Number of Character Appearances V

[TheWombatOfDoom]

I'm risking getting dangerously pedantic here, but the appearance I posted is the only one where you see enough of him to compare to the new comic. Seeing the back of his head doesn't just wasn't relevant.

I agree. I was just saying it wasn't his only appearance, is all. Not that it was another example of his appearance to compare to. I know what you mean now, I didn't then. I'm moving on.

[martianmister]

Updated through 974
Bandana, Crystal (as Golem), Haley Starshine, Sir François

[martianmister]

Updated through 975
Bandana, Crystal (as Golem), Haley Starshine, Sir François

[137beth]

Updated through 974
Bandana, Crystal (as Golem), Haley Starshine, Sir François

Where does Sir Francois appear in 974?

[ti'esar]

Where does Sir Francois appear in 974?

Looks like a copy/paste problem.

[137beth]

That's what I thought (since martianmister put the same characters in both 974 and 975.)

[ti'esar]

Okay, so "Spoiler Alert" (the Therkla PDF) is out. Here's what I have:

Spoiler: MAJOR SPOILERS for... well, Spoiler Alert

Show

Title page: Therkla
Page 1: Therkla, Eneth (new character), Fernanzio (new character)
Page 2: Therkla, Qarr, Daimyo Kubota
Page 3: Therkla, Kohaku (new character), 4 guards
Page 4: Therkla, Kohaku
Page 5: Therkla, Kohaku, three of the guards from Page 3. Dunno if they should be listed as individuals or a unit (they do have distinct faces), but either way they work for "Lady Kin-Hu", who does not appear at any point in the story.
Page 6: Therkla. Also an unnamed spice merchant, her husband, and a bunch of cats, none of whom have any other appearances.
Page 7: Therkla, Haru (new character), Fong the Forger (new character). Also Haru's girlfriend and other unnamed Azure City soldiers, none of whom have any other appearances.
Page 8: Therkla, Fong the Forger, the Azure City blacksmith. Also some various other people who I think only appear here.
Page 9: Therkla, nameless Azure City soldiers, and a female Sapphire Guard paladin that I don't recognize as having appeared anywhere else, but it's hard to tell in grayscale.
Page 10: Therkla, Sangwaan
Page 11: Therkla, Sangwaan, all of the Twelve Gods (on wall decoration)
Page 12: Therkla, Sangwaan, some of the Twelve Gods (on wall decoration). I can list the individual ones appearing if necessary.
Page 13: Therkla, Kohaku
Page 14: Daimyo Kubota, Therkla,
Page 15: Therkla. Also a random nameless House Kubota guard who only appears here.
Page 16: Sangwaan, Hinjo, Roy, Haley, Belkar. The first panel immediately follows after her last scene in the online comic, so Xykon and the zombie dragon are implicitly present, but they're still invisible.

[Gift Jeraff]

Spoiler

Show

Should Qarr communicating as Fernanzio count as an appearance for him?

[Porthos]

Spoiler

Show

Should Qarr communicating as Fernanzio count as an appearance for him?

Spoiler

Show

Under the "Voice Only" counts guideline, absolutely in my opinion.

[martianmister]

some of the Twelve Gods (on wall decoration). I can list the individual ones appearing if necessary.

Of course, I can't add them if you don't list them.

Spoiler

Show

Should Qarr communicating as Fernanzio count as an appearance for him?

Absolutely.

[ti'esar]

I wasn't sure if the Twelve Gods were listed as individuals or on a collective basis.

Spoiler: Spoiler Alert

Show

So the only ones visible on Page 12 are Dog, Monkey, Pig, Rat, and Rooster. All of them appear on Page 11, as I said.

[Yendor]

Spoiler

Show

Dog, Goat and Rooster appear on page 10. Ox is also visible on the first panel of page 11.

[Zyzzyva]

Spoiler: Spoiler Alert!

Show

Obviously this is the first (and, presumably, only) time we've seen Therkla, Kubota, and Sangwaan in the new art style... is this also the first time we've seen Hinjo in the new style too?

[Gift Jeraff]

Spoiler: Haleo and Julelan

Show

Soul-Muncher appears in 3 pages.

Spoiler: Spoiler Alert!

Show

Obviously this is the first (and, presumably, only) time we've seen Therkla, Kubota, and Sangwaan in the new art style... is this also the first time we've seen Hinjo in the new style too?

2015 Calendar

[martianmister]

All book related appearances are added to the list. Thanks for everyone for their contributions to the project.

[martianmister]

Updated through 976
Bandana, Crystal (as Golem), Eartha, Ferdinand, Haley Starshine

[137beth]

Did you fix the error with Sir François not appearing in 975?

[Elenna]

Just read through this thread. If I understand correctly, appearances of Durkon's body get counted as Durkon Allotrope Thundershield and as Durkon as Vampire. If Durkon's body says something, that also gets counted as the High Priest of Hel. Seeing the negative energy spirit counts as the HPoH, and seeing Durkon's trapped spirit counts as Durkon. Is that correct?

I'm not a huge fan of this, but oh well, let's just leave it.

Could martianmister please add something about this to the FAQ? Thanks!

[martianmister]

Did you fix the error with Sir François not appearing in 975?

There is no error. He appeared in 975.

Just read through this thread. If I understand correctly, appearances of Durkon's body get counted as Durkon Allotrope Thundershield and as Durkon as Vampire. If Durkon's body says something, that also gets counted as the High Priest of Hel. Seeing the negative energy spirit counts as the HPoH, and seeing Durkon's trapped spirit counts as Durkon. Is that correct?

That's correct.

Could martianmister please add something about this to the FAQ? Thanks!

I'll look into it.

[TheWombatOfDoom]

Updated through 974
Bandana, Crystal (as Golem), Haley Starshine, Sir François

Updated through 975
Bandana, Crystal (as Golem), Haley Starshine, Sir François

I think Ben is pertaining to this.

[martianmister]

That's a typo post. Actual post for 974 is this:

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/shows...&postcount=676

[Cizak]

Spoiler: BRitF recap page

Show

Are we missing Ted the seagull?

[TheWombatOfDoom]

That's a typo post. Actual post for 974 is this:

http://www.giantitp.com/forums/shows...&postcount=676

While I see that's the case, later posts generally supercede older posts, so that could be confusing. I suggest editing or deleting that typo, to avoid further confusion.

[Zyzzyva]

Spoiler: BRitF recap page

Show

Are we missing Ted the seagull?

Spoiler

Show

Ted the Albatross, please.

[Tom Tearcamel]

Rereading On the Origin of PCs I've noticed...

Spoiler

Show

Emmerick of Melbourne from 855a BRitF on page 57 during Roy's recruitment montage.

Right now he is in cameo's of named characters in bonus material, alongside Elric of Melnibone. Should they both be under cameo, or has the naming of the OotS stand-in for Elric replace him since has been named now?

[martianmister]

Spoiler: BRitF recap page

Show

Are we missing Ted the seagull?

He's not on 2.5 cats's list. Where did he appear?

While I see that's the case, later posts generally supercede older posts, so that could be confusing. I suggest editing or deleting that typo, to avoid further confusion.

Deleting that post now would cause more confusion. It's best to let it go.

Rereading On the Origin of PCs I've noticed...

Spoiler

Show

Emmerick of Melbourne from 855a BRitF on page 57 during Roy's recruitment montage.

Right now he is in cameo's of named characters in bonus material, alongside Elric of Melnibone. Should they both be under cameo, or has the naming of the OotS stand-in for Elric replace him since has been named now?

Are you sure that they're the same person? We've got both Harry Potter and Larry Gardener as characters.

[ti'esar]

Are you sure that they're the same person? We've got both Harry Potter and Larry Gardener as characters.

Despite opening up the bonus materials box and using ctrl-F, I can't find any appearances listed for Harry Potter.

[martianmister]

Despite opening up the bonus materials box and using ctrl-F, I can't find any appearances listed for Harry Potter.

Didn't he appeared in a bonus material? I must be seeing things.

[ti'esar]

Didn't he appeared in a bonus material? I must be seeing things.

Larry Gardener has a bonus appearance in SSDT, which is listed. (It's not an assumption that it's him - the page title is "Larry Gardener and the Hall of the Detained Juveniles").

[martianmister]

Larry Gardener has a bonus appearance in SSDT, which is listed. (It's not an assumption that it's him - the page title is "Larry Gardener and the Hall of the Detained Juveniles").

That's weird because I remember adding him...

Spoiler

Show

...still, Elric and Emmeric could be different persons.