Results 31 to 60 of 67
Thread: Does Charisma even make sense?
-
2018-05-20, 12:45 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2008
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
I'd call it more middling than low - there's a lot of games with 4 or 5, not to mention Tristat (which has exactly as many as the name implies). There's going to be some amount of lumping regardless of how many are used, it's just a matter of figuring out how you want to do that for a particular game.
I would really like to see a game made by Obryn, Kurald Galain, and Knaight from these forums.
I'm not joking one bit. I would buy the hell out of that. -- ChubbyRain
Current Design Project: Legacy, a game of masters and apprentices for two players and a GM.
-
2018-05-20, 09:25 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2010
- Location
- Dallas, TX
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
TOON has Muscles, Zip, Smarts, and Chutzpah, which are close to Strength, Dexterity, Intelligence and Charisma.
Constitution is not needed in a game in which your character walks back onscreen three minutes after losing all hit points, falling down, and getting X's in their eyes. And Wisdom is clearly unnecessary and unwanted for a toon.
-
2018-05-20, 09:32 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2011
- Location
- Cydonia
-
2018-05-22, 04:37 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2014
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Charisma, as illustrated by Dr. Dinosaur.
Dr. Dinosaur is absolutely self-centered and so immune to attacks against his world view. He is the stable fulcrum upon which his actions leverage.
He doesn't always make good decisions, though, he never makes mistakes
For more delightful Dr. Dinosaur:
http://www.atomic-robo.com/atomicrobo/v8fcbd-coverLast edited by cesius; 2018-05-22 at 05:09 PM. Reason: Clarification
-
2018-05-22, 06:47 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2014
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
I always saw charisma score as a characters base capacity to deal with other people.
the first half of the meaning of life is that there isn't one.
-
2018-05-22, 07:20 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2012
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
The same thing is true for Mayfair's DC Heroes RPG.
Dex/Str/Con
Int/Will/Mind
Influence/Aura/Spirit
And that's a good system if that is what is desired.
However, one of the big issues is making sure that each stat has something to do. In the DCH RPG, unfortunately "Mind" sort of doesn't do anything unless you're attacked by someone with mental powers. So, you have no way to tell even roughly how much Mind a fictional character has. (Technically, there is something about solving riddles, but it's a super obscure rule. And generally, the more "sane" someone is, the more Mind they are generally given, but the game has no way to connect sanity and Mind as game effects.)
But that's probably too much for D&D.
My issues with D&D's mental stats are that they started with "Wisdom is what clerics use", "Intelligence is what magic-users use," and "oh, yeah, charisma exists... we'll make paladins have lots of it." And that was pretty much it. However, while intelligence has obvious applications, "wisdom" is more nebulous, so it also helped with what would later be called Will saves. And then... they realized they forgot about perception. An issue of Dragon magazine (during the 1st edition days) suggested adding a Perception stat (and I did in my 1st edition games). So, when 3rd edition eventually came around, the game designers decided to add perception to the game... but unlike what Dragon suggested, they didn't just add a 7th stat. That would have been too radical. So, they just added it to an existing stat. And since intelligent people are typically the most perceptive people, they put perception abilities with... Wisdom? Okay, well, Wisdom doesn't do much of anything, so they were just throwing it a bone.
And so Wisdom (not Charisma) is the stat that makes no sense. It's a "will saves/perception/good at being a cleric" stat, none of which really goes together. So why is it all this stuff? Well, wisdom is the strength of your personality, so that's why it helps with Will saves. By the way, what is Charisma? It's the strength of your personality, which is why you can get people (and arcane forces, if you're a sorcerer) to do your bidding.
Uh-oh, there's this overlap. Force of Personality is two different stats, one which kind of makes sense (charisma) and one which doesn't (wisdom).
If I had the ability to redesign D&D's stats, here's what I'd do: (1) Dump Wisdom. It makes no sense. (2) Add a new ability score, "Perception". (3) Anything that used Wisdom for "force of personality" (Sorcerers, Paladins, Clerics, Will saves) will instead use Charisma. (4) Anything that used Wisdom for perception (various perception-related skills and monk's bonus to AC) would instead use Perception. Problem fixed.
Unless you want 9 stats so that you can have a version of DEX/STR/CON for both mental and social stats. Then, you still have more work to do.
-
2018-05-22, 07:59 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2013
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Exactly. D&D stats mostly don't make sense because later editions have given them a different purpose and meaning than what they were originally designed to do, or more accurately tacked-on new purposes instead of redesigning the system. D&D ability scores originally primarily describe "what class can you be", "do you get any extra HP", and "how many troops can you command". Every bit of detail added on top of that started breaking down the model, until you arrive where we are now, with stats that describe multiple unrelated things and no convincing way to make sense of the world this model describes.
-
2018-05-23, 12:37 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Shadowrun draws direct equivalences between the physical and mental stats, to the extent that the mental stats replace the corresponding physical stats in the astral. If your astral form punches another astral form, it's your Charisma you do damage with, and their Willpower that they soak the damage with.
The equivalences are:
Physical Mental Body Willpower Quickness Intelligence Strength Charisma
Body is basically Constitution. Quickness is basically Dexterity. Willpower is not the same thing as Wisdom, and IMAO makes more sense as a stat than Wisdom.Play your character, not your alignment.
-
2018-05-23, 05:58 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jan 2017
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
I guess I just don't see charisma as mental power like some of you.
To me, raw mental power is intelligence. Charisma sits more in the realm of social power to me.
-
2018-05-23, 06:30 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2016
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
In my favorite RPG, Savage Worlds, there are 5 main stats; Agility, Vigor, Smarts, Spirit, and Strength
Charisma is a flat mod to social skills and is modified by edges and hindrances like being attractive, a Noble, ugly, or having a serious personally flaw.
Force of personality falls under spirit and skills like persuasion are linked to smarts.
I don't have a problem with charisma in D&D, but it's not like I need it either.
-
2018-05-23, 09:54 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Location
- San Antonio, Texas
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
The Cranky Gamer
*It isn't realism, it's verisimilitude; the appearance of truth within the framework of the game.
*Picard management tip: Debate honestly. The goal is to arrive at the truth, not at your preconception.
*Mutant Dawn for Savage Worlds!
*The One Deck Engine: Gaming on a budget
Written by Me on DriveThru RPG
There are almost 400,000 threads on this site. If you need me to address a thread as a moderator, include a link.
-
2018-05-23, 10:28 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2016
- Location
- Corvallis, OR
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Dawn of Hope: a 5e setting. http://wiki.admiralbenbo.org
Rogue Equivalent Damage calculator, now prettier and more configurable!
5e Monster Data Sheet--vital statistics for all 693 MM, Volo's, and now MToF monsters: Updated!
NIH system 5e fork, very much WIP. Base github repo.
NIH System PDF Up to date main-branch build version.
-
2018-05-23, 11:57 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Part of the problem here, I think, is that "power" is such a vague term. I mean, why isn't Willpower the raw mental power stat? It's even got "power" in the name.
But if you break them down into Resistance, Speed and Finesse, and Affecting Others, this is obviously Con/Body, Dex/Quickness, and Strength on the Physical side.
Mental Resistance is obviously Willpower (D&D's Wisdom has been kind of crammed into this role, but it's a bad fit).
Mental Speed and Finesse? What lets you figure things out faster, come up with more creative solutions, and think outside the box? Seems like Intelligence to me.
And Affecting Others? Charisma. Yeah, it's social power, but "Social" is Mental Strength. It's how you apply your mental abilities to affect the world around you.Play your character, not your alignment.
-
2018-05-23, 05:25 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2005
- Location
- SW England
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
I've always felt the same.
IMO "Wisdom" is better thought of as the equivilent of "force sensetivity" in Star Wars.
It's essentially how attuned you are to the mystical forces of the universe, which is why it is the primary casting stat for divine spellcasters, the bonus stat for most monk abilities, protects you against mind control, and enhances your perception.
-
2018-05-23, 05:36 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- May 2016
- Location
- Corvallis, OR
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
In 5e D&D at least, it's not just sensitivity to the mystical, it's sensitivity to what's going on around you. Things it governs:
* Saving throws, mostly against mind-affecting or non-physical control.
* Ability checks:
Wisdom reflects how attuned you are to the world around you and represents perceptiveness and intuition.
Wisdom Checks
A Wisdom check might reflect an effort to read body language, understand someone’s feelings, notice things about the environment, or care for an injured person.
Other things:
* Intuitive feelings about which course to follow
* Tell whether something is undead.Dawn of Hope: a 5e setting. http://wiki.admiralbenbo.org
Rogue Equivalent Damage calculator, now prettier and more configurable!
5e Monster Data Sheet--vital statistics for all 693 MM, Volo's, and now MToF monsters: Updated!
NIH system 5e fork, very much WIP. Base github repo.
NIH System PDF Up to date main-branch build version.
-
2018-05-23, 05:42 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2013
- Location
- Paris, France
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
In simplified terms, the way I see it is: if the world is affecting your mind (noticing things, resisting mental assault), you're dealing with Wisdom. If you're using your mind to affect the world (dealing with other people, UMDing items), that's Charisma. And if you're looking at things stored inside your mind or happening inside your mind (knowing things, reasoning in abstract terms), Intelligence is what you want.
Avatar by Mr_Saturn
______________________
• Kids, watch Buffy.
Originally Posted by Bard1cKnowledge
Check out my extended signature and the "Gitp regulars as..." that I've been honored with!
-
2018-05-23, 05:49 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2011
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Would you have monks know how to avoid attacks based on how charismatic they are?
I'm pretty sure Strength affected how hard you hit, Dexterity affected how likely you were to avoid blows. I can't say before 2e whether Intelligence affected the number of languages you knew, or your chances of comprehending a scrap of arcane lore. But these don't feel like "breaking the model" to me. Now, granted, shoehorning intimidate into strength or charisma, and perception into intelligence or wisdom, may have issues. But I think ours a bit of an exaggeration to say that everything broke the system.
Same. In fact, IME, people who are good at convincing others are often rather... mentally deficient, especially in the realm of realizing when they are wrong. Charisma is, if anything, a force anti-multiplier (force divider?) to mental power.
Obviously, I disagree. Care to try to convince me of the merits of charisma as mental strength?
Same. And I've lived, if not at, then at least somewhere in proximity of both ends of that spectrum.
Personally, I apply my mental strength by writing code, solving algorithms, creating tactics and strategies.
When do I use charisma in determining a build order, or creating a TO character design? When do I use charisma solving a crossword puzzle or riddle or in Sudoku? When do I use charisma in calculating the effectiveness of a SoD spell, or weighing the design or tactical options for my Mech?
Charisma doesn't seem like mental strength from my experience.
-
2018-05-24, 06:33 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2007
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Tbh, all the stats are abstract or simplifications to a degree:
Strength: Doesn't differentiate between upper/lower body strength, body weight, and so on.
Dexterity: Encompasses fine manipulation, agility, contortionism, and reaction time.
Constitution: Encompasses resistance to many different diseases with very different effects, poisons, supernatural effects, endurance, breath holding...
Charisma: Attractiveness, force of personality, empathy, manipulation, acting ability, faith (in terms of powering Turn Undead).
Wisdom: Willpower, self-awareness, reasoning, faith (again)
Intelligence: Many, many different kinds, and also knowledge (and ability to actually apply it) plus linguistic ability.
All of these things could have their own stat! Reducing it to six means there is necessarily some generalisation and overlap present.
-
2018-05-24, 09:43 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2012
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
My D&D 5th ed. Druid Handbook
-
2018-05-24, 10:49 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2011
-
2018-05-24, 11:02 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
-
2018-05-24, 12:23 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2012
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
My D&D 5th ed. Druid Handbook
-
2018-05-24, 12:28 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2007
- Location
- San Antonio, Texas
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
As I said, some of it goes down to elegance of design... a clear correspondence between the physical and mental attributes. It ties in to the traditional uses of the ability; your Charisma affects how you influence people... how they take you in the instant, through Reaction checks, and how you affect them long term, through loyalty modifiers and maximum number of henchmen.
It's tempting to view Intelligence as Mental Strength... the horsepower your mind can bring to bear on the problem. And, if you do that, you might recast Charisma as mental dexterity... the ability to adapt yourself to others, making you more appealing. But I don't think that works as well. Intelligence is not just horsepower, but also parallel processing. Intelligence is being able to integrate multiple discrete thoughts into a single whole... Charisma is being able to mash a single idea into the space you want it to fit in other's heads.
Perhaps I missed a specific reference, here, but AD&D strength WAS how hard you hit, as well as how accurately. A 17 strength would give you a +1 to hit and +1 to damage in melee combat, as well as a set chance to open stuck doors, or to bend bars or lift portcullises.The Cranky Gamer
*It isn't realism, it's verisimilitude; the appearance of truth within the framework of the game.
*Picard management tip: Debate honestly. The goal is to arrive at the truth, not at your preconception.
*Mutant Dawn for Savage Worlds!
*The One Deck Engine: Gaming on a budget
Written by Me on DriveThru RPG
There are almost 400,000 threads on this site. If you need me to address a thread as a moderator, include a link.
-
2018-05-24, 12:55 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2009
- Location
- Boston, MA
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
-
2018-05-24, 01:13 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2011
- Location
- Sharangar's Revenge
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Warhammer 40,000 Campaign Skirmish Game: Warpstrike
My Spelljammer stuff (including an orbit tracker), 2E AD&D spreadsheet, and Vault of the Drow maps are available in my Dropbox. Feel free to use or not use it as you see fit!
Thri-Kreen Ranger/Psionicist by me, based off of Rich's A Monster for Every Season
-
2018-05-24, 01:27 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2012
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Ah, young man, young man. Sit thee down, and let us longbeards tell ye of how it was in the olden days. Not this newfangled stuff with 'advanced' or 'editions'.
Truth be told, I never played anything that old, but it was indeed the case in the earliest D&D versions that ability scores mattered a lot less, inluding not having direct effect on fighting (except maybe constitution?). Though I think dex gave a bonus to hit with ranged weapons.
Edit: Found a copy of the Basic Rules edited by Eric Holmes, and I ebelieve that's as old as it gets while still being called D&D. Dex did indeed affect missile attacks. 9-12 was neutral, above that +1 to hit, and below that -1. Con 18 gave +3hp per hit die. Prime requisites (you know, fighting man has strength, magic-user has int, etc.) affected XP by giving a bonus if it's high or a penalty if it's low. There's no mention I can find that strength affects to hit chance or damage dealt.Last edited by hymer; 2018-05-24 at 01:37 PM.
My D&D 5th ed. Druid Handbook
-
2018-05-24, 01:27 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Last edited by hamishspence; 2018-05-24 at 01:28 PM.
Marut-2 Avatar by Serpentine
New Marut Avatar by Linkele
-
2018-05-24, 01:54 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jun 2013
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Str was "how good you are at fighting/being a fighter"(via bonuses to hit and damage) and also how much stuff you can carry and opening doors. Somewhat but not totally related things. It's the least problematic.
Dex was how good of a thief you are via bonuses to thief skills, which includes moving silent, hiding and climbing as well as finding and removing traps, hearing noises and reading scrolls. There are at least 3 different categories of things there. On top of that, it gives a bonus to defense and to missile weapon attacks. These are mostly unrelated things in terms of actual abilities required- D&D makes it all one thing because it's all "thief stuff" (Bilbo the burglar is good at throwing stuff, remember).
-
2018-05-26, 06:48 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Oct 2011
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
So, I've been thinking about this. And, of course, being me, I'm looking at it as code.
To me, intelligence is the core of the code - how fast it runs, how complex the data it can process is, etc. What it can do.
Charisma is how pretty the interface is, how likely people are to accept it at a glance, and how likely they are to fall in love with it, and love it despite its faults.
But it's that last line of yours that gave me some pause. I couldn't quite figure out what to do with this notion of getting an idea to fit into others' heads.
I mean, yes, from a code standpoint, that's a matter of how robust and dynamic the interface is, to allow various programs to communicate with one another effectively.
But I finally realized that the real issue is focused around a single word: "mash".
Sure, there's the notion of trying to force an idea into someone's head. Prop up half a dozen supposedly respectable people on tv, have them use the exact same buzzwords over and over again, until it becomes part of everyone's thought process. It's a done thing, brute force insertion of ideas into the collective conscious.
But one on one, or even one on many, that's a bit harder. IME, the more common technique in such situations is to attempt to pair down the idea, modify the delivery to match the target audience. Make the idea relatable to the people you're talking to.
Someone who just keeps trying to eloquently shove an idea in where it doesn't go may have made their Charisma roll, but they failed something. From WoD, I'd say that they failed their Wits roll. Which then lets me tie communication into mental stats - specifically, mental agility. Whereas Charisma is social force.
However, if you're trying to force Charisma and Intelligence - two measures of force - into the roles of mental force and agility? Obviously, it's a tough call, and it's going to be a bad fit with some rough spots either way, but, as an introvert, I'm partial to keeping Intelligence internal power, and Charisma external agility. If you flip that to an extroverted stance, where what you care about is your impact on the outside world, I can see where the alternate casting would be appealing.Last edited by Quertus; 2018-05-26 at 08:01 AM.
-
2018-05-26, 10:48 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2006
- Location
- NYC
- Gender
Re: Does Charisma even make sense?
Charisma doesn't make sense.
Charisma makes pretty.
Intelligence makes sense.I want you to PEACH me as hard as you can.