Quote Originally Posted by Kosjsjach View Post
I think I really like the idea of Tumble vs the enemy attack bonus. Is there anything I'm missing that makes this unfair or non-viable?

(Also, tumbling fullplate dwarves are indeed cool.)
It's not necessarily a bad thing. It is in the method listed above that I take issue. It's in trying to combine a skill with AC, two items begging for people to break them. Yes, a natural 20 would still succeed on making a regular attack--obviously missing the critical confirm.

Another point mentioned was that it would slow down the game progress. The current skill roll has you attempting to make a set DC as you try and pass people. This means you roll 5 15's. Otherwise, you'd need to compare rolls to the attackers, slowing the game down.