As an unrepentant Joker fanboy, yes this one is good (endings a bit off though, the Joker looses)
On the same vein, Mask of the Phantasm is pretty good even if it is essentially a romance, and non-DCAU Under the Red Hood has John DiMaggio giving the only cartoon performance as Mistah Jay that is even comparable to Mark Hamill.
Originally Posted by DiscipleofBob
The Wonder Woman movie is one of my favs.
And I can't remember the name, but the one where they deal with their evil alternate-reality selves is brilliant.
Crisis on Two Earths unless I am mistaken. And I need to get around to seeing the Wonder Woman one, it's on my to-watch list.
One of the movies, I can't remember which, contains a Green Arrow short which is just awesome.
The shorts are great, definitely. Hell the 5 minute Jonah Hex short blows the movie out of the water. Though the Catwoman one seemed far too focused on flashing T&A for my tastes.
And I need to get around to seeing the Wonder Woman one, it's on my to-watch list.
You definitely should - it's easily one of the best. Annoyingly, I heard it didn't sell too well when it was originally released (though its sales figures picked up over time through word of mouth), reinforcing in the minds of studio executives the idea that female heroes won't sell well.
I'm a huge fan of Superman: Doomsday, too. I'd heard a ton of bad reviews about it from a variety of sources, but when I actually watched it for myself, I really couldn't see what had inspired all the negativity.
Maybe it's because it's not a faithful adaptation of the comic, but then the whole death-and-return comic storyline spanned multiple titles for over a year, so we were never going to get that in one film. The shortcuts and changes they made worked just fine, IMO.
Oh, and the DVD's got a insightful comentary with Bruce Timm and a fun documentary about the creation of and reaction to the original comic book death of Superman.
The shorts are great, definitely. Hell the 5 minute Jonah Hex short blows the movie out of the water.
The Green Arrow and Spectre shorts are great, too.
I have a cookie now! (::) I've licked it, so no backsies.
Last edited by Senator Cybus : 10-20-2012 at 06:59 PM.
Green Lantern Emerald Knights was a good collection of stories, I liked it.
My problem with Superman vs. the Elite and Superman:Doomsday is the diverging art styles. Doomsday have weird character models and Elite has a chin three sizes too large.
Superman/Batman Apocalypse and Public Enemies are great (Enemies has a colorful art style, Apocalypse has the lined Red-Hood sexiness).
Oh yeah. The stories are pure epic.
Edit: Shorts! The Spectre one is... scary. I really enjoyed watching it. Green Arrow's "the arrow's green" killed me (who else would actually say that? [its called 'a light']), and Year One was good (got that with Arkham City), but I disliked the Catwoman short because of both it being boring and "oh catwoman has TWO ENTIRE BREASTS DID YOU SEE THEM!", and also I hated the Catwoman sections of Arkham.
And I dunno if Return of Black Adam counts as a short or a really small movie. Was great though, epic Billy Batson.
Havent seen Frontier, Batman looks untolerable. And its all weird. Elite is much better than the comic, at least.
Originally Posted by Solaris
If it helps, think of me as the Agent from Serenity. Just not that good a fighter. Also, I have a mustache.
Originally Posted by kpenguin
I'm probably hilarious far off, aren't I?
Originally Posted by Telonius
This is not... the greatest story Tolkien ever wrote. No... This is just a tribute.
Originally Posted by Coidzor
Bah. You've got to believe in the you that believes in the heart of the cards to summon the 7 dragon balls to be the very best like no one ever was!
.; Many thanks piled on top of other thanks with a martini on top to Cuthalion for custom avatar.
Last edited by Mutant Sheep : 10-21-2012 at 05:51 PM.
Batman: Mask of the Phantasm and Batman Beyond: Return of the Joker are still the standard by which the others should be judged.
Put me on the list of people that "really should get around to watching the Wonder Woman one". I've had enough people tell me it's better than it looks that I'm getting ready to rent it.
The first Green Lantern one... I'll say this nicely, it stunk. Yes, that was being nice.
GL: Emerald Knights on the other hand? Darn good, and not just because they got Mojo Doesn't Socialize into animation. The complete remake of Liara was close to being an improvement.
New Frontier I've got mixed feelings on. I enjoy it enough I ended up buying it. It does have its flaws that keep it from the "Mask" and "Joker" level.
Superman: Doomsday is better than some poeple give it credit for. Personally I like my Lois married to Clark and knowing the truth, and this was an examination of why I don't feel the alternative works. To each their own.
All Star Superman? This is the one I think is overrated. That's a different thing from saying it's *bad*, but I regret buying it before I rented it.
I had hope for Justice League Doom... but it didn't rise to the level of the original story, which is a pity. Worse, some of the 'politics' stuck out like a sore thumb and detracted from the story (WW having a whip instead of a lasso, Cyborg being on a team, "our GL is a better actor", that sort of thing). Also, the end solution was... absurd... and that's being nice.
I'm going to second the opinion that Batman: Gotham Knights is a mixed bag. A couple of them were good (I've always said Deadshot had the potential to be a key Batman villain). One was incoherent. One was needlessly preachy.
Crisis on Two Earths was a great one-watcher or renter. I loved their take on Owlman in particular, and the Batman vs Superwoman fight was fair to both characters.
Sometimes, the knights are the monsters
The main problem with the world? So many grownups, not enough adults.
Pain is nature's way of saying you're not dead and the other guy is.
Current Project: Sky High, the superheroic High School campaign. The school's name isn't the only thing I borrowed...
Last edited by TheEmerged : 10-21-2012 at 07:30 PM.