Quote Originally Posted by fallenwarrior View Post
Bag of rats covers hits and when you reduce a target to 0. As written, it says nothing at all about a PC taking damage. The only hit we're concerned about in the above situation is when the character hits an ally. If you apply bag of rats to that, to be consistent you need to apply bag of rats every time an ally is hit, because they don't represent a meaningful threat to the character. I don't think that's what the bag of rats rule intended, and I don't think it's a good thing for the game, either.

Instead, you can house rule it so that it includes the PC taking damage. At that point, you can bring up bag of rats when that happens, rather than on the hit.
Right, so what's the problem with applying BoR every time an ally is hit with the caveat of leniency when game elements that explicitly grant benefits from hitting allies (rather than 'creatures') feature, keeping in mind that BoR only features when a benefit is derived from attacking a target that poses no threat? Why is employing this caveat worse off than one that considers damage?