Perhaps there is no end point to this conversation.

Apparently Beheld is simply arguing RAW, not what should happen in real games.

And the RAW are dumb on multiple levels. It's very buggy code. The game crashes when you push on it. Especially against a dummy DM.

And wish is terrible RAW. No gp limit on magic items? WHY DID YOU DO THAT, WOTC? Open permission for the DM to interpret a wish in such a way to hurt the players? No limitation, even bad buggy limitation on wishing for more wishes? WOTC DGAF.

This entire conversation has no discernable endpoint because... schroedinger's circumstances.