I worry it runs into the same problem as Careless, where the lack of visible progress makes people lose interest. I think pulling off something like that would require more complicated mini-games and sidequests than just guessing and luck.

- - - Updated - - -

Like, a Pun-off minigame would be a blast, or Three-Person Mafia, or one where you have to try to rewrite song lyrics so the others can't recognize it.