Vigilantism and the Lawful Alignment in OotS

[Porthos]

Especially once you consider the fact that the whole freaking book was about Redcloak and Right-Eye, as protagonists.

Which was the point I made in my prior post.

ETA to not double post:

All I'm saying is, taking some pastel shade of orange and saying "it's Red. Definitely Red" is going to invite disagreement from certain quarters.

Problem with this is, lots of people here don't agree with you about it being a shade of Orange.

Relatedly, people for years tried to claim that Belkar (v1.0 if we must) was anything other than Chaotic Evil.

Which is... amazing.

If people will argue in all seriousness over the alignment of someone like Belkar, I think trying to find unanimity over alignement discussion is pointless and fruitless.

Or to put it another way, if people can look at shade of color that Belkar was painted in and argue over it, how can one possibly conclude that they won't argue over characters with a bit more depth to them?