Quote Originally Posted by Actana View Post
With that in mind, sounds like Montreal might be a better fit at least as far as the supernatural community goes. Wizards would likely be drawn more to the traditionalism rather than technological innovation, and the various supernatural creatures and organizations thereof also are steeped in tradition. Montreal also has a bit better conflict going on with its identity than Boston, the latter's feels a bit vague to me. I like the island too, it certainly allows for potential.

That said, the two are still (relatively) close to each other. There's no reason you couldn't use both in the same game, with something of a supernatural rivalry between the two cities and their ideologies.
True on the proximity

I like Boston for the fact it draws a strong culture of faeries, young wizards(especially those from wizarding bloodlines), and minor talents.
But yeah Montreal looks better as a city with threats well Boston is better for a city built around themes.