ecarden
Barbarian in the Playground
Find latest postsMini Statistics
- Join Date
- 2020-06-12
- Last Activity
- Yesterday 07:58 PM
- Tab Content
- ecarden's Activity
- About Me
- Post Areas
-
Older Activity
-
2024-05-05, 08:35 PMI'd say the next two for you are pretty Empire focused, with the final one a bit Empire focused. I'd tend to agree that Tales of Morgan and Tales...12 replies | 1565 view(s) -
2024-05-04, 06:36 PMI'd tend to agree, but for two things: 1) The show, and this hopefully is just hype/advertising, really pushes the notion of some big...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-05-01, 03:41 PMI think the intent (assuming its just not a retcon) is that it's pretty widely variable. Coop made it a long time before he started to degenerate,...96 replies | 6515 view(s)
-
2024-04-30, 10:43 PMI don't think this is correct, as I believe at this point, he isn't after the head, he's after the drugs. He needs her alive, but his plan is to...96 replies | 6515 view(s)
-
2024-04-30, 06:49 PMExcept the point is that there is water available. It's irradiated, but its present. He can drink it without harm (ghoul), she can't. He is in no...96 replies | 6515 view(s)
-
2024-04-29, 10:36 PMI don't either, but I believe it's intended to be older than that, as I believe it's the same drug that was running down to our boy's coffin to keep...96 replies | 6515 view(s)
-
2024-04-24, 06:27 PMThat's a fair critique. To be clear, I'm neither a mod nor a dictator, you are allowed to discuss whatever you like regarding Jedi imperfections. My...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-24, 02:42 PMI don't agree that it does, anymore than it also being Padme's tragedy mean her flaws are part of the reason for her death. I mean, you can make that...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-24, 12:42 PMIt certainly can be, but even under that definition, it still works, because it's the tragedy of Anakin's pride, hubris and inability to accept...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-24, 07:30 AMJango was a gun for hire. From the Jedi perspective he was hired to provide a genetic template and then hired for other things. He goes back to...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-24, 07:27 AMBecause they're trying to dodge giving the wrong answer (which will get them killed) and don't know what the right answer is. They don't know which...10 replies | 1561 view(s)
-
2024-04-24, 07:13 AMI'll say, that's the point of the scene. That the characters who are being asked that question are desperately out of their depth and absolutely...10 replies | 1561 view(s)
-
2024-04-23, 09:53 PMOn the broader topic of Sifo-Diyas, Dooku and the clone army, I will point out that, from the perspective of the Jedi Council, it is really, really,...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-23, 02:04 PMI've heard that to and there's a source of uncertain validity here: https://mindstalk.net/brust/psych.html discussing that history.844 replies | 99496 view(s)
-
2024-04-23, 07:32 AMGotta run to work, so fast responses. To Mechalich: I disagree that clone commanders are more effective--I don't think the clone wars shows the...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-23, 12:01 AMThere seems to be a notion that its morally superior not to command the clones? Not to fight with them? Isn't that exactly backwards? If you believe...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-22, 07:42 PMI mean...no? It very explicitly is genocide. They were a religious order, who were targeted for that and murdered for it. They killed a large number...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-22, 04:21 PMTo be clear, it didn't occur to me until I deleted about half a dozen responses and sat down to figure out why I was getting so hot about an entirely...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-22, 03:29 PMI certainly see the parallel and it works rhetorically...but not logically. Vader doesn't turn on Palpatine in Episode 6 because Palpatine is killing...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-22, 12:04 PMThere's a lot here that's right, but I'd phrase it slightly differently. The PT is definitely "about institutional decay and failure of the...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-22, 11:04 AMIt's an interesting point, because the Vlad Taltos series sort of fell into this and sort of didn't, even early on when it was more in love with the...844 replies | 99496 view(s)
-
2024-04-20, 09:31 AMResponses in the original quote96 replies | 6515 view(s)
-
2024-04-19, 06:15 PMIt's an interesting movie and, at least to me, quite ambiguous in its view of journalism and journalists. Like, it looks like it's going to be a bog...10 replies | 1561 view(s)
-
2024-04-16, 10:32 PMI think the question of who is the best teacher depends on what they are attempting to teach. To the extent Anakin's only goal is to teach Ahsoka to...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-15, 08:52 PMEh, I guess I'd ask what the Jedi are actually doing then, while the war is going on and the CIS is merrily running around conquering planets,...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-15, 02:25 PMI mean, the timeline from the perspective of almost everyone is: Lots of negotiation, no actual war Attempted assassination of a prominent...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
-
2024-04-14, 03:03 PMSo, I think some of this is fairly likely, but there's still a lot of issues. Given her statements about hypocrisy and reappearance (especially...96 replies | 6515 view(s)
-
2024-04-14, 09:50 AMSo, I don't think that works: I agree that I doubt we're done with her, though I expect she only shows up in flashbacks going forward as she ends...96 replies | 6515 view(s)
-
2024-04-13, 03:50 PMGenerally quite enjoyed it. I didn't particularly like the two big larger canon choices: As I think the destruction of the NCR is just boring and...96 replies | 6515 view(s)
-
2024-04-10, 07:45 PMSo, it's a bit hard to tell. Is Palpatine having a grand time because he's top Sith, or because he's one of the only Sith we see who actually lives...620 replies | 25795 view(s)
About ecarden
Basic Information
Statistics
Total Posts
- Total Posts
- 740
- Posts Per Day
- 0.52
General Information
- Last Activity
- Yesterday 07:58 PM
- Join Date
- 2020-06-12
Post Areas
RSS Feeds: 
