Corrected! Thanks.
Printable View
here's the running thus far.
edit: changed yellow to less eye-bleeding colour:smallredface:
edit2: changed osric's score to reflect bobvosh's update, his ranking is the same
Spoiler{table=head]Build|Judge 1| Judge 2| Judge 3| Total|Average|Place
1st The hunger in the shadows|14.5|13.5|15.25|43.25|3.604|1st
2nd Lucian the Wanderer|12.5|14.5|15|42|3.5|2nd
3rd Maxwell Alard|14|13|14.5|41.5|3.456|3rd
Karn the Conqueror|14.5|10|16|41|3.417|4th
The Damned Drake|15.5|11.5|13.75|40.75|3.396|5th
The dancing shadow|13.5|12|14|39.5|3.292|6th
Claire Dini|13.5|14|11.75|39.25|3.271|7th
Osric the Fallen|14|11.5|13.25|38.75|3.229|8th
Ensis Tenebra|14|10.5|13|37.5|3.125|9th
Vesper|14.5|10|12.75|37.25|3.104|10th
Artou Defoor|12.5|11.5|12.5|36.5|3.042|11th
Domovoi|13.5|11|11.75|36.25|3.021|12th
Lord Shady McUmbra|13|10|12.75|35.75|2.979|13th
Theodore Johannes Kaczynski|10.5|10.5|13.25|34.25|2.854|14th
Pumpkinhead|11.5|10.5|11.25|33.25|2.771|15th
Khariman Sandiga|13.5|8|9.5|31|2.583|16th
Teissa|9.5|10|11.5|31|2.583|17th
Athek|10|9|10.25|29.25|2.438|18th
[/table]
Tiessa's individual components add up to 11.5, but the total given is 11.25, which is correct?
likewise, Lord McUmbra's individual components add up to 12.75, not 13.75, which is that total given. which one should I plug into the chart?
Two of your judges are labeled "Judge 2" in the chart, Venger. :smallwink:
Also, that particular shade of yellow against the chart's background makes my eyeballs bleed.
I PMed the Chairman this round while trying to put together a build, and he and I were both under the impression that the "+2 HD every third level" was for every third level after obraining the class feature, neaning that your shadow has 3 HD @ 3rd level, 5 HD @ 6th level, and 7 HD @ 9th level. If that's correct, BobVosh's original scoring was warranted.
If it is me, always go with what it adds up to. Especially since I was in a huge rush when doing it. I'll go check my math.
Corrected. Let me know what the official ruling on shadow's HD is, and I'll fix it/let it stand.
*edit* Now that I finished I also read the other judging. Werebear: You gave Kharn the Conquerer points for barbarian but didn't for Tiessa. I think for that kind of thing is required for consistancy.
Also are judges allowed to make honorable mention? Because if so I have to decide between two builds that will make it kinda hard.
yes, I was referring to your judgings. I figured that's what I should do, so that is the numbers I used for my chart, thus, I don't need to do anything. thanks for the reply
speaking of consistency, you gave artou points for spell reflection (presumably to avoid redundancy of having evasion twice over with SD's evasion) but did not give pumpkinhead any points for his spell reflection.
yes, judges are allowed to make honourable mentions, as are contestants and spectators, feel free to comment in the thread since you did not submit a build so the anonymity of your entry is not an issue
Wow, we went from ties all over the place at 3rd, 5th and 8th place, but now we only have a tie for 16th. Thank goodness we got the 3 judges in.
I just thought of this now, what do you think would happen if someone used the Dungeoncrasher Fighter from Dungeonscape for this PrC? Certainly would be intersting. Pop up in one area, bull rush them into a wall and disappear.
4 hours to go, and I don't think we've got anyone else who has announced intentions to judge. Get your votes for honorable mention in now!
To the chairman: How soon after this one closes can we expect ICOCITP XXVII to be up and running? I need to let my gaming group know if we're going to be meeting tonight, or if I'm going to be tinkering. :smallbiggrin:
DaragoKitsune, Kesnit, Ryu_Bonkosi, and Calanon threw their hats in the judging ring, DaragoKitsune bowed out, and Kesnit and Calanon haven't posted since (either saying they were still working or that they were bowing out). Ryu_Bonkosi posted saying his judging was taking awhile and usually submits judgements for ICs, I can't say I remember seeing the others judge beore.
maybe they PMed amphetryon? either way, can't hurt to wait another 3 hours
it's usually the same day (that was the case for this one) and amphetryon's already got XXVII all picked out (whatever it may be) so it'll probably be up tonight. I'm totally down for whatever it is. if I can't think of anything inventive, I'll be happy to judge
My honorable mention vote goes to Claire Dini, for making the build a function of the story and not vice versa.
If it's not too late, I'd like to give an honorable mention to That Damned Drake.
Really interresting round this one, really feel annoyed that i didn't get my submission done on time, but c'est le vie, anyways, really like a lot of the entries, people have really done an awesome job of making entries this time around =) especially loving the hunger in the dark and so it seems that the judges do aswell =)
Would like to throw in a HM for another of my favorites, namely that Damned Drake, really like the originality and the story on that one =)
I want to throw an Honorable Mention vote in for Kharamin Sandiga.
Excellent work all around and thanks to the judges who took the time for the mammoth judging.
I give an HM to Pumpkinhead just because I like the concept.
I'm inclined to agree with OMG's reasoning in this matter, but inclined to be grouchy about the way it was brought up. By leaving our PM out of the thread until another judge disagreed with the reasoning, it came across as gotcha gaming, at best, because rather than fostering debate before the judges spoke, it reads as "I'm right, you're wrong." That's not a healthy position for a judgment based on opinion to hold, in my opinion (hooray for irony, I know).
If a judge is swayed by the listed reasoning OMG gave, that's all well and good. If a judge is instead swayed by dextercorvia's logic and reasoning, so be it. It's been said several times that the reason we have multiple judges is to garner several differences of opinion, after all.
well, 5 minutes till the reveal, I think that we can assume the other judges were scared off by the volume (can't blame them) bracing myself for the reveal. great competition this time around. :)
I'm sorry, but I was unable to complete my judging due to my life starting to get complicated a few days ago. I hate Thanksgiving...
It's time for the reveal! There was a three-way tie in votes for Honorable mention, which tells an awful lot about how good these entries were all around. I ended up using final standings to break the tie in that category. Well done to every contestant, and every judge.
1st Place: gbprime’s Sandamir, the Hunger in the Shadows!
2nd Place: Piggy Knowles’ Lucian the Wanderer!
3rd Place: Piggy Knowles’ Maxwell Allard, The Raven!
Honorable Mention: TheGeckoKing’s The Damned Drake!
Other entries:
The_Gilded_Duke’s Karn the Conqueror!
cd4’s The Dancing Shadow!
Venger’s Mr. Dini!
Grey_McBannert’s Osric the Fallen!
Hunter_Killer’s Ensis Tenebra!
flabort‘s Vesper!
nedz’ Artou Defoor!
ZipDing’s Domovoi, the Dark Dancer!
Kestrel404’s Lord Shady McUmbra!
Diefje’s Theodorus Johannes Kaczynski!
Venger’s Pumpkinhead!
The_Gilded_Duke’s Khariman Sandinga!
ZipDing’s Tiesa!
DonutBoy12321’s Athek!
IC Challenge XXVII will be up shortly.