Originally Posted by
Gallowglass
As is, I'd make it 3rd level. If you change the components from "V" to "V,S,DF" then I'd make it 2nd level.
Why are you trying to make it verbal only? It doesn't benefit from being V only on face, so I don't really understand it. IMO, making a spell with V only increases the calculation of spell worth, but for this spell it doesn't really benefit much for that increase.
With the "only lasts 1 round maximum" qualifier, I really want to make it 2nd or 1st. It consumes the caster's standard action in a combat to probably give an Ally a better than level appropriate heal. That probability can be guessed at by the caster if he's been paying attention to the last couple rounds of combat. But with you making it verbal only.... I gotta put it up a level for that. And I just don't see what it gains you. You can still be AoO.... so really, the benefit here is you can cast it if you are tied up and one of your gang is trying to fight your captors or so you just need silent spell metamagic to play the "can't tell I'm casting" game rather than still and silent.
This spell is rife for gaming the system, as you point out, and if the spell exists, its going to be gamed. "I am way hurt... I'm going to jump off that cliff over there."