One
The sad face is because the Giant got hurt. Anyway, discuss the guest comics here.
EDIT: In case future generations wonder what the Lawful Evil plane this is, I'll put the most recent news post:
(6/27/05) Latest news: I've decided to take the rest of the week off to let my hand heal. I just don't want to rush it, and the hundreds of "Get Well" emails I've gotten tell me you guys understand. Instead, I'll post a previouslyunposted fan comic or piece of fanart every day this week, and start fresh with next Monday's comic. If you ever wanted to do fanart for OOTS and see it posted for everyone to see, now's your chance. So sit back and enjoy a week of what I like to call (drumroll please)... Sprained Wrist Theater!
__________________
Old 06272005, 08:35 PM #2
Wukei
I love the art of this comic, but I personally do not find it funny :/ sorry to the writer.
__________________
Old 06272005, 08:37 PM #3
Peregrine
I thought the beholder was pretty funny, although the "elf names" just irked me. I'm funny like that. :P
__________________
Old 06272005, 08:40 PM #4
Mouse
Well I laughed at the joke, and I liked the artwork too. Thanks, Roman! And thanks to Rich for taking the trouble to keep us amused while he recuperates.
__________________
Old 06272005, 08:49 PM #5
EvilWalks
LOL!
That and we still don't know V's gender!
Obviously the Beholder thought it was something opposite of what he saw.
Very good Roman! Very cleverly done!
__________________
Old 06272005, 09:19 PM #6
The_Glyphstone
Neat. In true drawingV fashion, Panel #2 makes V look like a guy, while panel #5 makes him look far more girly.
I love beholders.
Thus, I will nitpick and point out that it is actually a Gauth (lesser beholder) and not a true Eye Tyrant.
__________________
Old 06272005, 09:30 PM #7
Corsair
You know, I pity that beholder. I mean, he's got how many eyes to gouge out? 9? 10?
__________________
Old 06272005, 10:01 PM #8
Pax
Hey, it's certainly not an "Evilgasm"uality joke, but then, that can be said for most of OotS's installments, anyway. And it WAS worth a chuckle  finally, SOMEthing gets a good look at V "in the allnatural" ... and promptly proceeds to try gouging out all six of it's eyes.
Remember: not everything has to hit perfection, in order to be "good". ^_^ Let's just be glad that there're enough artisticlyinclined fans out there to give Rich (and his wrist) a muchneeded break, without COMPLETELY depriving us of our StickFix, Mmm'kay? :)
__________________
Old 06272005, 10:34 PM #9
Tawmis
A long time ago, I used the avatars on this forum (the ones not used  at the time in the OOTS strip) to make a silly parody kind of strip about them complaining they were not in the OOTS strip. I yanked it down, shortly after, because of some confusion. I was just curious if the mods would be okay with me uploading them again (in this thread), and posting links to them for folks here to see and possibly giggle at while we wait for Rich to recover?
__________________
Old 06282005, 01:51 AM #10
latehorn
lol ;D
__________________
Old 06282005, 02:51 AM #11
Seraph
I knew something horribly traumatizing would happen once V said something about "swim".
I'm happy it happened to the beholder and not the viewers.
__________________
Old 06282005, 05:01 AM #12
Xander77
When I first noticed "guest comic", I thought about "A Modest Destiny"'s creators thoughts on the subject: http://www.squidi.net/
Then I read the guest comic itself, and wondered wether he read it, and fel very justified.
__________________
Old 06282005, 06:59 AM #13
PokeTheBard
Lol, alas the Order gain noses but the Beholder looses its mouth :D
__________________
Old 06282005, 08:27 AM #14
Sundog
It's some kind of Beholder variant, clearly.
__________________
Old 06282005, 09:55 AM #15
Malachi, the Lich King
Chalk it up to artistic license. Beholders have 11 eyes total [10 eyestalks plus central eye], gauths have 7 total, spectators 5 [1st ed monster version] and the creature in the strip has 6 eyes total [5 stalks plus central eye] A stupid display of geek pedigree on my part but there you go.
__________________
Old 06282005, 10:38 AM #16
tazzlair
Quote:
Originally Posted by The_Glyphstone
Neat. In true drawingV fashion, Panel #2 makes V look like a guy, while panel #5 makes him look far more girly.
Thought this myself,  love it, gives us a real look at V in each gender while keeping the mystery set up by the Giant.
__________________
Old 06282005, 10:43 AM #17
Wolfie
ahah a great comic! ;D
__________________
Old 06282005, 12:33 PM #18
Nasrudith
Anyone know if it was written in true elven? Then it would tell us what the heck he/she is saying! Maybe V is both genders at once.
__________________
Old 06282005, 12:56 PM #19
Corsair
Funny. He looked like a woman in both of them to me. Annoying, since I've always thought V was a male, before I noticed "V's Gender Debate"
__________________
Old 06282005, 01:23 PM #20
nightsong
really cool interpretation of OOTS. man, i wish i could draw like that. wouldn't it be cool to see this artist's interpretation of the rest of the OOTS party?
one great thing about animestyle art is that you can never really tell if the character is a girly guy or simply a girl! maintains the anonymity of V's gender :)
in anime art, my friend once said that you can only tell a girl is a girl if she has eyelashes. (i see no eyelashes on V :P) but V does look pretty girly in about the 5th frame
__________________
Old 06282005, 01:53 PM #21
chibibar
nope... Escaflowne (one of many) guys DO hvae eyelashes :)
so there goes that rule (and some girls don't have eye lashes either but can't think of any) I'm kinda out dated on my anime viewing list.
__________________
Old 06282005, 03:26 PM #22
Psymon
More guest filler! These are seriously cool!!
I'm surpised at how small Belkar is though in the top one, 1/2lings arnt that small are they?
Also, if any one knows how to use a custom avatar i'd be greatful to know as Sneak has kindly made me one and dont know how to use it.
__________________
Old 06282005, 03:40 PM #23
Nightmarenny
They are good but I alway saw Belkar as a bit more childlike.
__________________
Old 06282005, 05:28 PM #24
Xander77
The last fanart was pretty cool. Belkar looked proper dangerous.
__________________
Old 06282005, 07:06 PM #25
Frojoe21
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nightmarenny
They are good but I alway saw Belkar as a bit more childlike.
I always picture belkar as one of those 4 year olds who hit puberty like a compulsive gambler at a blackjack table, so he would look like a 4 year old with 5 o'clock shadow. Guuuhhhhh
__________________
Old 06282005, 09:32 PM #26
Aser
When I saw the guest comics, I was very profoundly impressed by Rich's generosity in offering his pages for the display of others' art.
It being Twosday, I raise my beer in a toast to Rich.
Cheers,
Aser
__________________
Old 06282005, 10:20 PM #27
Melange
I wrote this in the June thread but Winged One was adamant(ine):
Um hi....
I'm a longtime reader, firsttime poster.
Love the comic and all...
Just wanted to point something out about today's comic... The middle picture is to the RIGHT not the LEFT as the caption would have you think....
__________________
Old 06282005, 11:58 PM #28
Winged One
I wasn't replying to anybody, I was just pointing out the existance of this topic.
__________________
Old 06292005, 12:53 AM #29
Jhulae
I like the guest art, especially the picture by Isabel Maria Guzman.
Haley looks extremely sexy there. And, so does V, no matter what gender V is. ;D
__________________
Old 06292005, 02:10 AM #30
Porter
In the middle comic, the one with just v and haley, um, is it just my eyes, or do other people see the shape of something on haley that does not belong?
__________________
Page 2 of 4
Old 06292005, 02:36 AM #31
Videospirit
Not till you mentioned it but her skirt does look sort of phallic.
Anyways today's comic's pretty good. Too bad there aren't many jokes of their own used or it'd be funnier.
__________________
Old 06292005, 03:49 AM #32
Grimmwulf
For some reason I've always been picturing Elan and Haley looking like how Guybrush Threepwood and Elaine Marley did in the Monkey Island games.
__________________
Old 06292005, 05:31 AM #33
Melange
Quote:
Originally Posted by Grimmwulf
For some reason I've always been picturing Elan and Haley looking like how Guybrush Threepwood and Elaine Marley did in the Monkey Island games.
Elan: (Telling story of travels) ...and then we died.
Haley: Um... no we didn't...
Elan: Oh yeah... (continues story)
__________________
Old 06292005, 05:34 AM #34
Matuse
Someone took out Haley and replaced her with Chyna!
__________________
Old 06292005, 07:19 AM #35
The_Glyphstone
Woah, Elan's been pumping iron!
__________________
Old 06292005, 07:55 AM #36
EvilWalks
Must've cast Bull's Strength and Eagle's Splendor in tandem,
__________________
Old 06292005, 09:04 AM #37
Loki_d20
For some reason, today's guest artist pretty much captured how I've seen Elan. Sure, he look muscular and everything, but he's really just all looks. The type of personality has always reminded me of those corny superhero types who mess up everything and always end up making the most inane of decisions whenever possible.
__________________
Old 06292005, 09:36 AM #38
Runolfr
Critique of SWT #1:
Pretty good play on the running "sexually ambiguous" joke over Vaarsuvius. V is disturbingly attractive in this comic  disturbing because we aren't sure whether s/he should be attractive (to us as individuals). There's a fear of getting really turned on only to find the object of desire is a crossdresser. I think writing "Silent Scream" in the beholder's shock frame was unnecessary: the image captured the creature's reaction quite well.
Critique of SWT #3:
Yes, Elan is probably that dense, I just don't like the way he's drawn. I don't envision him as musclebound.
__________________
Old 06292005, 09:45 AM #39
zeorge
I didn't like the way Elan was drawn either, if he were stronger the Giant probably would have given him wider arms or something. And since Elan was never very good with the rapier ("Either that, or I don't think that you can affect this battle in any way") I doubt he has much strenght in the first place.
__________________
Old 06292005, 09:46 AM #40
AtomicKitKat
Regarding the skirt, I think it's just that maybe the fabric's "fold" is a little unnatural(I might have to take a towel around the waist later and see)
I think the most "accurate"(to me) depiction of Elan would be Christoph Erichsen's, although maybe a little less boyish and more mannish in the jawline.
Haley looks like she's been huffing steroids in the newest one. :/
__________________
Old 06292005, 09:53 AM #41
Nikolai_II
Quote:
Originally Posted by AtomicKitKat
Regarding the skirt, I think it's just that maybe the fabric's "fold" is a little unnatural(I might have to take a towel around the waist later and see)
There was a theory spotted in the other thread that the folds were due to Haley's foot being in the vicinity. (Foot, boot, something  theories abound)
__________________
Old 06292005, 12:40 PM #42
nightsong
well, I think my opinion matches the general comments: a little too much muscle on both Haley and Elan. but it is interesting to see a different interpretation of OOTS.
__________________
Old 06292005, 01:39 PM #43
tazzlair
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nikolai II
There was a theory spotted in the other thread that the folds were due to Haley's foot being in the vicinity. (Foot, boot, something  theories abound)
Yes, I agree with this, I think it is quite obvious that it is just the fold with her boot peeking out at the bottom of it. Sometimes I think everyone reads just a little to much into the drawings.
__________________
Old 06292005, 02:56 PM #44
Sylvius
Regardless of gender, V is a hottie in Isabel Maria Guzmân's drawing in SWT#2.
__________________
Old 06292005, 02:58 PM #45
bingo_bob
I agree with whoever said that it looks like Haley's on 'roids. She looks kind of creepy in my opinion.
__________________
Old 06292005, 03:10 PM #46
Jevanyn
Quote:
Originally Posted by chibibar
nope... Escaflowne (one of many) guys DO hvae eyelashes :)
so there goes that rule (and some girls don't have eye lashes either but can't think of any) I'm kinda out dated on my anime viewing list.
Escaflowne is a bad example, though: the dub I saw had a woman doing a voice for one of the male characters (who was not particularly feminine either).
__________________
Old 06292005, 05:31 PM #47
Grey Watcher
Well, the Haley doesn't look too bad. I think it's just the drawing style lends itself to "topheavy" characters (I mean, those eyes are huge). But yeah, I always pictured Elan as having more of the Boy Band variety of good looks, as opposed to the whole Studly DoRight thing. But still, I think it's hilarious. I wonder how many submissions the Giant has to wade through. I'd consider submitting one, but I can't even draw a stick figure.
__________________
Old 06292005, 05:33 PM #48
Wukei
I actually enjoyed the comedy in it somewhat, but I agree that they look wrong.
I'd submit something (and I did send him a picture just cuz) but everything I do is in black and white, and people really do prefer colour.
__________________
Old 06292005, 07:58 PM #49
Invariel
You're still one up from me  I only draw eyes in the dark. :P
__________________
Old 06302005, 02:32 AM #50
foXXtail
Is anyone else reminded of Yamara comics by that Elan/Haley one?
__________________
Old 06302005, 03:16 AM #51
Szar_Lakol
Quote:
Originally Posted by zeorge
I didn't like the way Elan was drawn either, if he were stronger the Giant probably would have given him wider arms or something.
Eh? Even ogres and trolls have stickarms. Why would the Giant give Elan wider arms?
__________________
Old 06302005, 05:30 AM #52
Ruroshen
Quote:
Originally Posted by Aser
When I saw the guest comics, I was very profoundly impressed by Rich's generosity in offering his pages for the display of others' art.
Amen to that  I know I've certainly appreciated it. You have no idea how much I've geeked out over this.
Hope you guys enjoyed the Haley/Elan comic. Sorry if you didn't  better luck tomorrow! ;D
__________________
Old 06302005, 07:48 AM #53
JD
SWT#2, picture 3. That is the best representation of them IMHO.
V  Apart from those weird somatic components I like the way s/he looks.
Elan Boyish and NOT strong as an ox and does NOT have a chindimple(sp?).
Belkar Perfect! Has that 4yearold psychopath feeling to him.
Roy Depicted as a knight during the crusades. Check!
Durkon Great, 100% dwarven cleric.
Haley Best of them all...
__________________
Old 06302005, 08:02 AM #54
AtomicKitKat
Quote:
Originally Posted by JD
Elan Boyish and NOT strong as an ox and does NOT have a chindimple(sp?).
You're thinking "cleft chin". That's when the chin looks like a pair of breasts, or someone's buttocks. *runs before the people with cleft chins start bludgeoning him to death with them.*
*runs back*Edit: Now, if we can just persuade Christoph to do the LG(old and new members, eventually), and the Xykon Koalition. :P
*runs off again*
__________________
Old 06302005, 09:17 AM #55
The Vorpal Tribble
I wonder if we could get Greg Dean from Real Life Comics to do a guest strip... 8)
__________________
Old 06302005, 11:01 AM #56
Dumbdaddy
Quote:
Originally Posted by Nikolai II
There was a theory spotted in the other thread that the folds were due to Haley's foot being in the vicinity. (Foot, boot, something  theories abound)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dumbdaddy
For as feminine as Haley is, I thought, she was extraordinarily well ... endowed. Took me a moment to realize that was Haley's *foot* placed in an odd place.
... And I thought it was V who had the gender enigma thing going.
DD ::)
Wow! I was read! Truly, I was relieved when I realized that was Haley's boot, cause Isabel's depiction of Haley has otherwise been very happily seared into my brain. Yummy :)
And to reiterate a couple of other posts  All praise the Giant for allowing others to use his forum for guest art, and to all the guest artists, snide criticisms aside, GREAT JOB and THANKS!
DD
__________________
Old 06302005, 11:03 AM #57
Poeir
I'd really like to see that, but he's been having problems with his own strip lately. Plus his D&D humor has been more about the players, not about the game, though that may just be how he elects to do his comic. (Real Life Comics)
__________________
Old 06302005, 11:15 AM #58
Wukei
I've actually had a couple of people say that I should submit my artwork for this week. I told them "it's just artwork, and it's just b&w..there's no comic to it, and that's what people really want."
And besides, my ex reads this comic and I don't want him to think I'm actually close to Rich and come to me with apologies just because he thinks my artwork might actually go somewhere.
He didn't believe in me before, I don't want him to believe in me now just because someone more popular than him does.
__________________
Old 06302005, 06:01 PM #59
Melange
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wukei
I've actually had a couple of people say that I should submit my artwork for this week. I told them "it's just artwork, and it's just b&w..there's no comic to it, and that's what people really want."
And besides, my ex reads this comic and I don't want him to think I'm actually close to Rich and come to me with apologies just because he thinks my artwork might actually go somewhere.
He didn't believe in me before, I don't want him to believe in me now just because someone more popular than him does.
But Wukei, if your Ex gets a change of heart, that doesnt mean you have to. Your art is really good! Might as well go for it.
__________________
Old 06302005, 06:52 PM #60
LadyGlutter
Quote:
Originally Posted by Wukei
And besides, my ex reads this comic and I don't want him to think I'm actually close to Rich and come to me with apologies just because he thinks my artwork might actually go somewhere.
He didn't believe in me before, I don't want him to believe in me now just because someone more popular than him does.
Wukei! >:(
/me gives stern motherly look....
Please please please do not avoid taking risks or avoid SUCCESS because of your ex!!!!! *Are you kidding me? *Don't let that boy run your life, even indirectly. *You do what YOU want to do, you hear me? *Cuz I said so, and I know what's best! * ;) *
__________________
Page 3 of 4
Old 06302005, 06:54 PM #61
Wukei
It seems I'm doing fine without being a guest artist. ;)
__________________
Old 06302005, 06:59 PM #62
Winged One
Wukei, your art is great. We'd love to see it on the comics page. If it's because of color, get somebody else to do it(I seem to recall Allara being good at coloring your stuff).
__________________
Old 06302005, 07:33 PM #63
Psymon
Where is todays guest comic?
Hope the giant hasnt reinjured!
P.s. thanks to everyone who PM'ed helping out with the avatar  sorted now! Also thanks to sneak for making it! (its tattooed monk, see CW, they kick ass!)
__________________
Old 07012005, 05:43 AM #64
AtomicKitKat
Bridget's Elan is the new definitive Elan. ;D
__________________Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090615, 12:55 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Dec 2008
 Gender
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
I LOVE going through the comics and picking out the really shocking ones, and reading peoples reactions and reading peoples predictions.
Offical Diviner of the Vaarsuvius Fanclub
The Vorpal Tribble:
Roy likes big Sylphs and he cannot lie, You other fighters can't deny
That when an outsider walks in with a small category And a winged thing in your backstory You get Charmed Wanna take a feat that's tough
Cuz you notice her size was buffed...
Thanks to Holammer for the Avvie!
Last edited by noone in particular : Tommorow at 17:90 PM

20090625, 12:23 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090709, 02:29 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Feb 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
I like rereading them once in a while especially if there is an argument covering events that happened way back, and I want to see what people said then.
Marut2 Avatar by Serpentine

20090709, 07:28 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #665, #666, #667, and #668.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090729, 09:59 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #669, #670, and #671.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090902, 10:25 AM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #672, #673, and #674.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090912, 05:54 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #675, #676, and #677.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090912, 07:06 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 Nov 2008
 Location
 Sweden
 Gender
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Nice initiative. It could be interesting to keep an index on this. I just went back and checked the threads on #400, #448 and #449, all among my favourite strips ever.
A nitpick, however: in the lists, you contracted the removed threads of #363#365, which kind of breaks with your form. I think it would be prettier to write those out instead, but it definitely works as it is too.Quoth the raven, "Polly wants a cracker."
Pony avatar by the Great and Powerful DirtyTabs. Lotsa hugs!
Scourge Caste avatar by the illustrious Akrim.elf. Thank you!

20090912, 07:19 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Great, I'm always glad to hear that people are finding this useful.
The reason those are like that is because it wasn't three different threads. Apparently, during that time the forum was experiencing some problems and the thread was made sometime after #365 and was about all three comics. So it wasn't a contraction on my part, the original was one thread for the three comics.Last edited by Lira; 20090912 at 07:22 PM.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20090923, 08:47 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #678, #679, #680 and #681.
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.

20091011, 12:40 PM (ISO 8601)
 Join Date
 May 2007
Re: The Discussion Thread Index II
Updated for #682, #683, #684, and #685!
Credits to halfhalfling for my adorable avatar.
...............................................
Come visit the Discussion Thread Index II.
Looking for a new webcomic to read? Take a look at the Webcomic List.