Classic Werewolf: The Village of Vilcas

[Eldritch Knight]

Originally Posted by DiscipleofBob

Could you clarify this, Eldritch Knight?

Because that reasoning kind of applies to everyone left in the game.

Look up the forums Laws of Werewolf. Most of the games where Murska is lynched at, or after this point, he has proven to be a werewolf.

[Murska]

That rule is for Shadow, Eldritch Knight. My rule is that I'm a wolf regardless.

More seriously, I haven't been around for a long time and most of the players in the game are new. In addition, I've never been worth much to the Villagers as working as a Wolf just requires quick wit whereas working as a Villager actually requires work, and I'm far too lazy for that.

[Julian84]

Eldritch Knight because of reasons.

[Alarra]

Murska, because I'm fairly positive that he's wolf.

[Count Dingdong]

Too wagons, huh. Still suspicous of Eldrich, but for now on Murska for evening out wagons.

[inky13112]

Penguinator for now, since I'm not seeing the logic for EK or murska. Mostly due to being low enough on my radar that it seems suspicious.

[Elemental]

Murska is a good vote to placehold for now.
I'm too tired to do maths right now, so I can't be bothered working everything out.

[Grue Bait]

Elemental just doesn't seem right, if you ask me.

[Fleeing Coward]

Murska admits he's a wolf so that must mean Eldritch Knight is one.

[52.5 Lemons]

Originally Posted by Fleeing Coward

Murska admits he's a wolf so that must mean Eldritch Knight is one.

Fleeing Coward, can you explain that?

I'm really not convinced on either of the two wagons at the moment. The reasoning for Murska sounds a bit wolfy if you ask me.

[inky13112]

The day could be ending soon and we have a tie. I'm not sure what happens then? In case it results in another no lynch I'll switch to Murska. Does anyone know more specifically?

[Fleeing Coward]

It wasn't meant to make sense but between the two, I do trust Murska slightly more than Eldritch Knight.

I will admit that there is something weird about Murska's statement though. He can definately be effective on both sides despite his claims to been lazy.

[Penguinator]

Murska. It's time for that eye to roll out of here.

[Zar Peter]

Going to trust Reinholdt and point at Alarra

[Dragoon]

Hmm, Eldritch Knight.

[Count Dingdong]

Current Votes:

Murska - 6
EK - 5
Allarra - 2
Elemetal - 1
FC - 1

15 -> 5 min for vote
20 players -> 7 max min for lynch

Still have no idea so wont change vote.

[Matthias2207]

I'm not convinced of either bandwagon, but we'll have to kill someone.
Eldritch Knight to keep the options open.

[Gray Mage]

IMO, Murska is always a good vote.

[Atreyu the Masked LLama]

Eldritch KNight and Alarra always point at each other, but this game they aren't. Is it because they are on the same team?

[Eldritch Knight]

Originally Posted by Atreyu the Masked LLama

Eldritch KNight and Alarra always point at each other, but this game they aren't. Is it because they are on the same team?

If we are, and I'm lynched, and therefore shown to not a wolf, does that mean you'll trust her judgment?

[Gnomish Wanderer]

Day 5 End!
The middle of the evening was met by two people trading blows.

Murska and Eldritch Knight were fighting, each swinging and grappling, rage distorting their features. "You're the wolf!" "No, you are!" The villagers soon found themselves gathered in a semi-circle around the two, and I believe someone was trying to get a 'Fight! Fight!' chant going, though unsuccessfully.

The two finally fell apart, panting as they glared at one another. "Some Eldritch you are." Murska muttered, causing Eldritch Knight to jump back his way, fists swinging.

Llama and Gray Mage finally went to pull the two brawlers apart, but as they did so there was a sudden ripping sound, Eldritch Knight dropping a bag of herbs. "The last of my wolfsbane!" He cried out, everybody freezing.

Murska, too, was frozen, eyes wide as the wolfsbane fluttered on top of him as he pulled himself off the ground. His features distorted in rage for a second, a snarl emitting from his throat as fur broke out over his body.

Town was slow to react, pulling forth their swords and axes and other miscellaneous weapons to strike at the beast, but Murska shrugged off their initial attack, bursting through the crowd to the kneeling Eldritch Knight. He picked him up as more weapons sank into the monster's flesh, and Murska didn't go down until after Eldritch Knight was badly wounded.

Murska was lynched! He was a Werewolf!
Players

Spoiler

#	Player	Killed	Role
1	Alarra
2	The Grimmace	Night 4	Villager
3	TigerFang	Day 2	Devil
4	Penguinator
5	Grue Bait
6	Gray Mage
7	Atreyu the Masked Llama
8	Zar Peter
9	Elemental
10	usourselves&we	Night 2	Villagers
11	Matthias2207
12	Reinholdt
13	Lex-Kat	Day 4	Villager
14	DiscipleofBob
15	Rogue Nine	Night 3	Villager
16	Eldritch Knight	Day 5	Baner
17	Tom the Mime
18	Count Dingdong
19	Fleeing Coward
20	Dragoon
21	Julian24
22	super dark33	Day 3	Villager
23	inky13112
24	C'nor
25	Rules Lawyer #1	Night 1	Mason
26	52.5 Lemons
27	Murska	Day 5	Werewolf

Night 5 Start!
Ends in about 24 hours

Official Poll:
Is this poll getting tiring?

• Yes
• No

Ends at the start of Day 5! Vote now!

[Eldritch Knight]

You really should have said ties would result in both parties being lynched in the rules!

[C'nor]

Indeed; that's not standard, and really should have been mentioned.

[Alarra]

Yeah, EK should not have died under normal rules.

[52.5 Lemons]

Agreed. Shouldn't any rule that isn't found in werewolf central be noted in the custom rules before the game starts?

[Reinholdt]

That makes a HUGE difference on how days play out.

[Gnomish Wanderer]

Mod Note: I'm sorry; I didn't realize the standard was to have only the first person eligible lynched. When I created the initial rules I forgot to add an addendum in case of ties, so instead of changing the rules I just followed through with how they stand [which was with both EK and Murska eligible and up for lynch]. I'll make sure to not have such grievous mistakes in the future. If you notice any other inconsistencies in the ruling let me know, I feel terrible.

[Count Dingdong]

In rules, tis unclear whether sing. or plural. Figured stadard rules would apply or something. Didn't figure both would die...

[Elemental]

Well... We know the case now.


And as for the poll: No, they're not getting tiring. They are actually rather amusing.

[Reinholdt]

Is it going to remain ties equal both lynched or go to the standard?