Results 601 to 630 of 1478
Thread: Goblins
-
2009-02-10, 11:05 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Location
- Canada
- Gender
Re: Goblins
Oh God. The piling in begins. I thought I had left this behind by not posting in Thunt's forum anymore.
The point is that I am not doing any thing dispicable. I occasionally make some critical posts in one thread, not bashing posts. They are not to bash, I'm just giving criticism. You can see the difference if you look at the Dominic Deagen thread.
No, some people do bad. I am not doing bad. I gave valid criticism. A person need not apologize for that.
No, that's not it at all. I meant that my post hurts him because he knows better, he knows I am offering valid criticism. It's not because anything I say is inherintly mean or wrong. The people that do that, are people he can ignore because they don't have anything worthwhile to say.
As for convincing... Well, that is a two way street, isn't it? I've argued with him before. He wanted to reply to my original post. Unlike him, I can certainly be convinced if I understand the picture more clearly but he doesn't want to do that.
Wait, I have to be fair. I simply disagree with some stuff. Like he NEEDS to do two or 3 pages at once for a better story. Nothing anyone can say can make me agree with that and further I see this insistence as being directly harmful to his business. However, that being said, I DO try to see it from the other person's point of view.
On the other hand, know he won't listen to me no matter how detailed an argument I give but that doesn't mean I am going to lower myself to his level and simply give a rant. A dishonest rant at that.
So he gets hords of angry fans... Why are you picking on me? The more logical goal would be to focus on posts that are in his face on the GOBLIN'S message board instead of searching out every forum where something negative has been said. I was chased off of it, so that strategy works.
Now... we disagree on this point. Strongly. I think if he really cared about his fans he would set realistic goals. Because any author knows that when he creates a promise and doesn't keep it it makes people upset. Fans are much less likely to get upset when you don't mislead them. Take Erfworld. They used to say updates twice a week. They frequently missed that goal. Fans kept getting mad so they switched the goal to whenever. The fans are now content. See the difference?
Isn't that you calling the kettle black? You are not exactly being a gracious poster and Thunt certainly was not being polite and reasonable.
Perhaps I am more aggressive then I should be but I edit quite a lot. I thought I was being sufficiently polite given his post, which was nothing but a mean spirited rant.
Perhaps I'll be told that this post was too aggressive as well. I really can't tell. Looks fine as I reread it though. That's the best I can do.
My point was that Thunt told me I was off base with everything. Clearly, I was not. I also got chewed out in his forum for strongly advocating these things in the past. They were wrong. I, and others that felt the same way, was right. Why should I not feel some satisfaction from that? So what if others said the same things? I don't care why he did it, only that he realized the sense.
You misunderstand, I know he does two pages as well as one. The point is that he will not skip a week to do a long update anymore. He wants one update a week. That is a change from how he was.
Thunt has already made the crucial switch by moving his archives into a one page per click format. I just think he should finish it by sticking with only one page when he updates. It all comes out the same in the end.
Not saying he should.
That's what a buffer is for. Thunt is one man. One. Kender helps with coloring but he is doing this alone. He has to come up with a reasonable level of arrtwork and keep it consistent. Then he would have more time to do his job and do other things in his spare time.
You said it, not I. This is the worry though. Is he able to make goblins his "business"? I don't see it. It's actually looking bad from my perspective.
Well, I like complaining about what I don't like. Especially if I think it can be better. Doesn't everyone? I also have ideas. It's fun when people agree with them. I don't care for all of this arguing though. Normally, when this happens I make a few posts and then stop reading the thread because it just gets too much for me. I got sick of mostly getting piled on over at Thunt's forums so I stopped posting there. If I liked to argue, I could have just kept on.
blastwave is a good comic
*sigh*
This is my problem. I am regarded as some piece of fluff. What I say is irrelevant because the readers see it as nothing but entertainment. I actually mean what I say. I believe in the correctness of my views. I'd suggest HC, that you are looking at my posts in the wrong way.
Besides, this is hardly my drama. I made one critical post and now I am getting jumped on. People want to come on over from the other forum. I don't see this kind of piling on for other people that wanted to say something less then flattering about Thunt on this board. If my tone is worse then it w3was, perhaps it's because Thunt got worse. He has continued to promise more and deliver less. you have watched him for years, as I have. Am I wrong? Look at his archives, there are indisputably less updates over the years and they got smaller.
I said that taking a break, would not change anything unless he changed the way he worked. He did not and things got worse, so my tone got more shrill.
If an argument is right, then it's right. Just because I say the same things doesn't mean that it's somehow become irrelevant.
I'm criticizing, not talking smack. There is a difference.
I feel like I am right. Why should I talk as if I am wrong. Is that how you talk? Do you not have opinions that you feel are better then prevailing wisdom.
I say the same things because it's the same issues that come up. No mystery there.
If I did it for the attention why am I posting here? I post here to I don't get the raved fanboys tearing me alive. I don't feel that I get a fair shake. I have heard little to say I am wrong in my opinions when I do. I'll consider it.
I never said he wasn't but missing an average of one update in four is hardly "good" for a man that has made this his job AND who promised to do much, much better in the years leading up to this.
I believed Thunt when he said that. I honestly thought he would get consistent updates on time. Just another broken promise. I suppose I am a bit bitter about it. *shrugs*
This is why I have been pointing out that the new age started on November 15th. Thunt quit his job and made his big announcement on Saturday, September 20, 2008. Remember the drawing marathon? He had almost 2 months for the moving in to his new home. I'm not even counting that. Why? because that would be totally unfair. He told us updates would be spotty. I appreciated that. I don't hold it against him.
For your sake, I really do but it's been three months now and I don't see anything encouraging to be confident in that opinion, which is why I made a critical post for the first time in, like six months? More? This isn't exactly something I do frequently anymore.Last edited by tomaO2; 2009-02-10 at 11:41 PM. Reason: felt I was too strong in an opinion I gave.
-
2009-02-10, 11:21 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2006
- Gender
-
2009-02-10, 11:45 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2007
Re: Goblins
We kid because we love.
See here's the thing your criticism is your opinion, but you act as if it is absolutely the right thing to do when what works for you doesn't necessarily work for anyone else. Instead of just leaving it out there you continue on about how, "I take a large measure of satisfaction that he finally realized that I had the right of the matter." So for all the good you could be doing you just come off really smug and condescending regardless of the intent.
Though it's interesting to hear about the "hordes of people" defending thunt's so called "mistakes". If that is happening then perhaps what he is doing is working.Last edited by Twin2; 2009-02-10 at 11:46 PM.
-
2009-02-11, 12:09 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2008
Re: Goblins
Awww, the poor minotaur.
Two by two, hands of blue.
-
2009-02-11, 12:17 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Location
- Canada
- Gender
Re: Goblins
I loved Goblins once and I wanted to give suggestions to make it better. You "kid" just for the sake of it. How is that better?
I get this argument a lot. I don't understand it though. Never have. I believe it's the right thing. I say why I believe it's the right thing. What else should I do? If I am wrong, I try hard to be open to that but I don't get the idea of sabotaging your own ideas by not making the strongest case you can for them. Especially when you make your first post.
As for being sastisfied with the result... Well, why not? I got hounded for what I've said. This isn't me stating these things for the first time. It's kind of like an "I told you so" at this point. I get treated like a pariah but can't enjoy some vindication?
You don't know what it's like. You go into the Dominic Deagen forum. You say it's crap. Everyone praises you for saying so and you log off, all satisfied. I would love that kind of consensus too but it seems my views are usually contrary to popular opinion, so I have to suffer the consequences of that. It's not fun. I am quite earnest in my beliefs though. I don't say things that people respond to for lols.
Finally, hoards of fans following the party line is not a sign that things are going right, in my opinion. I have read numerous times how an author allowed himself to get caught up in people saying how good he was on his own forum. They would stifle dissent. The artist never improved. They only got better when they take an outside opinion and realize that maybe, just maybe, that person has a point.Last edited by tomaO2; 2009-02-11 at 12:22 AM. Reason: spelling and editing
-
2009-02-11, 12:41 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Gender
Re: Goblins
Indeed. Mind if we steal that quote for posteriority?
Anyway, back on topic, TomaO2 is indeed offering valid criticism, and while many readers still support Thunt unconditionally, there many many others that have been put out of goblins altogether because of the erratic update schedule. Sure, his opinions are right and conflicting ones are wrong, but so does everyone. The whole reason while they are your opinions is because you think that it is right. You never hear anyone saying, "hey I have a wrong opinion about this". TomaO2 is no different, and although he does sound smug about it sometimes, it still is valid and reasonable polite criticism. The answers to him, not so much...
Ok, going back to the point again, Twin2, one webcomic having "hordes of people defending one's mistake" proves absolutely nothing about the quality of such webcomic. Not to cite names, as quality is very subjective, but no matter what webcomic, no matter how bad it is, how *expletive* awful it is, no matter, there will be still be fans giving unconditional love to the comic and it's author. It may be a small fraction of the internet, but there is a LOT of people in the internet, even in the webcomic "turf".
While I don't believe any of us do prefer erratic and sporadic update schedules, many will tolerate if the webcomic is of their liking, indeed. But I don't think it's hard to see why such thing is a bad business model. If this just were thunt hobby, while it is a little annoying updates that sporadic, it wouldn't be that bad. I can't deny, Thunt does put a lot of work on his webcomic, but that's not the point. When making a business out of webcomics, it's, to some extent, more important to keep a reliable schedule than to have perfect art. Not to say it need to be a fast schedule. Though such thing is nice, even having a bi-weekly schedule and keeping it will help to reduce the flak and keep fans happy.
This all, said, yes I do like Goblins a lot. It's a very nice webcomic, even with the erratic nature. But still not a good business model as it currently is. If it were just a hobby, and didn't made schedule promises that he couldn't keep, I wouldn't even be posting this. I would be defending Thunt, as he would be doing it just because he felt like and didn't said that there would be updates every (something)day. Heck, I do like and keep reading such as Dragon Mango, and it updates every once in a blue moon, though I only actually check it once every a blue moon as well... I even check Elf Only Inn and Legendary (hint, hint :P) every so ofter just to see if some miracle happened and they started updating again...
Anyway, I wrote somewhat a lot, and it got a little redundant with current tomaO2 post, but I'm not going to let all the time I took to write this post go to waste...
Quick edit: Just found by complete accident a quite nice text relevant to the debate and arguing. Quite a nice reading and very valid points:
http://www.zompist.com/arguing.html
Also, if you allow me a quote:
Someone (unfortunately I forget who) mentioned that the best thing an academic can have is a good enemy. Your friends will, perhaps, read through your papers and make a few comments. But only an enemy will read through an entire book, for free, finding every error and questionable statement.
-
2009-02-11, 01:00 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2007
Re: Goblins
This is apples and oranges really. You're giving your opinion, and we're pulling a MST3K. They are two entirely different things really.
Perhaps it's you. For all the good you're trying perhaps you are wrong about this. That's something you need to be asking yourself if you are constantly experiencing the same thing over and over again.
Seriously go look at the archives of the original deegan threads. People enjoyed the comic, and even in the new threads some still do (I do enjoy some of them myself), but for all of that the main thing is that everyone is being respectful in their opinions and having fun doing it. It seems like that element is missing somewhere here.
But then again people saying it is good can be right as well. Honestly I feel for you, but you've got to distance yourself a bit here. You've posted your opinions, the author has theirs which don't match them so the best you can do is ironically enough hope for the best.
True, I guess it's just part of me that dislikes always hearing that "all these people liking this are wrong" phrase being tossed about. I guess I get caught up the the shouting match mentality of it all.Last edited by Twin2; 2009-02-11 at 01:12 AM.
-
2009-02-11, 02:15 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2006
- Gender
-
2009-02-11, 04:45 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2006
- Location
Re: Goblins
I feel the need to apologize to Toma, because while I do disagree on a few key points, I can recognize the spirit of criticism. I don't think I ever noticed people hounding you/him back when he used to participate in the goblins forums... and I didn't mean to imply by "Toma drama" that it was purely of his own machination. Merely that it was drama dragged back up because toma started being tomaishly critical again.
Really toma, put some points in charisma. Your entire tone of writing doesn't help you at all, and apparently that's when editted.
In Thunt's defense for his response, from what I've heard from him in the feed he is feeling incredibly stressed by all the people disappointed and angry at him for being so late.
I'm a bit confused though... when you say "missed updates" you simply mean late correct? Because of note, while he's often still late, he IS updating more often than he was before the change.
EDIT: I feel inclined to state also, regarding my "no offense" example. The characters involved really DIDN'T mean any offense, they were simply stating the truth as they saw it as part of conversation and they weren't doing so in a mean way, they were actually trying to help the party involved. But it was still pretty much talking bad, and the third party still took offense after it was done enough.Last edited by High-Chancellor; 2009-02-11 at 05:09 AM.
I had a witty quote, but it was too long, so you get this instead.
-
2009-02-11, 05:40 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2007
- Location
- West Midlands, UK.
Re: Goblins
I know what you mean, Hands of Blue. To be fair, he's probably going to be happier where he is now then he was in GS's dungeons.
"It doesn't matter what you think I'm supposed to be, 'cause I myself know all too well." Line from "King of My World" by Saliva.
Good itP 2009 winner,Cleric itP Winner.
Taking Reiki requests. PM me for details.Spoiler
-
2009-02-11, 11:05 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Location
- Charlottesville
- Gender
-
2009-02-11, 11:55 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Dec 2004
- Location
Re: Goblins
Hark! An avatar drawn by Kate Beaton!
-
2009-02-11, 01:16 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Location
- Charlottesville
- Gender
Re: Goblins
No, no. That's efficiency. Ctrl-Alt-Del is efficient.
On the side of drawing, and slow updates, can I point to this comic? Lots of fun detail, big pictures, and didn't take a week to draw. Now, I know that different artists are going to have different skill levels, and I also know that Pete is one of the best out there, so maybe the comparison is a little unfair. But still, does it really take over 100 hours to draw two pages of Goblins? It seems slow.Last edited by Sholos; 2009-02-11 at 01:26 PM.
Tali avatar by the talented Thormag.
-
2009-02-11, 02:29 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2007
-
2009-02-11, 04:16 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Location
- Charlottesville
- Gender
-
2009-02-11, 04:36 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2006
- Location
- Almonte, ON, Canada
- Gender
Re: Goblins
This whole conversation makes me really, really glad I don't care about how fast updates come out. Like, at all. I mean, I like reading Goblins. I enjoy the updates. But, despite that, Goblins is such a small part of my life. I have school. I have work. I have video games. If there isn't a Goblins comic? Big woop, I can do something else. I'll read it when it comes out. I just don't base my life around when some webcomic gives an update. Not that it applies to Goblins only -- I'm a big OotS fan, but Rich could go on an unplanned hiatus for two weeks and I honestly wouldn't care. Same with SMBC.
Perhaps it's because I've been in his shoes, writing episodic content that started to slip very much from what I planned. It may seem like a simple solution to say "Sorry guys, it's gonna be late." But, when you've done that the last three times too, you just can't. It kills you. You're going out there into the crowd of people that are waiting with baited breath, and you have to tell them to their face, "Er... maybe later?" It really is harder than it might sound, and so very much easier to just hide and hope they don't tear into you too much. Overall, it's just super-stressful to be late and knowing there are so many people waiting. Even the people encouraging you and saying, "I can wait, it's OK. I know you'll get us something."... that starts to hurt too, the feeling that you're letting the NICE guys down too. It's all very discouraging and painful. I feel it's the least I can do to just wait silently, really.
I guess I'm not trying to really defend or justify either of us here. I just thought I could give a clearer view of the other side -- of course, Thunt may not be like me at all. *shrug*My PMV's! Youtube Channel
Newest: La Da Dee (PMV)
Other notables:
Spoiler-Hero (PMV)
-Cutie Mark Chronicles -- Theatrical Trailer (Winner of the BroNYCon 2011 September PMV contest!)
-Pinkie Sparrow
-Party of One -- Theatrical Trailer
-Faint (PMV)
-Canterlot Wedding -- Theatrical Trailer
-Crystal Empire -- Theatrical Trailer
-Come and Get It (PMV)
-
2009-02-11, 06:01 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Aug 2006
- Location
- sector ZZ9 plural-z alpha
- Gender
Re: Goblins
This. I have a lot of webcomics I read, and some of them update very infrequently. I don't mind. It's awesome when there's an update, but if I have to wait a bit for one, that's ok. Same with the video game industry. Sometimes games get pushed back. Delays happen. That's alright. It just means the final product will be more polished, more complete, and more in line with the level of quality we've come to expect from comics such as Goblins. Infrequent updates don't make an awesome thing any less awesome.
I used to do LP's. Currently archived here:
My Youtube Channel
The rest of my Sig:
SpoilerAvatar by Vael
My Games:
The Great Divide Dark Heresy - Finished
They All Uprose Dark Heresy - Finished
Dead in the Water Dark Heresy - Finished
House of Glass Dark Heresy - Deceased
We All Fall Down Dark Heresy - Finished
Sea of Stars Rogue Trader - Ongoing
-
2009-02-11, 07:40 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Feb 2007
- Gender
Re: Goblins
I believe no one here is arguing that the schedule problems makes goblins a bad webcomic. It doesn't. It still is a terrific webcomic, one of the best comics in the internet. Still it is both a little annoying for those who want to keep with the story, but more importantly, it's a bad business model.
Employees might be payed on a per-hour basis, but Thunt is a freelancer here. It doesn't matter at all how much time he works on the comic, just what is delivered. This might sound harsh, but sadly is the truth. People won't care if you have worked on a single page 30 hours or 3 hours, they will just see it's final quality.
Also, it doesn't matter for you if Thunt goes on Hiatus, but it does matter for one person. Thunt himself. As the webcomic is his main (and possibly only) income source, a Hiatus will really hurt him, as people won't visit so often, won't give him ad-views, are very less likely to donate, and for all reasons, are likely to result in delays in books which he could sell.
-
2009-02-12, 02:04 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2006
- Location
Re: Goblins
Which is probably the main reason he CAN'T really build a buffer. The level of quality he expects and wants to get for his updates wont let him.
And I think I may have said it before, but in any case I'll say it again.
Making something lower quality just to produce more of it doesn't make things more awesome, it makes things LESS awesome. Lots of people eat McDonalds, but that doesn't mean they think it's great food. This is why places like Red Robin and TGI fridays and the various steakhouse and grill restaurants stay in business. It's more expensive, and the food takes longer, but so much better that it becomes worth it.
Not that I'm saying it would be a bad comic if it was more cheaply produced, but it would definitely be noticeably of lower quality.I had a witty quote, but it was too long, so you get this instead.
-
2009-02-13, 12:36 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Location
- Charlottesville
- Gender
Re: Goblins
Again, it may be a bit unfair, but I point to Sluggy Freelance. If Pete only produced one page a week, but still kept his same production, he'd have a huge buffer. I find it hard to believe that Thunt is that much worse of an artist. If so, I think I'll have to attribute it more (or entirely) to Pete just being supremely epic.
Tali avatar by the talented Thormag.
-
2009-02-13, 01:17 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2006
- Location
Re: Goblins
No offense to Pete, because he does a great job, but his artwork is more shapeless and far less detailed than Thunts in general. For instance the eyes, and faces in general. Petes eyes are generally just a few lines to give the impression of expression. Thunt actually draws eyeballs with defined shapes to them. Pete's faces are basically a human thumb with some eyes and a mouth in different expressions thrown on, Thunt's faces are pretty much made of sillypuddy with how much they stretch and change when portraying different emotions, with a lot more depth to the noses/cheeklines/bonestructure etc.
It doesn't really compare.
Thunt HAS drawn more simplistic stuff before, and granted he pumps it out a lot faster, but it wouldn't have the same emotive qualities and epic feel if he did so I do not think.I had a witty quote, but it was too long, so you get this instead.
-
2009-02-13, 01:47 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Mar 2006
- Location
- Charlottesville
- Gender
Re: Goblins
And yet, Pete's artwork conveys an amazing amount of emotion. I think that it goes to show that too much detail runs into the diminishing returns wall.
Thunt HAS drawn more simplistic stuff before, and granted he pumps it out a lot faster, but it wouldn't have the same emotive qualities and epic feel if he did so I do not think.
Both of those are what I'd call epic, and both have a ton of emotion in them. In fact, I'd say those strips (well, that specific arc, really) is a lot more epic and a lot more emotional than what Goblins has done so far.
There's also the pacing. The sheer slowness of Goblins makes the epicness seem less, as well as the emotional impact. At least, it does for me.
So, all in all, I'd say Thunt puts a little too much detail in his work.Tali avatar by the talented Thormag.
-
2009-02-13, 02:11 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Nov 2006
- Gender
Re: Goblins
His use of black and white is pretty good, as well as his use of lighting, but his figures could definitely use some work. They often look stiff, flat, or unnaturally posed. His shading and perspective could use a bit of work as well, since they do basically the same thing to his art as my first point. I mean, it's not bad, I enjoy comics with worse art, it's just kind of mediocre.
As for the emotion and epic: First let me justify my criticism; I don't read Sluggy Freelance (though I have tried. No particular gripes about it, but it really is very unfriendly to new readers, and I haven't felt like putting the effort in. I suppose I'll read it someday, just because a lot of people seem to like it.) As such, these two pages are the only samples that I have of his art, so I might be off base here.
This comes of as pretty unsubtle; the situation seems as or more important than the art in conveying the emotion of the scene, and the rest comes from the color being composed in such a way that it is obviously supposed to be very emotional. (Which is to say, he uses a lot of black.) I mean, unsubtle drama isn't inherently bad, but if it's an artist's only trick then that artist is, in my opinion, still in need of work. Thunt has used this trick to invoke emotion, but he can also do so in lots of subtle ways. As I said, I could be wrong on this point, as I have a relatively small sampling of the comic, but it honestly isn't very impressive as far as that goes.
-
2009-02-13, 02:47 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Apr 2006
- Location
Re: Goblins
If you think either of those scenes is more emotional OR epic than... for instance... Kore killing Taps, I don't think we're ever going to reach common ground on this.
In any case, aside from average joe making excellent points (Though I DO enjoy sluggy freelance, or did for a long while rather) I feel I must clarify my point, because I don't seem to have conveyed it accurately.
Thunt's actual portrayed character emotions generally have more depth and expression than Pete's, who relies more on story pacing/tone and lighting to convey his depth.
Thunt also generally uses more dynamic positioning and poses. But averagejoe touched on that.
Which is nothing against Pete, he's a good artist and has refined his drawing style for his comic fairly well. But I don't find the comparison fair at all. Apples and oranges.I had a witty quote, but it was too long, so you get this instead.
-
2009-02-13, 05:37 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
- Location
- France
- Gender
Re: Goblins
There is no doubt in my mind that if Thunt used a simpler style, he could pull off several updates a week. He could even draw more updates while redrawing the previous ones, every week.
But is it something he should do? One of the strength of Goblins is the amount of detail and the cinematic angles, zooming in and out and such. If Sluggy Freeland or the Order of the Stick were a movie, Goblins would be a 3D movie. It's just different, and special.
If Thunt had started the webcomic that way, it would be one thing. But he's drawing it this way. His fans are people who like his art, the colouring, the special effects. People who can appreciate the shine on earrings, armour or swords. And more importantly, that's the way Thunt wants to do it, to tell his story, and that makes it the way it should be told. He's the author.
I strongly believe that the best possible style for the Order of the Stick is the style Rich Burlew chose, and I believe just as strongly that Thunt's style is the best possible style for Goblins.
Each page, no, each panel of the comic is a work of art that has enough to feed the eyes for up to hours. It just annoys me that so many people demand a new update when they haven't really finished reading the old one.
It just feels like they're getting a piece of cake, take a bit and then demand a new piece of cake. Why don't you finish the one that's on your plate? If you just want to know what's happening, get someone else to read the story when it's done and give you a summary. If you want to read a graphic novel, remember that it's a graphic novel.
Note that I am not insulting the other artists. The Order of the Stick is still my favourite webcomic (sorry Tarol. You're still sexier than Rich though), and I applaud Burlew's decisions regarding his webcomic, because it works.
And I do think a story is more important than art, but by that, I mean that a story will keep me there even if the art is only average, not that the art SHOULD be average. If the art is great, I'm not going to ask the artist to do a less great job so I can read the story faster.
So yes, Thunt would be faster if his style was different, but it's not. And he's a perfectionist, he already doesn't detail things as much as he'd want to, especially the colouring (although it might be the case for the drawing as well. I wouldn't know, but I can't imagine him detailing things more).
I don't want Thunt to draw things differently. I want to still be able to feel textures and materials when I look at his comic. I want to be able to recognise the guards from one update to the next even when there are many of them. I want to look at Nail and wonder how the fur would feel on his ears.
I've always said that I think Goblins work better as books that as a webcomic. But I've not sure if it's true anymore. Having one week to look at each update actually helps give it the attention it needs. And it's even better when you can watch it being worked on :)
-
2009-02-13, 12:15 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2008
Re: Goblins
I hate to be an echo chamber, but I think some things that have been said bear repeating, at least because I share those feelings too. I do wish their would be more frequent updates, If only because I'm totally hooked on the story and I can't wait for the complete series to come out on book. I disagree with Lissou in that I do think Goblins would work better as a nice size book that I could hold in my hands and peruse at my leisure, taking the time to really, really appreciate the detail that Thunt has packed into this story. Because he has. Packed in detail, that is.
Spoilers ahead!
Remember when GS discovers Caine's body? Everything about that strip, GS's position, the look on his face as it changed from confusion and disbelief, to grief, to grief and rage... it was just epic. GS is a thoroughly despicable character, but for one moment, just one moment, I felt sorry for this guy who had just lost his best friend.
For another example, take the whole sequence at the Viper clan camp when the tent fell. Or any battle scene. Thunt is great with packing emotive detail into scenes with lots of characters without having the whole scene become a confused mess. Are there any other webcomics that combine that level of non-stylized affect with dynamic body postures and realistic panel-to-panel consistency? Please tell me so I can get addicted to them too.
Okay, now that I've gushed all over the place, I want to note that it would be economically practical for Thunt to produce more stuff faster, as he could have more site visits and ad views, and more material for merchandise. I don't like the notion that he has to choose one or the other (quality or quantity) and wish there could be a happy balance.
-
2009-02-13, 01:24 PM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2007
- Location
- West Midlands, UK.
Re: Goblins
Ironically, my reaction to GS discovering Saril's corpse was "I hope you have 10,000 GPsworth of diamonds and a level 13 Cleric handy". I know what you mean about how things are drawn, though.
"It doesn't matter what you think I'm supposed to be, 'cause I myself know all too well." Line from "King of My World" by Saliva.
Good itP 2009 winner,Cleric itP Winner.
Taking Reiki requests. PM me for details.Spoiler
-
2009-02-16, 04:56 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
- Location
- France
- Gender
Re: Goblins
So... I know the main thing of this update is Nail vs GS, and "It's payback time, bitch!"
But... Anyone noticed the minotaur? The bolts and blood are here, but not the Minotaur's body. Did he disappear? Was he carried further away by the crowd? Does it have anything to do with how weird the bolts are?
I really wonder what's up with that.
-
2009-02-16, 06:20 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Sep 2007
- Location
- West Midlands, UK.
Re: Goblins
I doubt Thunt would forget to draw him in, so I'm guessing he got carried away; the bolts aren't likely to be able to make corpses vanish and I can't think of any other logical explanations. Do you guys agree that Nail was a Bugbear? I'm assuming he was.
"It doesn't matter what you think I'm supposed to be, 'cause I myself know all too well." Line from "King of My World" by Saliva.
Good itP 2009 winner,Cleric itP Winner.
Taking Reiki requests. PM me for details.Spoiler
-
2009-02-16, 07:23 AM (ISO 8601)
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
- Location
- France
- Gender