Elves and fridgehorror in OotS

[FujinAkari]

Fact: The Giant said he won't tell us what gender V is.
Fact: The Giant is the only person IRL who knows V's gender.
Fact: The Giant can retcon V's gender if he feels like it.

Conclusion: This debate is pointless.

You must be new to the OOTS forums... pointless debate has never been an obstacle to their continuance :P

Seriously though, you're right. The Giant has now made V ambiguous and (s)he could go either way, but claiming that the INITIAL conception of V wasn't male is to ignore all available evidence. That (s)he started as a man is all but fact at this point.