Quote Originally Posted by Morrolan View Post
Sorry, but I find it hard to be more specific about this, because I've been struggling to understand counters. How is this:

Q: When, compared to the enemy's action, do counters occur? Does that depend on the counter, or is that always the same moment?


I'm asking this because some counters clearly state what happens, (such as Scarlet Throne's Scarlet Riposte) but others are a bit vague on the actions (Like Black Seraph's Vengeful Riposte), and I can't really find any general rulings on counters apart from the following:


But that doesn't say anything about when a counter happens. Before the enemy attack roll, between attack and damage roll, or after both? Let us say I am confused.
A: Well, I just answered this in post #112. In general, you make the counter after the attack is rolled, because as has been stated, a natural 20 is an automatic hit even against a counter. Some counters have different triggers though, so they will specify when they're used.