D&D 3e/3.5e/d20The forum for conversations specifically related to the rules and procedures of Dungeons & Dragons 3rd Edition, 3.5 Edition, or any fantasy game using the d20 system or a variant thereof (commercially published or not).
A region of black sand literally
swallows light, emitting magical
darkness rising to a height of 20
feet over the surface. Creatures that
come in contact with the sand take
1d4 points of damage per round from
negative energy (no save). Those
reduced to 0 hit points crumble into
black sand themselves.
When they die, do they turn into "permanent" sand?
I am a Dread Necromancer with the Tomb-tainted soul feat and I want to use the sand to heal myself, by putting it into my boot or something like that.
But we are unsure if the sand created when they die is permanent, the DM says it's not (by reading the spell) but I am unsure if that's true.
Is it permanent and why?
Also the "spell" it self can be made permanent by a permantcy spell (which i will never get as a dread necromancer).
A region of black sand literally
swallows light, emitting magical
darkness rising to a height of 20
feet over the surface. Creatures that
come in contact with the sand take
1d4 points of damage per round from
negative energy (no save). Those
reduced to 0 hit points crumble into
black sand themselves.
When they die, do they turn into "permanent" sand?
I am a Dread Necromancer with the Tomb-tainted soul feat and I want to use the sand to heal myself, by putting it into my boot or something like that.
But we are unsure if the sand created when they die is permanent, the DM says it's not (by reading the spell) but I am unsure if that's true.
Is it permanent and why?
Also the "spell" it self can be made permanent by a permantcy spell (which i will never get as a dread necromancer).
I'd rule that it has to be a significant volume of sand involved -- several cubic feet at least. A bit of sand in your boots just isn't enough to create this magical effect.
RAI tells me it's meant to be a terrain feature, not a piece of equipment.
__________________
Indigo is a much more appropriate colour for sarcasm, don't you think?
Blue is strictly for emphasis.
And grey is kind of like an aside to my main point.
When they die, do they turn into "permanent" sand?
I'd say no. When the spell expires, all of the black sand (including creatures turned into black sand) would revert to normal not-so-black sand. Creatures killed by the sand would still be dead, effectively the equivalent of being disintegrated.
Quote:
Originally Posted by IzorkX
I am a Dread Necromancer with the Tomb-tainted soul feat and I want to use the sand to heal myself, by putting it into my boot or something like that.
Awesome idea! Since the spell doesn't specify any minimum amount of sand, yeah, you could put some in your boots. You win D&D.
However, you might want to be careful... your DM might rule that if you were brought down to 0 HP by some other attack while touching the sand, even though the sand didn't do any damage, you still might wind up turning into black sand.
Quote:
Originally Posted by IzorkX
But we are unsure if the sand created when they die is permanent, the DM says it's not (by reading the spell) but I am unsure if that's true.
Is it permanent and why?
It's a spell effect with a duration. When the duration expires, the black sand becomes ordinary sand.
There's also the point that you can make the spell permanent via permanency, which kind of drives home the point that the spell effect wasn't permanent to begin with.
There may be an additional problem with the spell effect area, which creates a 20' area spread. There's no indication in the spell description that if you remove the black sand from that area that it will still retain the properties of black sand. Essentially, the effects of the spell is not literally something you can pick up and walk around with, it's just an emanation of negative energy tied to a particular geographic location.
There's an argument that if you find some black sand that was not created via a spell effect, you could pick it up and walk around with it. If you really were a Tomb-Tainted Dread Necromancer, however, you could probably expect even a somewhat reasonable DM to start dropping positive-energy anvils on your head whenever he felt like it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by IzorkX
Also the "spell" it self can be made permanent by a permantcy spell (which i will never get as a dread necromancer).
Did you already add the black sand spell via the Arcane Disciple feat? If not, then you could pick up permanency via the Time Domain that way. Otherwise, there are other ways to add the spell to your spell list. Extra Spell or Wyrm Wizard, for example.
I get the impression that blacksand also occurs naturally in deserts in D&D, going by sandstorm. I'm not certain that's the RAW of it though.
__________________
I am not seaweed. That's a B.
Praise I've received
Spoiler
Quote:
Originally Posted by ThiagoMartell
Kelb, recently it looks like you're the Avatar of Reason in these forums, man.
Quote:
Originally Posted by LTwerewolf
[...] bringing Kelb in on your side in a rules fight is like bringing Mike Tyson in on your side to fight a toddler. You can, but it's such massive overkill.
Page 20 of Sandstorm describes Supernatural Waste Hazards, including Black Sand. Page 111 details a spell that creates Black Sand.
The first entry explains that some of these supernatural hazards occur in unnatural environments and in areas where the land is infused with magic. In these instances, there appears to be Black Sand that exists on a permanent basis.
The spell only creates black sand for 1 min/level, but can be made permanent by the permanency spell.
So both permanent and temporary black sand appear to exist. There is no explicit mention of how this affects the people who die. However, I think it would be reasonable for a DM to rule that those killed by 'temporary' black sand just become regular sand when the spell ends.
__________________ “No matter how subtle the wizard, a knife between the shoulder blades will seriously cramp his style.” ― Steven Brust
"In God we trust. All others we investigate." - United States Army Military Police Corps
I think people are adding a bunch of rules to "balance" the spell and/or its effects. This is fine, but let's separate RAW vs. house_rules, and once we get RAW straight, then we can rule 0 it as much as we want...
1) The rule states that a creature killed by black sand (temporary or otherwise) turns into black sand. since it doesn't say otherwise, this new blacksand is permanent.
2) Any undead touching blacksand heals every round. Again, there is no volume stated, so even a thin layer inside the undead's boots will suffice.
Those are RAW as I see it. Fee free to adjust to your own worlds.
However, you might want to be careful... your DM might rule that if you were brought down to 0 HP by some other attack while touching the sand, even though the sand didn't do any damage, you still might wind up turning into black sand.
I for one love this idea. You want to use an obscure rule and a Feat to gain Fast Healing 1d4? Fine. But if you are ever at 0 hit points for any reason, you turn to black sand. Thus, the cost of using Black Sand in this way is that you lose access to your negative hit points, and can't be brought back from death with anything short of True Resurrection or Wish.
I for one love this idea. You want to use an obscure rule and a Feat to gain Fast Healing 1d4? Fine. But if you are ever at 0 hit points for any reason, you turn to black sand. Thus, the cost of using Black Sand in this way is that you lose access to your negative hit points, and can't be brought back from death with anything short of True Resurrection or Wish.
Well, to be honest, the feat is pretty much a given for any Dread Necro for plenty of self-healing, so that feat has already been expended, he's just wanting to use an obscure rule to get more mileage out of it.
I for one love this idea. You want to use an obscure rule and a Feat to gain Fast Healing 1d4? Fine. But if you are ever at 0 hit points for any reason, you turn to black sand. Thus, the cost of using Black Sand in this way is that you lose access to your negative hit points, and can't be brought back from death with anything short of True Resurrection or Wish.
Its a cool idea, but I'm pretty sure its a house rule. The "those" is clearly meant to refer to "a creature reduced to 0 hp by the damage of the black sand", and given that the rules say that and not "creatures reduced to 0 hp whilst in contact with black sand" leads me to be pretty sure that RAW points in the same direction.
__________________
"It doesn't matter how much you struggle or strive,
You'll never get out of life alive,
So please kill yourself and save this land,
And your last mission is to spread my command,"
Slightly adapted quote from X-Fusion, Please Kill Yourself
Well, to be honest, the feat is pretty much a given for any Dread Necro for plenty of self-healing, so that feat has already been expended, he's just wanting to use an obscure rule to get more mileage out of it.
Well, Tomb-Tainted Soul already gives you infinite out-of-combat healing, and Fast Healing 1d4 is honestly too small to be significant in most combats. It might not legitimately be worth the risk.
Also, half of RAW is literally semantics, trying to figure out what the tense or subject of a specific word is and what it refers to. That's why I consider it pretty stupid.
__________________
Avatar by araveugnitsuga.
91% of DMs started their first campaign while wearing pants. If you're one of the 9% that didn't, copy and paste this into your signature.
RSS Feeds: 
Black Sand - Confused
