Oh I didn't fault him for it...I was mostly banned because I always played the rogue..but to great effect, this scenario just showcased that to him. He wanted me to branch out to play other things. It wasn't my fault, really, no one else wanted to ever play the rogue and I lived further away so everyone else chose classes before I got there. So in each campaign that followed this one, I chose a completely different class each game. He allowed me to choose first. Good guy, too bad he moved away.