Quote:
As for the hero worship comment, yes. Get over yourself. Luke can make mistakes.
I can't roll my eyes hard enough. I see a trend with people that like ****ty movies. You have to attack the motive and intent behind critics instead of actually addressing the points being made.
Of course Luke can make mistakes. Remember when he left to face Vader and lost his hand and found himself dangling underneath the Cloud City? Remember when he fell through a pit trap and found himself facing a rancor? Luke is not perfect. He's not a god. No one is expecting him to be.
In an attempt to call me out as a hero worshiper, you are equating "I may have to kill this boy in cold blood" with "a mistake". And, you're very conspicuously ignoring the part where Luke's great act of heroism was to deliver himself to Sidious to move his father's heart to the light side.
This is about characterization, not hero worship.
Quote:
You're twisting in knots trying to find some way to rationalize "Luke saw the darkness in Ren's heart and on instinct wanted to cut it out" because you cannot stand the fact that maybe your hero isn't perfect. Maybe he just made a mistake. These things happen.
I'm not twisting in knots, though your style of "argumentation" is a little nauseating.
If you want to reduce "almost deliberately murdered his nephew" to "a mistake", then that's cool. Obviously it doesn't bother you and it doesn't seem counter to Luke's character. I obviously can't change your mind on that and it doesn't seem that we'll even come to any sort of understanding because you seem to have me figured out already.
Quote:
You and the other person who brought this up are at the point where you're reading into the actor's words to be like "no see he agrees this is bad like I do!" when it couldn't be further from the truth.
So you keep saying. Feel free to elaborate, because I'm not sure how
I pretty much fundamentally disagree with every choice you’ve made for this character. Now, having said that, I have gotten it off my chest, and my job now is to take what you’ve created and do my best to realize your vision. is far from the truth.
And again... how weak of an attack. I was responding to someone bringing Mark Hamill up. I didn't use him as an argument. Please, stop guessing at my intentions, because you're **** at it and you're not half as clever as you think you are. If you want to discuss the movie, we can do that.