Vigilantism and the Lawful Alignment in OotS

[Porthos]

I am simply refusing to blur the distinction between Lawful and Chaotic methods to the point of being meaningless.

No, I think it is more that you insist on something being a Chaotic trait and very few people agreeing with you.

To paraphrase what you said earlier in the thread, you're painting something in a orange color and are puzzled why everyone disagrees with you calling it red.