Why Isn't Thor More Distressed

[Zenzis]

...that he used to be a slice of pizza?

He seems seriously irritated at becoming not a ginger, but I would think the extreme discomfort that would arise from transforming from a slice of pizza or cyberpunk chinchilla into a humanoid stick figure would be far more disturbing.

Assuming the ideas of gods throughout the worlds reflects the inhabitants somewhat, because of the belief thing. Otherwise other weird implications arise like how a world of milkshakes would feel about worshiping a fantasy stick figure or why the gods happened to match this world in particular.

[Morty]

Presumably because there was never a popular superhero comicbook that depicted him as a slice of pizza.

[Fyraltari]

Because he was a ginger pizza.
Obviously.

[Oracle_of_Void]

The real answer is that the whole food universe thing is a joke and should not be seriously considered.

[martianmister]

Because he never was a pizza.

[Gift Jeraff]

He was probably beer in any of the food-themed worlds.

[Zenzis]

Because he never was a pizza.

Yeah that seems fair.

The Southern Parthenon was probably a pizza. The northern gods seem more like an assortment of candies.

[martianmister]

In a world where foods are people, the gods are cooks.

[Mad Humanist]

In a world where foods are people, the gods are cooks.

This is the best response I've seen. More generally the last two strips strongly imply to me that the gods have always been humanoid. Most mortals are literally "made in the image of the gods". If they messed around long enough the gods' forms would change but not drastically in one world. The comment about the Thor comic tells us something I believed but should not necessarily be taken too seriously as it may be breaking the 4th wall.

[zimmerwald1915]

ginger pizza

I can't decide whether this would be pleasant or disastrous.

The Internet suggests the former.

[Anymage]

I think the bit with Odin really underlines the point.

Changing into an anthropomorphic animal form willingly because you're making an anthro world is something that's under your control, and as such you can change back pretty much any time you like. When accumulated mortal belief makes a change to your essence, that takes a lot more work to undo. Changing your hair color is minor compared to being turned into a simpleton, but it reminds you just how vulnerable to change you are.

[kivzirrum]

I can't decide whether this would be pleasant or disastrous.

The Internet suggests the former.

I can confirm that ginger on pizza is A+.

[Fyraltari]

I didn't know that ginger pizza was a thing (though I am not very surprised to find out).
I had in fact forgotten that ginger was also the name of a food.

Suffice to say, I am more than pleased with this development.

[Cicciograna]

He IS a pizza. And at the same time he's a blonde humanoid resembling a human wielding a hammer.

My take on it is that gods are not actual, physical beings, but more akin to concepts: just as Belief determine their intellect and faculties, the belief of their worshippers determine their physical manifestation to them.
In the food universe, the Belief of his worshippers shaped him into a form that was suitable to them, so maybe a pizza (or a beer, as it was suggested before).
In a hypothetical marine world with intelligent narwhals, dolphins and sharks, he would probably have the shape of, dunno, a hammerhead shark

Spoiler

Show

Don't take this answer as too serious

[KorvinStarmast]

In a hypothetical marine world with intelligent narwhals, dolphins and sharks, he would probably have the shape of, dunno, a hammerhead shark

Spoiler

Show

Don't take this answer as too serious

I see what you did there, and it made me grin.

[denthor]

He IS a pizza. And at the same time he's a blonde humanoid resembling a human wielding a hammer.

My take on it is that gods are not actual, physical beings, but more akin to concepts: just as Belief determine their intellect and faculties, the belief of their worshippers determine their physical manifestation to them.
In the food universe, the Belief of his worshippers shaped him into a form that was suitable to them, so maybe a pizza (or a beer, as it was suggested before).
In a hypothetical marine world with intelligent narwhals, dolphins and sharks, he would probably have the shape of, dunno, a hammerhead shark

Spoiler

Show

Don't take this answer as too serious

But would he be an acid living shark?

Since any hack can write a source book.

[hroþila]

In a hypothetical marine world with intelligent narwhals, dolphins and sharks, he would probably have the shape of, dunno, a hammerhead shark

Surely Nergal would be the narwhal. NARWHAL OF DEATH.

[GloatingSwine]

...that he used to be a slice of pizza?

Because dude, Pizza.

The real answer is that the whole food universe thing is a joke and should not be seriously considered.

Won't you look silly when the official OOTS/Aqua Teen Hunger Force crossover happens.

[Snails]

I think the bit with Odin really underlines the point.

Changing into an anthropomorphic animal form willingly because you're making an anthro world is something that's under your control, and as such you can change back pretty much any time you like. When accumulated mortal belief makes a change to your essence, that takes a lot more work to undo. Changing your hair color is minor compared to being turned into a simpleton, but it reminds you just how vulnerable to change you are.

I would suggest that such is a fundamental Rule of Magic: the more magical you are the more deeply vulnerable you become.

Example: The Djinn that can bestow wishes but is ruled by the owner of a lamp.
Example: The devil that can be bound and commanded to obey.
Example: The god whose hair color can be changed by a comic book.
Example: The god who could be mentally befuddled for a thousand years by a mediocre game supplement from >35 years ago.

[Windscion]

Thor is like, a billion years old at this point. He's seen some stuff in his day. Hard to think what would phase him.
Plus, y'know, he's a god.

[Mith]

Keep in mind that Thor also dressed up as Freya to marry Thrym in order to get his hammer back. It's one of m favourite stories.

[Mad Humanist]

Keep in mind that Thor also dressed up as Freya to marry Thrym in order to get his hammer back. It's one of m favourite stories.

I had forgotten that. It makes it so interesting that the Giant would pick that up as a motivation for Thrym to ally with Hel.

[Jasdoif]

Surely Nergal would be the narwhal. NARWHAL OF DEATH.

Nergwhal, the Bringer of Death with a Point.

[Mordaedil]

I had forgotten that. It makes it so interesting that the Giant would pick that up as a motivation for Thrym to ally with Hel.

Didn't Thor murder everyone after that took place?

[Fyraltari]

Didn't Thor murder everyone after that took place?

I think that Mad Humanist meant that in both stories Thrym gets involved because he wants to marry an Asgardian Goddess, Hel here, Freya there.

[sillymel]

Nergwhal, the Bringer of Death with a Point.

Wait. Woah, woah, woah. Are you saying Nergal had a point?

[Jasdoif]

Are you saying Nergal had a point?

Nergwhal would be an unconvincing narwhal without one.

[Aeson]

Nergwhal would be an unconvincing narwhal without one.

Unless Nergwhal, unlike Nergal, is female, or at least chooses to take a feminine form.

[Jasdoif]

Unless Nergwhal, unlike Nergal, is female, or at least chooses to take a feminine form.

Choosing not to have a tusk would be the "unconvincing narwhal" part. Seriously, 15% occurrence of tusks in female narwhal means it's not a particularly rare occurrence.

[rbetieh]

silly follow on question?

Lets say a Trickster god wanted to troll Thor...
If he were to change the depiction of Thor to always wearing a purple polka-dot tutu and Groucho Marks glasses, how many generations would it take for Thor to start doing that?