General Exalted Discussion IV: Roll Join Debate

[Mr.Bookworm]

Would a theoretical Fu-Sion-Ha spell that functions exactly like Unity of the Closed Fist but with only a maximum of two participants be Terrestrial or Celestial circle? (Assuming that the casting cost was maybe scaled to 20m if it was Terrestrial and 30m for Celestial.)

Neither, because Unity of the Closed Fist is pretty broken and doesn't need another easier-to-get version?[/hasnotseenyourspell]

If you fix UotCF, then sure, but I don't know what that would look like.

Also, Protean, hell yeah.

Also, Celestial Monkey doubles your DV? Might have to expand the ban list a bit.

Tavar, if you ban every single thing in Exalted that could possibly be broken, we're not actually going to play Exalted. Exalted is a pretty inherently broken system, and overuse of the banhammer will result in both the ToS being not fun, and it not being representative of Exalted. In my opinion, it'd be better if you just ban the things in the system that are broken beyond repair, and allow the other stuff in.