The Index Reloaded --- (Index of the Giant's Comments II)

[Gift Jeraff]

No

I am of the opinion that all this wrangling and voting is a deterrent to Rich's free communication. I wonder if he becomes less likely to share, knowing that every word will be dissected and debated and rated on its worthiness. (That probably happens anyway but there's no reason we must make it worse.) Include the quotes as a matter of course, if they are clearly OOTS-related and not redundant to other things in the Index.

Voting is an exercise in pre-emptively culling the Index for imagined future problems. I don't see the point. If in the future a real problem arises, deal with it then.

I agree.

He's basically already asked that the thread not do what you're proposing.

Moreover, ThePhantasm has already stated that he's not going to maintain a thread that amounts to adding every new post the Giant makes to an ever-increasing Index.

I agree with this, too.