Witchunt V1.0 Game 3 - We are going to need more ducks

[Leta]

I'm not angry, just questioning it. Is there any particular reason you couldn't post earlier?

To be honest, I'm kinda losing interest in WW, and with midterms coming around and everything, that's how it goes.

You guys can go ahead and lynch me if you want.

[Tydude]

To be honest, I'm kinda losing interest in WW, and with midterms coming around and everything, that's how it goes.

You guys can go ahead and lynch me if you want.

Okay then. I really hope you're not a power role.

[Gray Mage]

Day ends. Leta was lynched, he then D.O.B kills CitizenFry.

Night begins now and ends in 48 hours.

[Gray Mage]

Since I already have the night actions in, night ends now.

No one was attacked.

Day begins and ends in 72 hours.

[Rogue Nine]

My idea for today is risky, but I think it can give us the win:

EVERYBODY claims.

There are 5 good roles that I can't peg down and only 4 people who haven't claimed anything, so something doesn't add up.

If someone has a better idea, I'd like to hear it.

[Ramsus]

Wait, before we do that...Zanshin, do you know if the WW is dead? If not that's a bad idea.

[Tydude]

My idea for today is risky, but I think it can give us the win:

EVERYBODY claims.

There are 5 good roles that I can't peg down and only 4 people who haven't claimed anything, so something doesn't add up.

If someone has a better idea, I'd like to hear it.

Why would we ever do that? Unless you have proof the WW is dead that would be a terrible plan.

[Rogue Nine]

Wait, before we do that...Zanshin, do you know if the WW is dead? If not that's a bad idea.

Why would we ever do that? Unless you have proof the WW is dead that would be a terrible plan.

I have no concrete proof, but my suspicion is that Sotek was the WW.

And I know it's a bad idea, but what else have we got- continuing to lynching suspicious people?

Look at how that turned out yesterday.

[Ramsus]

Uh....fairly decently actually? We managed to lynch the DOB and kill someone who was very likely the WW. However considering that Fry didn't do anything about us lynching the possible DOB, it means he might not have been the WW afterall. I would say that yes, further lynching is probably the best plan here.

[Rogue Nine]

We managed to lynch the DOB...

That part is true.

[Onime-no-Enishi]

I am quite sure Sotek isnt WW, this worth rushing things. (not 100% sure, but probability of him being WW is too low)

As much as it was surprising that Leta is in fact the DoB, Leta also wasnt as interested in the WW game already anyway, so it had to be done regardless.

But with this reaction coming from zanshin, i can assume that Citizen is not scum and probably a possible power role >>; that or hes just not scum/WW.

Either ways, we need to do this carefully, mass claiming with WW still up = instant lose.

[Tydude]

We managed to lynch the DOB

Yay! Go team! Anyways, Sotek being the WW is a possibility, since byers (the necromancer, according to Ramsus) said Sotek was the Priest. That's most likely false, so why would byers have lied? Because Sotek was really the WW. So, yeah, it's possible. But then why is the game still going? I guess there could be a JW out there, but it doesn't seem likely. So, here's the list of players and what I think of them:

Tydude - Confirmed town.
Ramsus - Probably Spy, but is not threat right now even if he is a witch.
Zanshin - Most likely town.
Mannikath - Most likely town.
Onime - Don't know much about him, kind of suspicious.
Seraine - Self-proclaimed low power role. So, no harm in testing him.
Eternal Drifter - Hasn't said much, but from what he has said seems towny to me.

And, that's it. Onime-no-Enishi, you're at the top of my list. Have anything to say?

[Onime-no-Enishi]

^ in my post i meant "this isnt worth rushing things"


Anyway, I dont have much to say without giving out too much info and risk having WW go on devour spree. If anything i can only guarantee I'm town. Otherwise, theres no reason for me to follow plans that are pro-town this late in the game.

If it means anything, I can say there will only be a -1 to town if I'm lynched and medium gets info. But I believe i can be quite certain of the roles of everyone who died at night, and have a good guess on the roles of everyone except for 5, 3 of which are dead. But said info is pretty much meaningless unless WW is dead and I can spill them (or more like we can compare notes) and find out the remaining scum.

If anything can we get a confirmation if the JW is still alive or dead?

[Ramsus]

lol, Tydude. I meant that it was good we lynched the DOB without the Werewolf managing to eat them.

And well since Tydude is doing a list I might as well I guess. Though I have to say, my suspicion meter is on way higher alert apparently.

Ramsus - Hey, that's me!
Tydude - Town unless the GA got tricked by Witches somehow or something really weird happened. Most likely town.
Zanshin - Could be town, could not. There was no reason for me to lie about byers and hipen's roles and plenty of reason not to and anyone could guessed that. He could be just making up whatever.
Mannikath - Keeps trying to kill me. Survived a hit where he could safely believe that GA would protect him.
Onime - Hasn't said much but I've been pretty sure I knew exactly what role he was for most of the game and that would be a town role.
Seraine - Not much info other than claiming to be something relatively unimportant.
Eternal Drifter - Talks more than Seraine but still not much info.

I'll second Onime's request to Zanshin about the JW's status.

[Eternal Drifter]

Might as well post my thoughts as well.

Ramsus - Quite likely the spy, since the night kills have stopped. Also, due to a lack of interference from the Junior Witch, he could be the last witch. Still, he could be trouble, as in an actual witch and not a spy, but low on priorities at the moment.
Tydude - Unless we had some interference from the GAs, he's the only one remaining 100% confirmed town.
Zanshin - He 'confirmed' that Ramsus is the spy by confirming which witch role died when. The only way he could be witch (very unlikely at this point, but possible) would be if he was in league with Ramsus by witch-chat.
Mannikath - Keeps trying to kill Ramsus, the supposed spy. Bears a close watch until otherwise needed.
Onime-no-Enishi - Not a key player, so not on my list to watch. Still, I should pay closer attention...
Seraine - He claimed a weak townie, but specifics are unknown. Low key as well. Need to pay more attention to him...
Eternal Drifter - 100% town to me. Of course, with my laying low in the begining, you may be suspisious, even with my claim of late-game town. I still can't say more until I know the Werewolf situation has been resolved.

As to yesterday... WW suspects 1 and 2 were killed, 2 being lynched and DOBing 1. We can't afford any more mistakes...

Zanshin, I'm adding my power behind the request of the Junior Witch status after we hear from Mannikath.

[Rogue Nine]

Of the people I know dead, the JW is not among them.

There are a few dead players I have no info on. I thought Sotek was the Spiritualist- it fit the pattern of what happpened earlier, but now I'm not so sure.

To be honest, I don't really think he was the WW. There is a better probability that he was the JW. The reason I say that is that last night would have been the PERFECT time to sac Ramsus and kill me- Town would have lost BOTH ways of killing the WW without knowing if he was dead, AND the only Medium claimant, one of the few real power roles left, would be unable to tell anyone about it.

Ramsus - My gut says he is telling the truth. He's had several chances to hurt us and hasn't.
Tydude - Confirmed Townie.
Zanshin - Well I know I'm the Medium. I've hinted about it SEVERAL times in thread (I use the Wheat colored font in Quotes, it's ALMOST impossible to see- Check posts #310, #427 and #431. Also, I referenced the artist (ImperfectEclipse) of the Medium card by saying I'm not perfect). I am purposely not info-dumping to hopefully catch someone in a lie.
Mannikath - Probable Townie. Says he was protected by the GAs.
Onime-no-Enishi - No read, but Possible Scum (~30% chance) Helped town kill byers, a known Witch.
Seraine - Probable Scum (~60% chance). Claimed a "weak" town role, apparently (I don't remember seeing it). Did NOT help kill byers, but was on the Hipen wagon.
Eternal Drifter - Most Probably not Scum (~10% chance). His claim made me think DOB, but that can't be true. I think I know who he is though. VERY strange voting pattern.

My gut says Seraine.

[Rogue Nine]

Oops, forgot to finish my formatting.

Also a question: when the Enchantress picks, do they pick two players or two roles?

[Ramsus]

Pretty sure it's two players. Otherwise the JW would probably be lovers with the Nun in every game or something.

[Onime-no-Enishi]

If the JW isnt among the dead during the day, Then I am almost certain hes still alive.

this brings us to a vulnerable position, considering we wasted our DoB and killed a very possible towny in the process.

There are only 2 people i have completely no idea about and Seraine (Deadline Vote) is one of them.

My current guess on role accuracy atm is:
Ramsus: ~80%
Zanshin: ~80%
Tydude: ~95% (very low chance but GA may be f'ing with us >>; but i doubt that, Tydude is towny mc'towns person for the moment)
Mannikath: ~50% (at the very least, least probable to be WW, but still a lurking possibility)
Eternal Drifter: ~20%
Seraine: 0%
Myself: 100%

This is just from my reads from those that are dead and those remaining alive. Right now im completely blank on Seraine.

[Gray Mage]

Oops, forgot to finish my formatting.

Also a question: when the Enchantress picks, do they pick two players or two roles?

He/she picks two players.

[seraine]

If you guys want to lynch me, then lynch me. I still think it's more important to keep info from the werewolf.

[Ramsus]

*shrug* Seraine then.

[Tydude]

Now you're actually looking suspicious, Seraine (at deadline), and Onime is looking townier in my mind.

[Eternal Drifter]

Seraine is now good for me... a vote before bed...

[Gray Mage]

WW Seraine devoured Tydude, the Survivalist.

[Eternal Drifter]

WW Seraine devoured Tydude, the Survivalist.

Wait? What? Where in the thread did he devour?

The good news... we have our Werewolf at last...

... The bad... we'll have to lynch our Medium, Zanshin, to speed the time to when we can kill him...

[Gray Mage]

Wait? What? Where in the thread did he devour?

The good news... we have our Werewolf at last...

... The bad... we'll have to lynch our Medium, Zanshin, to speed the time to when we can kill him...

WW doesn't post the devours in the thread to avoid shenanigans. Instead he posts in the private QT.

[Ramsus]

ED is right. Dropping vote from Seraine. Sorry Zanshin.

[Onime-no-Enishi]

Wait? What? Where in the thread did he devour?

The good news... we have our Werewolf at last...

... The bad... we'll have to lynch our Medium, Zanshin, to speed the time to when we can kill him...

I have thought of that, but you have to realize the JW is still up and running =/ The best course of action would be to guess the JW and hope we get it right and kill him off.

[Rogue Nine]

Wait? What? Where in the thread did he devour?
This post is true, the rest we're lies.
The good news... we have our Werewolf at last...

... The bad... we'll have to lynch our Medium, Zanshin, to speed the time to when we can kill him...

Well he would have a hard time eating me, since that isn't really my role. I'm the Spiritualist. Everything I've claimed was based on things I've seen, GA chats, and my Gut. They do have the game almost all figured out, except the JW. I was trying to give the JW a false sense of security by claiming Sotek was probably that role.