The Index Reloaded --- (Index of the Giant's Comments II)

[Kalmegil]

I vote yes to include the illusion quote.

Furthermore I vote yes to "just include quotes and stop voting on everything." Double-underlined, with an exclamation point.

I vote "no" on "drop the Index in favor of the Google search".

Technically, what was suggested was more like the old Yahoo curated index rather than a Google search. Even if we included every single thing the Giant said (which I am not advocating, though I do think concerns about "cluttering" the index are overblown), it would still be far more useful than a Google search, simply because of the organization and summary.