Results 1 to 30 of 35
-
2018-04-08, 08:52 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2018
- Location
- Philippines
- Gender
Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Can a story or RPG adventure have (real world) political themes and still be worth reading or at least not be off-putting?
-
2018-04-08, 11:10 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2015
- Location
- San Francisco Bay area
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Um, yes.
Are you for real?
You list your occupation as "school teacher", and while I've never gone to college, my memories of "Literature" classes in Junior High and High School is that was what it mostly was.
Okay, some works by Dashiell Hammett, Ernest Hemingway, John Steinbeck, Mark Twain, and pretty much everything by George Orwell come to mind.
As far as RPG's a Call of C'thullu adventure had the Spanish Civil War as a background, which is...
...and it's not alone.
I don't think that this discussion may go far without getting too close to breaking Forum rules, but basically the answer is yes, but tread carefully.
-
2018-04-08, 11:48 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2018
- Location
- Philippines
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
I know. If you haven't noticed, I also listed my nationality as Filipino so we might not have the same political climate. I just wanted to make sure is all.
Thanks anyway for the reply.
-
2018-04-09, 12:08 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2010
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
I find that you used the term (real world) political themes, as often, fictional politics are a reflection of the politics of the author , the society the author lives in, or historical political ideas.
The Star Wars political conflict (specifically the original trilogy) is about as fictional as you can get (Empire vs. Rebels). But Order vs. Freedom (keeping these ideas broad in order to stay clear of forum regulations) have political parallels throughout history.
I personally think that all works are, at least in part, political in nature. Though I know that some disagree with that assessment.
-
2018-04-09, 02:15 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2007
- Location
- Cippa's River Meadow
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Yes, massively so. A major theme of the early A Song of Ice and Fire books (and by extension, the Westeros based storylines in early seasons of A Game of Thrones) is political manoeuvring (ie the aforementioned game of thrones), all of which are based on historical events.
A large majority of Romance of the Three Kingdoms is subterfuge and politicking, although the warfare that ensues when that politicking breaks down is more famous. There's a Chinese saying that "The old shouldn't read Three Kingdoms, the young shouldn't read The Water Margin'; The Water Margin is full of idealistic bravado and essentially machismo which isn't the best behaviour for young people to emulate, while Three Kingdoms is full of manipulative social and political tricks that the old should really know better not to use.
Branching out a bit, there's plenty of drama series (The West Wing, In the Thick of It, Yes (Prime) Minister) that are based on modern politics.
I can't think of many games with modern-era political themes, aside from the obvious like the Democracy series and to an extent, simulation games like Tropico and Urban Empire where dealing with various political factions is a major part of the game.
-
2018-04-09, 02:22 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2013
- Gender
-
2018-04-09, 02:50 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2013
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
I think what Brother Oni zeroes in on is the political manoeuvring in the show which would certainly qualify as drama. As a comdey show it's comedy is built on the drama of the clashing views and wills and goals of the newly appointed inexperienced idealistic politician and the jaded stick in mud civil servant who knows how things actually works and expects it to continue. The fricition, drama if you will, between these is what drives the comedy. Unlike say Benny Hillesque "slapstick".
I believe we have adequately established that yes it can. I would point out it can be tricky. People don't like to be hit over the head with stuff especially things that go agains't what they believe in. Which means you easily can get into the off-putting part. It also results in work that in this day and age will be termed "partisan". IE it's hard to balance without leaning one way or another and be considered preachy.Last edited by snowblizz; 2018-04-09 at 02:55 AM.
-
2018-04-09, 06:51 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2006
- Location
- London, England.
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
There's a big difference between a story that contains politics and a story that is politics.
Stories containing politics can absolutely be good. Game of Thrones is the obvious example, where most of the story is about the manoeuvring between the various factions. The key is that the politics is something that happens in the setting.
The problems start when you get a story that is a piece of politics, ie it's written in part or in whole as a piece of social/political advocacy. These tend to be pretty annoying if you don't share the author's opinions, and their overall quality also tends to be bad, since the events in the story are specifically chosen to prove the author correct. They also tend to steer away from hard questions or ambiguous morals (like the ones you get in, you know, real life).I'm the author of the Alex Verus series of urban fantasy novels. Fated is the first, and the final book in the series, Risen, is out as of December 2021. For updates, check my blog!
-
2018-04-09, 07:19 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2009
- Location
- In my library
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
As somebody trying to write a story that is written as semi-political allegory, it's hard to both keep it entertaining and keep it from strawmanning the other side. I've gone with an unrealistic setting that probably could not happen in real life (widespread ecological collapse by 2100) because it fits with the pro-science pro-trying to mitigate this stuff now angle I'm going with, but there's a lot of difficulties in keeping it good (one of the things is that the main character is essentially a police officer, and so unarmed, to reduce the ability to solve problems with 'and then they were shot'). It's still going to be heavily biased and probably hard to enjoy for those with opposing views, for the simple fact that I can't bring myself to promote views I dislike.
Now I understand that being too political tends to lead to being unentertaining, and the same happens when your force your politics at the reader
-
2018-04-09, 07:36 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2016
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
I think that people use the word 'political' to mean different things. Maybe it carries a subtly different meaning in different English speaking countries.
Some people use the word 'political' to refer to refer to the governance of a country or some smaller institution, and particularly the attempts to become the governing power within a democratic system. By that definition discussing the 2016 presidential campaign, or the merits of the Trump presidency would by political. But things like Star Wars, discussions on feminism, whether abortion should be legal (or a myriad of other stances on social issues), wars (although the reasons behind them can be connected to politics, and even discussion on the balance between taxation/public spending, is not political. This use of the word is consistent with the dictionary definition https://en.oxforddictionaries.com/definition/political
Others seem to use the word much more broadly - to refer to any discussion of a contentious social issue.Last edited by Liquor Box; 2018-04-09 at 07:37 AM.
-
2018-04-09, 07:55 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2012
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Hmm... can a story be entertaining and have Politics in it? Sure. There are plenty of stories which have explicit political themes and are rightfully heralded as timeless classics going all the way back to Antiquity. Of course there are also plenty of works which do it poorly, but the same claim can be made for works with no such pretensions as well.
RPG adventures though? That's more of a challenge. You of course can bring politics into a game setting and make it an important aspect of the story, having factions with different aims and philosophies that intermingle is part of the fun. To have anything coherent to say though beyond very simple acknowledgement of they existing would need a degree of authorial control which a traditional RPG doesn't really have.
You could say that, for instance, your post-capitalist cyberpunk dystopia has heavy anti-corporate themes implicit to it as a setting. To go beyond it merely being window-dressing though it needs something compelling in the narrative. As it's an RPG, it doesn't necessarily mean anything like that will happen or, at least, that it'll be at all incisive or interesting when it does, reducing it more to flavour than substance.
-
2018-04-09, 08:15 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2013
- Location
- The Chi
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Right, I recall how vapid and preachy Guilliver’s Travels and Alice in Wonderland were for their contemporary political angles. Off with their heads, indeed.
Also hated being tortured with the socialist propaganda of Grapes of Wrath, or the communist-hating 1984. Then there’s the liberal preachiness of Catch 22. I can’t believe that anyone ever found Atlas Shrugged to be any good, given its unabashed libertarian message by its Social Darwinist author.
Did I mention how “Cry, the Beloved Country” left me in tears from boredom, when I wasn’t ranting about how dare they turn a naked attack against apartheid into a novel?
Mark Twain’s anti-slavery screeds and other contemporary political commentary ruined his novels like “Huck Finn.”
While we’re at it, “A Handmaid’s Tale” was trash. In fact, the entire literary output by the politically concerned English-majors and anyone in English departments have not produced a single worthwhile piece of literature in the last half-century or so (ignore the Nobel Prize committee and international best sellers lists, what do they know).
Its good to know that social advocacy doesn’t belong in literature. It allows me to throw out a good portion of my personal library, and most of what I read in a college-level lit classes.
I suppose the political messages in “The Hunger Games” and the current crop of teen novels is just fine since there is no clear political advocacy to it. You know, I thought of “The Hunger Games” when I learned how housing and other welfare benefits in the United States are partial entitlements, which means only a fraction of the eligible poor get it or even how full entitlements keep narrowing their eligibility criteria. You know, how filling out eligibility forms, signing up for lotteries, and making certain (seemingly arbitrary or counterproductive) lifestyle choices becomes, in effect a literal game about warding off hunger.
Also this game often involving children, since eligibility and amounts depend on how many you have. I’ve even sponsored some in their annual battle to claim their children against rival claimants.
Now I just ruined the book.The laws of physics are not crying in a corner, they are bawling in the forums.
Thanks to half-halfling for the avatar
-
2018-04-09, 10:10 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2015
- Location
- San Francisco Bay area
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
@Cap'n Gravelock,
I'm not a moderator so my words are nowhere near official, but given some of the subject matter that you've mentioned in this and some others of your threads and are interested in, before you post much on them, it may be wise for you to re-read
Forum Rules
to decide what to post.
For more clarifications on those rules, you may wish to PM a Mod, or ask in the
Board/Site Issues subforum.
Good luck and best wishes.
-
2018-04-09, 11:37 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2013
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Ever Read Drury's Advise and Consent? It contains both of your categories, and is pretty good with it (the sequels much less so). It's also primarily about how much of politics is less about party than settling personal pique, ambition and general wang measuring, which makes the U.S. Congress much more understandable.
-
2018-04-09, 12:14 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2015
- Location
- San Francisco Bay area
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Took me a bit before I remembered my sarcasm language skills.
Anyway, some thoughts on some works you cited @Reddish Mage:
1984 (which I was assigned to read when it still took place in the "future") was one of the few novels that I can still remember the title of that I read for school that I didn't loalthe (unlike, for example The Great Gatsby, every character of which I despised).
Sadly while I was assigned it, I just don't remember Huck Finn very well, but on my own I read Twain's The Mysterious Stranger, which impressed me.
The Grapes of Wrath, movie I watched on a field trip to the Pacific Film Archive in Elementary school, and it shaped how I viewed my grandparents, but I didn't read the novel until I was sn adult with a child. I thought it was good, but not the page turner that Steinbeck's In Dubious Battle was, though to gamers I recommend Steinbeck's The Acts of King Arthur and His Noble Knights more.
-
2018-04-09, 12:57 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2006
- Location
- London, England.
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Too bad that none of those classes apparently covered more basic subjects, such as the meaning of the word 'tend'.
I haven't, but it does sound interesting. It's definitely possible to write advocacy that's also a good story, it's just that it's extremely rare. I usually find that a good litmus test for this kind of thing is "If I gave this book to someone who votes for a different political party, could they still enjoy it?"I'm the author of the Alex Verus series of urban fantasy novels. Fated is the first, and the final book in the series, Risen, is out as of December 2021. For updates, check my blog!
-
2018-04-09, 01:23 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2013
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
It's possible, but the more partisan you get, the trickier it is. Authors tend to lean towards 'what needs to happen to prove my point' over 'what would actually happen in this situation'.
I think To Kill a Mockingbird handles this well, it makes its point, but treats the characters fairly. Judge, Jury, Prosecutor, Racist Neighbour, Angry Mob, Mayella are all treated like people, not soapboxes or vehicles for other people to stand on soapboxes.
-
2018-04-09, 01:54 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2009
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Memoirs of a Nun by Diderot is fun to read.
Originally Posted by J.R.R. Tolkien, 1955
-
2018-04-09, 02:56 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2015
- Location
- San Francisco Bay area
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Enough Science Fiction authors that I've read have been outspoken enough that I know they vote "On the other side of the aisle" from me, but I still enjoy their work.
To get away from more recent examples, a hundred to one hundred and twenty years ago Chesterton, Kipling, London, Morris, and Wells each had very different political views, yet I still enjoy each.
-
2018-04-09, 03:22 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2009
- Location
- Germany
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
All spy fiction is inherently political.
We are not standing on the shoulders of giants, but on very tall tower of other dwarves.
Spriggan's Den Heroic Fantasy Roleplaying
-
2018-04-09, 03:46 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2013
- Location
- The Chi
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
{Scrubbed}
Last edited by Roland St. Jude; 2018-04-09 at 10:25 PM.
The laws of physics are not crying in a corner, they are bawling in the forums.
Thanks to half-halfling for the avatar
-
2018-04-09, 03:51 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
I'm with Reddish Mage here. There are stories ruined by hamfisted politics (Plague Dogs comes to mind, particularly given that Watership Down was a masterpiece, the Narnia series), but there's no shortage of politically themed stories that are interesting precisely because they're politically themed. At it's most simple politics is just how groups organize and act, and that's something of deep interest to our species.
I would really like to see a game made by Obryn, Kurald Galain, and Knaight from these forums.
I'm not joking one bit. I would buy the hell out of that. -- ChubbyRain
Current Design Project: Legacy, a game of masters and apprentices for two players and a GM.
-
2018-04-09, 04:00 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2012
- Location
- Tharggy, on Tellene
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
-
2018-04-09, 04:27 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2017
- Location
- France
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Yes, a thousand time yes.
Make your story interesting, make your characters likeable, don't demonize your opposition and you can put all the politics you want in a story.
It may even be better because you will be doing something you believe in.Forum Wisdom
Mage avatar by smutmulch & linklele.
-
2018-04-09, 05:30 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2013
- Location
- Twin Cities, Minnesota
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
I think part of the problem is when people think of political stories, there's a bias toward thinking first of the rambling screeds centering on some topic currently contentious in their culture in which the message was the chief aim and telling a compelling story...wasn't. It's also one of the more overt traps for amateur writers to fall into, when portrayal of the message as the ultimate inexorable correct victory is squarely in the way of the needs of the narrative or doesn't allow the narrative to breathe and be anything else but a track. Like so many things, such as the author inserting themselves as the protagonist, most people simply don't remember all the times this works.
Last edited by Legato Endless; 2018-04-09 at 05:31 PM.
-
2018-04-09, 05:44 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2009
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
The Robbers by Schiller also is fun.
Originally Posted by J.R.R. Tolkien, 1955
-
2018-04-09, 06:26 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2012
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Bioshock, which is blatant, in your face, beating you over in the head with the message anti-objectivism story that literally has you beat rule 63 Ann Ryand to death spawned a cult following and two sequels.
Black Panther, which is the most politically-charged movie MCu has ever produced, is now third highest-grossing movie in USA and changes are he might climb even higher.
Comcis industry has been redefined b Watchmen, an extremely political story that was a huge sucess. Alan Moore got a chance to write it by success of his earlier, extremely political story, V for Vendetta.
So I'd say that yes, they can.
-
2018-04-09, 06:31 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2016
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
I'd be interested in how many posters have found politically themed stories, that adhere to a political view they disagree with, to be interesting.
-
2018-04-09, 07:08 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2009
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
Objectivism is such a small thing though, I am surprised that anyone took the time to engage in anti-objectivism.
Originally Posted by J.R.R. Tolkien, 1955
-
2018-04-09, 07:50 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2015
- Location
- San Francisco Bay area
- Gender
Re: Can A Politically Themed Story Still Be Interesting
In Science Fiction?
Most definitely, and more interesting than stories that mirror my views.
Off the top of my head David Brin, Orson Scott Card, and Larry Niven, I agree with one or two politically, but I find the narratives of a different one or two more interesting.
No I'm not going to say which is which, because if I did....