The Index Reloaded --- (Index of the Giant's Comments II)

[Silver Swift]

Speaking of thread clutter - discussing whether a quote should be in the index is not clutter. I realize it can be tiring to see constant discussions going on, but again, this is a community project, and so everyone gets a say.

I am very much in agreement here, this thread shouldn't just serve to notify people whenever Rich post something, so the following should not be seen as a critique, but may I make the suggestion that when an argument drags on past a certain point (well past the point that voting is going to happen) that you can put a stop to the discussion until the vote happens. Otherwise I fear we may again be looking at discussions that drag on for weeks after everything meaningful has been said.