Vigilantism and the Lawful Alignment in OotS

[warrl]

Kish, I think that because I have (A) pointed out that Tarquin commits many Chaotic acts

False. You've claimed it, repeatedly, but not shown it. You keep on bringing up the same specifics again, even after others have shown that those specifics do not support your case.

, and (B) that Lawful Stupid exists, and is still Lawful, you are jumping to the conclusion (C) that nothing exists between these extremes.

That's because every action that doesn't qualify as Lawful Stupid, you - and ONLY you - use as an example of a Chaotic action.

Deceit - officially, by D&D rules and real-world examples, NOT CHAOTIC, but you use it as proof that Tarquin is Chaotic.

Making war - I showed at some length how it is SOMETIMES Lawful, in the sense of advancing Law in general, but you still assert that it's automatically Chaotic.