The problem with Gone Home is that it was hyped as something it isn't. Indie horror games are becoming quite popular thanks to Youtubers and Gone Home isn't one, even though it portrays itself as one. So people who went in expecting a chilling atmosphere or scares were left disappointed - and the people who praise the game are predominantly fans of stuff like Dear Esther, which barely registers as a game for most people.

So if you think of video gaming's potential as some form of high brow entertainment, if you prefer style over substance, you'll probably like Gone Home. Otherwise it's a waste of time.