PEACH Exchange

[Iamyourking]

I gave the Limber Ones a look, and I think you'd be safe calling them finished. I also looked at the Dragon Ascendant, but didn't find anything that really caught my attention; although it certainly isn't bad.

[scarmiglionne4]

@ Troll Brau I looked at you Limber Ones and I think it is perfect. I did not leave anything on that thread because I don't think you should change anything else at this point that has not already been suggested.

[Zman]

Limber Ones look very polished. I can't see any problems. Well done.

[Tanuki Tales]

Thank you three for your feedback.

King and Scar, I've left my comments in your threads. Zman, I'll be getting to your Dragon Ascendant when I can in the next few days.

[Cipher Stars]

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showthread.php?t=264831

Anything for me to look at in exchange :3?

And I'm trading for PEACHes, not sour apples

[scarmiglionne4]

@Cipherthe3vil
I did my best offer you some PEACHes on you Naturally Sacred Something. If you found my critique adequate you may PEACH anything in my signature.

[Cipher Stars]

@Cipherthe3vil
I did my best offer you some PEACHes on you Naturally Sacred Something. If you found my critique adequate you may PEACH anything in my signature.

I've looked through your stuff. I have nothing more to add, nothing I see wrong with it, or I'm not experienced enough to help with the something, like paths.

[inuyasha]

I would like a PEACH for my Cthulu stats I made a while back using Bhu's kaiju template
http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showt...7#post13500777

and here is bhu's template

http://community.wizards.com/go/thre...r_Thread?pg=96

P.S. please tell me if you think my homebrew sucks, I want honest answers
P.S.S Bhu if your reading this I am a huge fan of all your work

[Iamyourking]

Ok, done. I guess you can PEACH Sons of the Fallen if you think you have something constructive to add, but don't bother if you can't; I'd just like to encourage new homebrewers and show them where they went wrong.

[AttilaTheGeek]

I'm looking for a PEACH or two on my Lightning Bloodline for Sorcerers. It's an attempt to add new options and combat spells to the blasty caster.

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showp...03&postcount=1

I'll also check out those Cthulhu stats, those seem cool.

[Durksmurf]

Please PEACH my sig and I'll return the favor and more.

[Cipher Stars]

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showt...8#post14404038

[Durksmurf]

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showt...8#post14404038

Hey want to PEACH exchange? I'm up for it.

[AttilaTheGeek]

I think this is a great thread, especially for new homebrewers, and I'd hate to see it fall into disuse. I'm going to start it back up again with a PEACH request for my Elementalist class.

[Frathe]

Attila--I'll PEACH your Elementalist if you PEACH my crystalline creature template.

[AmberVael]

If anyone is interested, I'd like to have some more feedback on my latest invocation set.

[SirAxealot]

I'd like some comments on this class I've been working on, the Blackthorn Savage. It's a sort of mix of Druid, barbarian, and martial initiator

Before you do review it, be aware that 1) it is very much a work in progress 2) it is probably going to be tier 1 when we're done with it. After all, anyone playing a druid needs a reason to not take straight druid or planar shepherd.

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showthread.php?t=265023

[Deepbluediver]

I recently posted a monk fix, that I would love some feedback on. It's quite extensive (i.e. long and complex) so I will try and PEACH several people's work in this thread, and hope that they can all drop a small comment or two in mine.

I think this is a great thread, especially for new homebrewers, and I'd hate to see it fall into disuse. I'm going to start it back up again with a PEACH request for my Elementalist class.

I've given a few thoughts in to your elementalist. I'll try to work through the most recent posters in order, though if anyone reviews my monk I'll bump them to the top of the list.

Attila--I'll PEACH your Elementalist if you PEACH my crystalline creature template.

Left a few comments on your crystaline creature template.

[WaylanderX]

If somebody wants to PEACH my Delirionist, especially the spell section, I would be thrilled. Just give me a PM with that you want to have PEACHed in return. ^^

[JoshuaZ]

Some PEACHING of my Forsaken Blade would be greatly appreciated.

[AttilaTheGeek]

This thread is now so full of cool new homebrew, I can't keep up!

Attila--I'll PEACH your Elementalist if you PEACH my crystalline creature template.

Done. Looks awesome.

If anyone is interested, I'd like to have some more feedback on my latest invocation set.

I am almost done with a PEACH of your invocations. However, I don't usually play 3.5, nature-related classes, or warlocks, so take my comments with a several grains of salt.

I'd like some comments on this class I've been working on, the Blackthorn Savage.

I've taken a glance at it, and it seems interesting, but I don't want to skip Vael and leave him in the lurch. I'm going to look at it more in depth later tonight.

After that, I'll leave some comments on Deep's monk, Waylander's Delerionist, and Joshua's Forsaken Blade.

I'm also looking for some comments on my Rune Knight archetype (ACF) for Pathfinder's magus.

[Razanir]

(Hope this isn't thread necro yet)

I'm making (more or less) a PF rebalance. Peaches are welcome, both the fruit and the acronym.

[Jeff the Green]

(Hope this isn't thread necro yet)

I'm making (more or less) a PF rebalance. Peaches are welcome, both the fruit and the acronym.

Nope, not necroing yet. Only if a thread has been dead for six weeks is it necromancy. As 'tis, it's resuccitation.

Alas, never having played PF, I can't give a meaningful critique of yours, but I'm sure someone else can.

Also, a note, I finally PEACHed Grelna's spell. I also looked over Iamyourking's Sons of the Fallen, but I couldn't think of anything to say other than "that's awesome," which is too close to spam for my taste.

If anyone wants to, I'm still open to critiques of the three classes in my signature (or any of the ones in my extended sig, though those are past the necromancy date). I'm working on another triptych of classes at the moment, this time of theurges, which I hope will be done soon, but needing to come up with brand new abilities for every official vestige is killing me.

[Iamyourking]

Well, I wouldn't consider it to be spam if you noted which parts you found to be especially awesome; because if I know what people like I can build on it and make it even more awesome.

[Nightgaun7]

Still looking for input on the Blackthorn Savage, a druid/barbarian/martial initiator. SirAxealot and I have been working on some changes already, but they're not up yet.

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showthread.php?t=265023

Also looking for input on a new discipline, Frenzied Beast.

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/showthread.php?t=267279

Be aware that these are both very much WIP, since we are both relatively new to this.

[Razanir]

Update on my rebalance– The shaman is now posted. It's a cross between druids and barbarians. I'd greatly appreciate someone stopping by and PEACH'ing it. And yes, I realize there are dead levels. Feel free to suggest ideas for how to fill them. One note, however– Spell lists are coming later once I have the classes otherwise written.

[Deepbluediver]

Meant to get back to this sooner, but I've unexpectedly busy. Still plan to try and PEACH more of this as promised.

My comments on the Blackthorn Savage are up, since it seemed the easiest to start with. I've got a barbarian fix I've been meaning to type up. If I get that done within the next weak maybe I can trade it for a Peach of the Frenzied Beast Discipline (which sounds odd right off the bat; maybe we need some word other than "Discipline" to describe it)

I'll try to get to Vael's invocations tonight yet (no one hold their breath). I've scanned over WaylanderX's crazy-magic class, and the concept is so odd I'm not exactly where to start. Maybe I can post something by mid week though.
And JoshuaZ's post is a PrC that is partially based on other Homebrew. I will need to knock the rust off of my ToB skills before I dig into that one.


Edit: Have PEACHed the Invocations (furry creatures huzzah!)

[AttilaTheGeek]

Raz, I'm an avid Pathfinder player; I'll PEACH your rebalance if you check out my Rune Knight magus archetype?

(actually, I was going to look at it anyway, because it seems interesting)

[Razanir]

Raz, I'm an avid Pathfinder player; I'll PEACH your rebalance if you check out my Rune Knight magus archetype?

(actually, I was going to look at it anyway, because it seems interesting)

Sure. Don't be surprised though if my comments are more what looks good/bad and a complementary spelling and grammar check

[Zireael]

I want this homebrew system P.E.A.C.H.ed, in exchange I'll P.E.A.C.H. anything that's D&D 3.5 or Pathfinder.

Already P.E.A.C.H.ed Frenzied Beast and Blackthorn Savage.