Quote Originally Posted by rgrekejin View Post
That you personally don't care about alignment does not in any way change the fact that it is a valid piece of character sheet data to pursue.
Again: I'm not trying to argue that he is or isn't evil, only restating Kurald's point that alignment, unlike feats and levels, is too wishy-washy a subject to nail down. It is in the FAQ for a reason, that reason being that long and painful experience in the forum is that there is never consensus.

rgrekejin, the point I'm trying to make is that there is a lot that can be said about Malack's actions and how a complex character fits in an inflexible reductionist alignment system. I would happily cheer any such discussion in this forum - I'm sure interesting insights can be reached. I just believe that the discussion should be held away from this thread, which is useful only as long as its conclusions are as ironclad as possible.

TL;DR: In theory, we should be able to figure it out alignments. In practice, we can't.

Grey Wolf