Alright, this was really tough due to the many good submissions you guys made, and I really don't enjoy the process of cutting people out. I went through them all, trying to compile different sorts of teams and imagine how they would play out. After I had a relatively clear picture in mind, I asked the Wuhtu players for their input to see how well their opinions jived with mine. Thankfully, we all had pretty similar ideas. Anyway, enough buildup.
In the end, these four entrants stood out.
(In reverse-alphabetical order) Wordplay, Planswalker, MesiDoomstalker, and Inedible: Head on over to the OOC
Thank you to everyone else, you'll be the first ones I reach out to in case we find ourselves needing more players.