Is Roy's dad able to get into the LG heaven?

[Jay R]

I think youre missing my point here. How is it the fault of the deva's if they are not omniscient? If they cant foresee every single contingency in the history of existence that has been or will be.

I'm not missing your point. I'm saying it doesn't apply here.

That is certainly how you treat a courtroom, or a sports referee, or any other construct of fallible people. But if the measurement of Goodness is itself unjust, then it isn't measuring Goodness, just as a ruler which changes in size isn't measuring length.