New OOTS products from CafePress
New OOTS t-shirts, ornaments, mugs, bags, and more
Tab Content
  • RSP's Avatar
    Today, 06:04 AM
    RSP replied to a thread Moon Druid + Rune Shaper in D&D 5e/Next
    AoA is good when you have an ability to mitigate damage. In terms of going this route with a Druid for Wildshape, I’d probably suggest getting Rage...
    6 replies | 533 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    Today, 05:41 AM
    RSP replied to a thread I don't like Rune Knight in D&D 5e/Next
    I think it’s a fair point that “Giant Magic” isn’t what any of the giants do (at least not the main giants), they do spells (if any magic). Are the...
    51 replies | 2637 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    Yesterday, 01:08 PM
    RSP replied to a thread Benefits of being big in D&D 5e/Next
    In line with area denial: if two size categories smaller or larger, area denial goes away.
    11 replies | 856 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    Yesterday, 12:02 PM
    If the counter argument to “it’s not easy to play a non-human with only human experiences to draw from” is “but it’s been accomplished by a...
    79 replies | 4923 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    Yesterday, 10:20 AM
    Yes, it’s not easy to play a non-human with only human experiences to draw from. But I’m also surprised others say they don’t get any non-human...
    79 replies | 4923 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-05-07, 01:59 PM
    This all just comes down to what tables want to play, and managing expectations with a session 0. Some tables love murder hobo, and don’t want to...
    79 replies | 4923 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-05-06, 08:04 AM
    I think it just all depends on what the table wants to play. If, in making a PC, role playing that they’re a being that might not be readily...
    79 replies | 4923 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-22, 08:27 PM
    Concentration, is by my reading of the RAW, just mundane, real world concentrating. Now I will say, one of the big questions I’ve always had is...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-21, 09:45 PM
    RSP replied to a thread How do you handle Wish? in D&D 5e/Next
    I still don’t see how an extra 9th level slot isn’t in-game. Do you operate that casters are unaware of the level of spells, or of how their energy...
    52 replies | 5005 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-21, 09:32 PM
    I don’t know that anything about concentration is necessarily magical. I mean, in common English, concentrating on something isn’t magical at all (us...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-21, 12:48 PM
    They are Concentrating on whatever they cast. But Concentrating on a spell isn’t the same thing as having a spell on you. That’s the issue with how...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-21, 12:39 PM
    Not sure if this come up as much at your table, but the +1 to Wis (resetting the Wis 8 to Wis 10) also helps Wis skills (namely Perception). So...
    84 replies | 6579 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-20, 11:55 AM
    Fair, though I believe this makes DM more powerful than expected: it essentially dispels all spells on a caster and an effect, rather than one or the...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-20, 09:40 AM
    Not sure what you’re referring to: specific to SB or DM as a whole but, yes, to both. We’ve had a number of issues surrounding DM: not just in...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-19, 08:51 PM
    What? You’re saying PCs get to command animals, fey, elementals, etc., that they encounter? That those creatures will just automatically obey their...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-19, 06:35 PM
    Yup. That’s the spell. The SAC says it vanishes when the caster lets go of it. Which, unfortunately makes it official.
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-19, 09:56 AM
    So then you can’t throw it if following that…
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-18, 09:27 PM
    That’s still very much working off the power the spell grants the caster though. Yeah I’ve never been sold on that. Common English doesn’t say...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-18, 10:02 AM
    Which doesn’t change that the ability still comes from the weapon. Your claim was the command property came from the creatures, not the spell being...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-18, 09:50 AM
    Thanks. The wording here is such that it’s inconclusive whether a single casting of DM can end the creations of CWBs (say as if targeting the magical...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-18, 09:21 AM
    Not true. The spell is what allows you to command the Summons/Conjures. For instance, no one else other than the caster is afforded that permission. ...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-18, 09:02 AM
    I don’t mind hearing that argument, but to me it seems really odd that while we know (d/t the existing magic items in the game) that weapons have...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-17, 10:38 PM
    RSP replied to a thread How do you handle Wish? in D&D 5e/Next
    Work with the DM, not against them. I like the aspect of Wish in being any other spell, but outside of chain simulacrums and whatnot, there’s...
    52 replies | 5005 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-17, 10:04 PM
    You mean this? “If dispel magic targets the magical effect from bless cast by a cleric, does it remove the effect on all the targets? Dispel...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-17, 07:58 PM
    Interesting, but not exactly rules official: “Nov 15, 2016 @JeremyECrawford If I Dispel Magic one of many creations from a 'Conjure ???' Spell,...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-17, 07:44 PM
    Or, you know, it’s a legit question. ____ For those wishing to discuss the topic, I find it odd that a spell that creates an object is not...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-17, 02:30 PM
    If you’re fine with “affects only the caster” as meaning “affects the caster and others” then we disagree too much on that basic point for other...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-17, 11:13 AM
    So you would agree stating “BB only affects the caster” would be inaccurate? So would casting DM on the caster, after the BB attack has been...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
  • RSP's Avatar
    2024-04-17, 11:05 AM
    And yet, it clearly affects the target of the attack who is sheathed in booming energy, no? I’m pretty sure you aren’t contending BB damages the...
    145 replies | 8357 view(s)
More Activity
About RSP

Basic Information

Statistics


Total Posts
Total Posts
5,210
Posts Per Day
1.81
General Information
Last Activity
Today 06:38 AM
Join Date
2016-06-25
Post Areas

Top Areas Of Posting