My Little Pony XXXI: The Great and Powerful XXXie!

[Tiki Snakes]

Wait, so you're saying static electricity is magic? I thought friendship is magic.

Magic is Static Electricity.
Friendship is Magic.

Therefore, Static Electricity is Friendship?

[Eakin]

Magic is Static Electricity.
Friendship is Magic.

Therefore, Static Electricity is Friendship?

"Dear Princess Celestia,

Today I learned that, even though they might seem incompatible on the surface, when a negative charge and a positive put aside their differences they can discover a wonderful attractive force between them. So much so that anypony who tries to resist them will suffer painful shocks.

Your faithful student, Twilight Sparkle"

ETA more pony and electricity-themed puns

[Beeskee]

Woohoo, a new thread!

FFA FF RP: Free Raspberries! (Free-for-all Freeform RP)

Spoiler

Show

Beeskee sets up a small wooden stand in the market area in the middle of the town, with a sign that says "Free Raspberries!" in colorful writing. He stands behind it patiently, smiling. Oddly enough, there do not appear to be any raspberries on display. Or anything else, for that matter.

(Admiral Ackbar) It's a trap!

[Trazoi]

Basically the same (flexible) criteria for calling yourself a fan of something. In my opinion, if you've watched it, liked it, and would seek more episodes out given the opportunity, you're a fan.

Fan + not in the "target demographic" = brony.

Cool. I was never too sure if there was some Trekkie-like requirement of writing Mary Sue fan fiction and getting married with costume pointy ears and/or forehead ridges.

For me, I'm more at the "make amusingly captioned images on the Internet" level but not reached the "make fanfiction of favourite ponies" level. Eventually I might reacht the point I name a MP3 player or mobile phone Scootaloo.

[otakuryoga]

For me, I'm more at the "make amusingly captioned images on the Internet" level but not reached the "make fanfiction of favourite ponies" level. Eventually I might reacht the point I name a MP3 player or mobile phone Scootaloo.

give it time.......


also...WELCOME!!
Our Benevolent Hooved Overlords Are Pleased.

[Eakin]

Cool. I was never too sure if there was some Trekkie-like requirement of writing Mary Sue fan fiction and getting married with costume pointy ears and/or forehead ridges.

For me, I'm more at the "make amusingly captioned images on the Internet" level but not reached the "make fanfiction of favourite ponies" level. Eventually I might reacht the point I name a MP3 player or mobile phone Scootaloo.

Oh man, I hope not 'cause otherwise the brony police are going to be all over me for slacking off.

Also, I'm taking off tomorrow for a trip to New Zealand and Australia. I won't be on the internet much until after Thanksgiving, and probably not on these forums at all. I expect you all you be on thread 35 at least by the time I get back

[Lord Raziere]

Oy, A question:

Is there a new episode out yet?

I remember:
the two Discord episodes
the twilight goes crazy episode
the nightmare moon episode

is the fifth out yet? I can't remember, or don't know, I don't keep much track of this.

[Gamerlord]

Oy, A question:

Is there a new episode out yet?

I remember:
the two Discord episodes
the twilight goes crazy episode
the nightmare moon episode

is the fifth out yet? I can't remember, or don't know, I don't keep much track of this.

Yeah, it aired on Saturday. EqD should have links to some HD videos.

[Topaz]

s2e5 Relatedish:

Spoiler

Show

Ponies on bikes!

[Kindablue]

She says, "Does the name Sarah Wall mean anything to you?"

...

My mind broke.

My drama teacher is on FIRST NAME TERMS with this woman. And the best part?

Spoiler

Show

SHE MIGHT BE GETTING ME AN AUDITION!

... Vorpalbob remains best pony.

[CanvasWolfDoll]

egads, do you lot go through a lot of these threads. had to jump through about five after google dumped me on a mention of my fic...

so, am i alone in thinking that, in general, each episode's quality keeps improving to the point that, five episodes into season two, the earliest episodes seem rather weak?

[Soras Teva Gee]

So this made me laugh:

[Tiki Snakes]

egads, do you lot go through a lot of these threads. had to jump through about five after google dumped me on a mention of my fic...

so, am i alone in thinking that, in general, each episode's quality keeps improving to the point that, five episodes into season two, the earliest episodes seem rather weak?

Opinions vary wildly. I did very much enjoy the last episode, though.

Edit - Oh, and best report letter, Eakin. Best.

[Eakin]

egads, do you lot go through a lot of these threads. had to jump through about five after google dumped me on a mention of my fic...

so, am i alone in thinking that, in general, each episode's quality keeps improving to the point that, five episodes into season two, the earliest episodes seem rather weak?

My off the cuff subject to change rankings of each episode, out of 10, with 5 being an average S1 episode

E1: 6
E2: 8
E3: 8
E4: 9
E5: 4

[Draconi Redfir]

Haha! Nice title!


BWAHAHAHAHAHA! Open the link in a new tab/window, then open the spoiler below! :D

Spoiler

Show

Granny Smith was obviously in a heavy metal band at one point.

[SiuiS]

So taking up the vote for thread name was for naught? Noted.

Episode 5

Spoiler

Show

There's one special ingredient used to make all the insane food burning happen.

One that seems obvious.
One that seems familiar.

Tree sap

I was wondering if somepony would beat me to it...

pony thread moving a little slow it seems so let me attempt to bring up a subject that will no doubt be ignored.

so, pony episode authors.

M. A. Larson brought us the season two 2-parter, and Luna eclipsed, season one he brought us Sonic rainboom, Swarm of the Century, and Cutie mark Chronicles. it seems he was Lauren's second in command when it comes to writing, and he diffinitely brings us plenty of pony back stories, plus he writes some rather epic scenes.

Meghan McCarthy brought us Lesson Zero, and before had Dragonshy, Call of the Cutie, Green isn't your color, and Party of One. She is diffinitely the OCD Crazy pony writer. I look forward to more panicking crazy ponies from her in the future.

Lastly season two has Cindy Morrow with Sisterhooves Social, she seems to have the track record of mediorcre episodes when it comes to recieption by bronies. I must say I like her episodes though, it is simple and quiet, and at times heartwarming. (she brought us Griffon the Brush Off , Winter Wrap Up, The Show Stoppers, and Owl's Well That Ends Well.

I look forward to any Amy Keating Rogers's epsiodes, she also has several memorable ones. Chris Savino and Charlotte Fullerton also is favorable in my book, though they both rank near the bottom as far as exciting episodes go.

Dave Polsky may be the most underwhelming pony writer, with Feeling Pinkie keen and Over a barrel. I wonder if he will be able to bring a non-controversial episode in season two, if he is still writing for MLP that is.

Only comment is that I like over the barrel, and Pinkie Keen wasn't bad so much as folks let a poorly worded moral affect thee synopsis of the entire episode.

But there seems to be a depth here I've never really considered for any other show. I wonder if I can parse other televised programs by which writers I enjoy the work of?

Spoiler

Show

And wear pants, don't forget the pants. Also she either is a terrible cook, or she's being incredibly supportive (and blind to the faults of) Sweetie Belle's cooking efforts.

She is the Peggy Bundy stereotype, without the Bundy. Chubby, big haired, tourist in capris. I suspect she's a terrible cook, myself.

Huh, back just in time for page 50. So only 2/5 of a thread to catch up.

I know how you feel, mate. Even I'm behind

New Ponythread! That means time to party!

Spoiler

Show

I am glad y'all love that gif. I'll have to dredge up more Oldie-but-goodie stuff sometime.

Aww, I though I could make the first non-Op post. You guys are fast.

These ponies are CRAZY. fast comes with the territory
How's life treatin' ya, mate? I would have suspected you had weekends off but here you are on Monday/Tuesday, instead. Busy week?

Hooray new thread!*

What better time than to tell a nice little story?

Those of you on the IRC have most likely already heard this.

For those of you who follow the MLP Drawthread, you know that I had two costumes for Nightmare Night, one of which was Derpy.*

I walked into my Drama class that day, and my teacher had no idea who I was, so I explained the history of the character, how a fan-created name was accepted as the canonical name. She loved the idea, and said she would look it up.

The next day, I walk into class to see her texting away. I didn't see who she was talking to, but I saw her type in my name, so I asked who was on the other end.

"Oh, just a friend of mine. I'm telling her about your costume and acting and stuff. She thinks you sound really cool!"

I'm rather confused at this point, so I ask, "Who exactly is this person?"

She says, "Does the name Sarah Wall mean anything to you?"

...

My mind broke.

My drama teacher is on FIRST NAME TERMS with this woman. And the best part?

Spoiler

Show

SHE MIGHT BE GETTING ME AN AUDITION!

Fabulous! Good luck, and as they say, "go get 'em tiger!"

I'm surprised you're not puking rainbows cause of your awsm.

Ew. Thanks for that. XD

Unrelated: Did anyone here about a wall st. journal report on the Brony Phenomenon where in apparently Hasbro explain that the reason none of the Friendship is Magic toys look right is because they want to try and discourage the Broney's from buying them? I've heard about it but I've yet to see/read it myself so I figured I'd ask.*

And if it proves true, thoughts?*

Also Unrelated: If this made first page.

Spoiler

Show

First page. Yay.

You've heard the telephone version, the article didn't directly say they want to discourage anything; just that they don't believe the fandom is as big as it thinks it is.

Which is entirely true; for a collector, such as most bronies, you Rent going to play with, break, and thus have to buy a new toy. Once the first wave of show-accurate toys hit shelves, we'd flock to buy them and then... Maybe the bubble bursts and we're all satisfied an never buy another toy?

Their pessimism irritates me but it is perfectly understandable pessimism.

Alright! Thread 31/32! Lets do this!

Woo! Combination high-five/bro hoof go! *grows a Lyra hand* yeah!

[UrsielHauke]

Oy, A question:

Is there a new episode out yet?

I remember:
the two Discord episodes
the twilight goes crazy episode
the nightmare moon episode

is the fifth out yet? I can't remember, or don't know, I don't keep much track of this.

I just watched it. Check youtube.

Thoughts Rant!on ep. 5:

Spoiler

Show

Phenomenal episode, another dead-on hit. And, Rarity's dad wears a SOMBRERO. That said, I didn't like it quite as much as previous episodes. And don't get me wrong. I *LOVE* Rarity. I think she's a really smart, witty, character with realistic strong and weak points. Simply put, is best pony (Aside from Luna; sorry, but I shall never forsake my alliance). This one just couldn't beat art of the dress ; I mean, that was one spectacular episode. Art of the Dress = Amazing. Rarity has one amazing voice, and I am even guilty of singing that in the shower. It's true, and I'm not afraid to admit it.

Another thought before the Rarity-Lovefesting rant gets too out of hand. I think (and I just KNOW this has already been addressed) that Applejack is not nearly as boring and not-awesome a character as many seem to believe. I'm not saying I worship AJ. I'm not going to rank the ponies because I love all of them. But there is something crucially important to keep in mind: Applejack is a reactive character. She responds most favourably when placed in situations where everyone else is going completely crazy. This episode was a perfect example of this; Rarity and Sweetie Belle are having a complete nervous-breakdown-bad-stuff-flamewar-of-doom and AJ fixed everything. It is important that a character such as that exists in just about any story as a device to keep things from spiraling out of control. Because we all know what happens when things spiral out of control.

And that would be...

THE!

WORST!

POSSIBLE!

THING!


Had to finish with some Rarity, of course.

Well, I could really rant for another twenty or thirty minutes, no problem. But I really want food. So, yeah. That's my (dreadfully incomplete version of) my rant on ep5.

[Thanqol]

*Total brain-block with a story for school*

*Realises that one of the main characters is a Fluttershy*

*Story writes itself*

[Trazoi]

*Realises that one of the main characters is a Fluttershy*

Is this a trope now? What's the definition of "The Fluttershy"?

[Shadow of the Sun]

Probably a Shrinking Violet with some badass thrown in, to use Troper Terms.

[Tectonic Robot]

My off the cuff subject to change rankings of each episode, out of 10, with 5 being an average S1 episode

E1: 6
E2: 8
E3: 8
E4: 9
E5: 4

Which episode is a 1? You need to have a 1.

[Strife Warzeal]

Which episode is a 1? You need to have a 1.

Personally I would pick Look Before You Sleep. To me it just seems one of the least entertaining. Though I think Applebuck Season ranks fairly low too. These are my thoughts, anyone dispute them? Sounds like I'm asking for an argument to start doesn't it?

[PhantomFox]

I've been thinking, does Applejack have a long-term goal that can create conflict? My initial impression was that she needs money for fixing up the farm, but we've never seen the farm cause problems for her. Should they go with this, or think up something new for her to pursue? Dash has her stunt-flying career, Rarity wants to be in high society, Fluttershy is chock full of phobias, Pinkie wants everypony to be happy, and Twilight wants to be a pony archmage. But what does AJ want?

[Eakin]

Which episode is a 1? You need to have a 1.

Probably Owl's Well would be my least favorite episode. Feeling Pinkie Keen and Call of the Cutie are down there as well, and maybe Over a Barrel. Applebuck season's a little closer to "average" although I admit it's lacking in "hook"

I should really divide them into quintiles

[Mystic Muse]

Which episode is a 1? You need to have a 1.

I'll get back to you with season 1 (Need to re-watch it before rating episodes). As for Season 2....

E1. 1
E2. 1
E3. 2
E4. 8
E5. 6.5

[Jahkaivah]

Open the link in a new tab/window, then open the spoiler below! :D

Spoiler

Show

Granny Smith was obviously in a heavy metal band at one point.

And Fluttershy is her faithful student.

Though I think Applebuck Season ranks fairly low too. These are my thoughts, anyone dispute them? Sounds like I'm asking for an argument to start doesn't it?

Yes and yes. Applebuck Season was the first of the really good episodes and you are a terrible person.

[Zevox]

My off the cuff subject to change rankings of each episode, out of 10, with 5 being an average S1 episode

E1: 6
E2: 8
E3: 8
E4: 9
E5: 4

Hm, personally, I'd say:

E1: 7
E2: 8
E3: 8
E4: 7
E5: 4 (or maybe 3.5)

For baselines, Sonic Rainboom is my 10, The Show Stoppers would be my 1, and something like Boast Busters or Look Before You Sleep would be my 5.

Zevox

[Topaz]

Thoughts Rant!on ep. 5:

Best. Rant. Ever.

I've been thinking, does Applejack have a long-term goal that can create conflict? My initial impression was that she needs money for fixing up the farm, but we've never seen the farm cause problems for her. Should they go with this, or think up something new for her to pursue? Dash has her stunt-flying career, Rarity wants to be in high society, Fluttershy is chock full of phobias, Pinkie wants everypony to be happy, and Twilight wants to be a pony archmage. But what does AJ want?

As far as I can tell, she wants Sweet Apple Acres to be prosperous, and keep expanding the business. She's unique among the Mane 6 in that she is inheriting a successful family business instead of being on her own, which sets her priorities accordingly.

And speaking of ; tonight we decided to go to Souplantation (aka Sweet Tomatoes, a soup/salad/etc. buffet chain) for dinner. There I found:

• Taffy Apple Salad (with marshmallows & coconut) on the salad bar
• Diced Apples & Sweet Potatoes with Cranberries & Walnuts in the side dishes
• Whole apples (small green & red ones) on the dessert bar

There was no apple soup, so I had Pumpkin Bisque instead.
Needless to say, my inner Applejack was very happily fed.

[the_druid_droid]

*Total brain-block with a story for school*

*Realises that one of the main characters is a Fluttershy*

*Story writes itself*

This is excellent

Out of curiosity, what story?

I've been thinking, does Applejack have a long-term goal that can create conflict? My initial impression was that she needs money for fixing up the farm, but we've never seen the farm cause problems for her. Should they go with this, or think up something new for her to pursue? Dash has her stunt-flying career, Rarity wants to be in high society, Fluttershy is chock full of phobias, Pinkie wants everypony to be happy, and Twilight wants to be a pony archmage. But what does AJ want?

Hmm, you make a good point, although Applebuck Season kind of suggests AJ's biggest problem is dealing with her own stubbornness. At the same time, that doesn't seem quite to the scale of some of the other complications that her friends have, and it's only really come up in that one episode.

I guess on that note, I would like to see them do something more with AJ, either to go on with the farm potentially needing money or something new; I don't know if I have a preference, but I would like to see some development.

[UrsielHauke]

Best. Rant. Ever.

Can I sig this?