Werewolf: Classic XIII

[Khal]

Bladescape

[Supagoof]

Yeah, bladescape. Makes sense for my notes. If not then i'll have 3 wolves.

Also "death your friend the reaper" not a valid password for my network anymore.

[bladescape]

I am a Seer. Just in case anyone was wondering.

(Supa:Not sure about three wolves, but possibly they're trying to do a 'sacrifice a wolf for a seer' trick?)

[Julian84]

I remain dubious, but fine: Bladescape.

[Supagoof]

I am a Seer. Just in case anyone was wondering.

(Supa:Not sure about three wolves, but possibly they're trying to do a 'sacrifice a wolf for a seer' trick?)

Then I have three names to give up...

[Firemeier]

Yay, lynching bladescape, as authorized by goof.

[smuchmuch]

Why exactly is everyone trusting supagoof without even a shred of evidence he is the seer(s?) proxy he pretends to be ?

[Imperial Psycho]

bladescape

Because he was attacked and baned. Wolves can't attack their own.

[rakkoon]

Bladescape duh

[Matthias2207]

I don't want to be involved in another villager lynch, so...
Point at Rogue Nine.
Maybe he's no wolf, but I don't think he will be lynched.
If bladescape turns out to be a wolf, so be it.
At least it won't be my fault if he turns out to be the seer or a villager.

[smuchmuch]

Because he was attacked and baned

Ah yes, on night 2. My bad.

Wolves can't attack their own.

(I'll admit it's unlikely anyway but just out of curisosity is there an actual writtebn point in the the classic rules saying that wolves can't eat each others ?)

Hum; switching point to Rakoon then, because I'm really not sure about the bandwagon on Bladescape.

[banjo1985]

(I'll admit it's unlikely anyway but just out of curisosity is there an actual writtebn point in the the classic rules saying that wolves can't eat each others ?)

I don't think anything is written to be fair. But for the wolves to have set up something like that attack on Goof on Night 2 a massive amount of things would have to have fallen into place. They need to find the Devil, use them to find the baner, get the baner to protect one of their own rather than themselves (very unlikley), and trust that they've convinced the baner well enough to target one of their own flock with their kill attempt. It's all outrageously unlikely.

Actually scratch that, it's pretty much impossible. The Devil only got one scry before they attacked Goof, they couldn't have joined up with the wolves and found the baner in that time.

Also, Bladescape prepare to die, obviously/Scottpilgrimreference.

Matthias, with that last post you've just put yourself at the top of the lynch list if bladescape turns out to have extraneous body hair and pointy teeth.

[Tasroth]

Is this a Seer wagon I see before me?

Yes, yes it is.

bladescape

[Matthias2207]

Matthias, with that last post you've just put yourself at the top of the lynch list if bladescape turns out to have extraneous body hair and pointy teeth.

?
What did I do?

[GrlumpTheElder]

Bladescape

[Lemonus]

Let's go with bladescape.

[Thufir]

I don't think we can be 99% sure based on one correct divination, unless I don't understand the seer power. The fool isn't always wrong, right? They just have a chance of being wrong, I think. But having had a correct divination so far, it definitely makes this seer more likely to be the real one! :) Depending on bladescape's status, we'll either have a better idea that it's the real seer or we'll know for sure that it's the Fool. Useful information either way, but let's hope it's the first one. Correct me if I'm wrong about the power. This is the first time I've played Werewolf.

You are correct. If the Fool was always wrong, it'd be too easy.

Also, though no-one asked, if bladescape was scried as a Wolf, he cannot be the Seer he claims to be, since the Fool still scries the Seer as Seer/Fool. So we have the delightfully unambiguous situation that either bladescape is not the Seer or the people claiming he's a Wolf are lying and therefore presumably Wolves themselves.

bladescape

Because he was attacked and baned. Wolves can't attack their own.

Wolves can in fact attack their own, I believe it's even happened once that the Wolves persuaded the Baner to bane one of them, who they attacked, thus getting him trusted for the rest of the game and helping them to victory.

But as Banjo says, the chances of them managing to do it on night 2 are vanishingly small.
I guess I'll go with the majority and point at bladescape.

[Murska]

bladescape, obviously.

But why do we have two proxies?

[Deathslayer7]

bladescape for a vote.

[Reinholdt]

Wolves can in fact attack their own, I believe it's even happened once that the Wolves persuaded the Baner to bane one of them, who they attacked, thus getting him trusted for the rest of the game and helping them to victory.

But as Banjo says, the chances of them managing to do it on night 2 are vanishingly small.
I guess I'll go with the majority and point at bladescape.

Lord of the Rings is the game reference.

[Zar Peter]

Oh well, point at bladescape

[cd4]

About the only time I can see where Supagoof is not on the village side is if the devil scried the baner, got the baner to protect him and the wolves tried to kill the devil. This however is unlikely.

I will follow the 2? proxys and vote for Bladescape.

[Bobby Archer]

Bladescape it is, then.

[smuchmuch]

Well then if everyon is so sure Supagoof is a villager, Seeing as I scried him as a wolf, I can then safely claim:
I am the fool

Hope that's any help for the remaining seer.

[Mustiado]

bladescape I suppose

EDIT: Hey Qwaz, I was one of the first people to vote yesterday. What's up with the autolynch warning?

[Matthias2207]

bladescape I suppose

EDIT: Hey Qwaz, I was one of the first people to vote yesterday. What's up with the autolynch warning?

Well, I can't find your vote either, so...
Maybe you were halfway posting when you lost interest and went chasing your tail?
Edit: You were one of the first people to vote on day 3, maybe you missed day 4 entirely? Because this is day 5, and you didn't post on day 4.

[calar]

Bladescape, for the obvious.

[Zjoot]

Wait, it's day 5 already?

Forsooth! I have had another vision of the ending of this game! Day 5, ____ will proclaim that they are a ____! :O

It came true! Thrice!

Oh, and Smuchmuch, I just realized that you forgot to cross out your point at supagoof when you switched to rakkoon.

[otakuryoga]

well, we have plenty on blade so ill throw out a safe non vote on the grimace

i was already fooled by a false rapture prophecy so i blame you

[Castaras]

It came true! Thrice!

Beware! Beware, the ides of 7!