Vote up a new monster species

[Strormer]

BEST: Shapechanger
2nd: Swarm
3rd: Cold
4th: Incorporeal
5th: Chaotic

Incidentally. If incorporeal and cold win, this could be a really terrifying beast to fight.

[thetobias]

Incorporeal
Shapechanger
Chaotic
Swarm
Cold

[Veklim]

Incorporeal
Cold
Swarm
Shapechanger
Chaotic

[137beth]

Aquatic. KELP!

....Sorry, Aquatic has already been voted off.

[SowZ]

1. Shapechanger
2. Swarm (The idea is that it can either be a bunch of small things, like vines or spores hence the Swarm, or mesh into one large thing that looks like a mold that takes any shape it chooses)
3. Chaotic
4. Incorporeal
5. Cold

[Zale]

Shapechanger
Chaotic
Incorporeal
Swarm
Cold.

Shapeshifting Chaotic Incorporeal Plant.

[Dragon Star]

Shapechanger
Swarm
Cold
Chaotic
Incorporeal

[137beth]

Voting closed, wait while I calculate the results.

Also

Shapechanger
Chaotic
Incorporeal
Swarm
Cold.

Shapeshifting Chaotic Incorporeal Plant.

wow, that is the exact opposite of my choices

And the winners are Swarm, Shapeschanger, and Cold!

Voting is now reopened.

[zagan]

Shapechanger and Swarm were my favorite so I'm happy with the result so far.

For size I'll go with

1. Tiny
2. Diminutive
3. Fine

In that order, I don't want it to be too small otherwise nobody will recognize it as a plant.

edit: i post too fast and got confused betwen tiny and diminutive, this is the correct vote.

[Zeta Kai]

1. Fine
2. Diminutive
3. Tiny

[Domriso]

I'll throw my vote down for:

Tiny
Diminutive
Fine

[Timeless Error]

From favorite to least favorite: Tiny, Fine, Diminutive.

[thetobias]

Fine
Diminutive
Tiny

[Strormer]

Best: Fine (for a swarm)
2nd: Diminutive
3rd: Tiny

[Dragon Star]

Fine
Diminutive
Tiny

[Togath]

1: Tiny
2:Diminutive
3:Fine

[Chainsaw Hobbit]

Tiny
Diminutive
Fine

[Veklim]

I'm with Strormer on this one, it's a swarm so it should definitely be as small as possible.

Fine
Diminutive
Tiny

I don't want it to be too small otherwise nobody will recognize it as a plant.

And what, pray tell, is algae, moss, etc if not fine plant life? Easily recognisable, it's a swarm/colony after all.

[137beth]

I'm with Strormer on this one, it's a swarm so it should definitely be as small as possible.

Fine
Diminutive
Tiny

And what, pray tell, is algae, moss, etc if not fine plant life? Easily recognisable, it's a swarm/colony after all.

I'm with ya on this one, if I were voting for size (which I'm not, except to break ties), I would have voted for a fine swarm, since it is the same overall size (takes up the space of a large creature) but can fit through smaller holes, and is generally more awesome.
I also appear to have predicted correctly: almost all of the voters would want it as small as possible (and vote fine/dim/tiny) or as big as possible (tiny/dim/fine). So far this prediction holds up quite well.

[wiimanclassic]

Dim, tiny, fine. Can't have it be TOO small. But not too big.

[zagan]

And what, pray tell, is algae, moss, etc if not fine plant life? Easily recognisable, it's a swarm/colony after all.

What I mean is that each independant part should be easily recognizable as an independant plant. In my mind fine size was the equivalent of a perle. Upon further checking it can go up to 6 inches, much bigger than that.
Still I stand by my vote, lot of big component part.

[Debihuman]

1. Fine
2. Diminutive
3. Tiny

Debby

[Darthteej]

1.Tiny

2. Diminutive

3.Fine

This is awesome.

[Arcran]

1. Fine
2. Diminutive
3. Tiny

[dethkruzer]

1.Diminutive
2.Tiny
3.Fine

[Temotei]

1. Tiny
2. Diminutive
3. Fine

[Qwertystop]

I can never remember what order the sizes are in below Small. My vote goes to (middle, smallest, largest).

EDIT: Just found out which is which. Diminutive, Fine, Tiny

[137beth]

And voting is now closed! I will update with the next phase shortly...

Voting reopened. Also, I am going to add what we have to the monster's stat block...

[Togath]

CR 9 gets my vote

[zagan]

Let's go with CR 11 not too high and not too low. (plus I could per haps use it in my campaign)