Quote Originally Posted by Jasdoif View Post
Evidence that the Blood Oath of Vengeance kept Eugene out of the afterlife, sure.

The problem is that the interviewer said he didn't see anything too serious on the record, and then mentioned the Blood Oath. So either the Blood Oath didn't qualify as "too serious" for him, which would be a really hard argument to make since it kept Eugene out of the afterlife....or the earlier statement meant he hadn't seen anything too serious at that point. And in that case, assuming there was nothing else too serious on the record is speculation, to the same extent that assuming that there was something else too serious on the record is. There's simply nothing there to support a conclusion beyond "the Blood Oath is the first matter the interviewer saw that was worth drawing attention to".
Or option 3, he was looking for "evil/chaotic acts," of which the Blood Oath was neither. After all, he started the discussion by saying "there are black marks on your record, let's take a look." The fact that he then references the Blood Oath as having a bog-standard "completion certificate" suggests that such Oaths are not inherent barriers to Celestia, but leaving them unfinished is.

So again, not saying your conclusion is impossible, but I'm sticking with mine all the same, thanks.